Meditation Over Worry: Finding Peace In A Noisy Mind

Meditation is often touted as a cure-all, but it can be difficult for people with anxiety to practice. While it can help reduce stress and calm panic attacks, meditation can also increase anxiety and, in some cases, lead to panic attacks. This is because meditation increases awareness of physical sensations, which can be interpreted as threatening by people with anxiety. However, meditation has been practised for thousands of years and is known to have many health benefits, including reduced stress, improved memory, enhanced willpower, better sleep, and lower blood pressure. So, how can we reconcile the benefits of meditation with the potential for increased anxiety?

Meditation can increase anxiety and panic attacks

Meditation is often touted as a cure-all for mental health issues, but it can sometimes have the opposite effect. While it can be an effective tool for managing anxiety, it is not a cure-all and can even make symptoms worse in some cases.

The Benefits of Meditation

Meditation has been shown to be an effective tool for reducing anxiety and panic attacks. Mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) is a well-known technique that involves focusing on the breath and practising non-judgment. This practice can help people become more aware of their thoughts and feelings, allowing them to observe them without reacting. This can lead to greater emotional regulation and a reduction in anxiety symptoms.

The Drawbacks of Meditation

However, meditation is not always beneficial and can sometimes increase feelings of anxiety. This is because meditation increases activity in the parts of the brain responsible for focus and attention. While this can lead to improved focus and alertness, it can also result in increased anxiety and insomnia if taken too far. In addition, some people may become overly focused on their physical sensations during meditation, such as their heartbeat or pulse, which can trigger anxiety or panic attacks.

Who is at Risk?

Anyone who meditates is at risk of experiencing increased anxiety or panic attacks. Research suggests that at least 25% of regular meditators have experienced adverse effects, including panic attacks and depression. However, this risk can be mitigated by being aware of the potential drawbacks and knowing when to stop or switch to a different technique.

Alternative Techniques

If you find that traditional meditation techniques are triggering anxiety or panic attacks, there are alternative techniques that may be more effective for you. These include focusing on things outside your body, such as flowers or a poem, or practising techniques that encourage compassion and perspective-taking. It is important to find the technique that works best for you and to be mindful of how your practice is affecting your mental health.

While meditation can be a powerful tool for managing anxiety, it is not a cure-all and should be approached with caution. It is important to be aware of the potential risks and to know when to stop or try a different technique. By practising mindfulness in a safe and informed way, you can reap the benefits without exacerbating anxiety or panic attacks.

It can worsen pre-existing mental health issues

Meditation can be a powerful tool for managing anxiety, but it's not a cure-all, and in some cases, it may even worsen pre-existing mental health issues. While meditation is often touted as a solution to stress and anxiety, research shows that it is possible to take it too far, and that it may not be suitable for everyone.

For some people, meditation can increase feelings of anxiety rather than reduce them. This is because meditation practices often involve focusing on bodily sensations and becoming more aware of physical sensations, such as an increased heartbeat or breathing difficulties. For individuals with anxiety disorders, this heightened focus on physical sensations can trigger panic attacks or increase feelings of anxiety.

In addition, meditation practices that encourage observing thoughts and feelings without reacting or judging can be challenging for people with anxiety. Instead of calming anxious thoughts, this practice may lead to a heightened focus on negative thoughts and feelings, making them more overwhelming.

Furthermore, meditation can also bring up unpleasant memories and feelings of failure or hopelessness, which can exacerbate existing mental health issues. This is particularly common among individuals with acute anxiety or a history of trauma. The intention behind mindfulness meditation, which is often to "let go" or "accept" difficult thoughts and emotions, can feel inaccessible or condescending to those struggling with anxiety.

Finally, the pressure to "make anxiety go away" through meditation can lead to self-criticism and a sense of failure when anxiety persists. This sense of failure can worsen pre-existing mental health issues and create a negative feedback loop that reinforces anxiety and negative self-talk.

Meditation is not a cure-all

Meditation has been practised for thousands of years in Hindu, Buddhist, Zen/Chan and Taoist communities. Today, it is often used to help people cope with stress and worry in a busy world. It can bring calm and insight to those who often feel anxious.

Meditation is a set of techniques to enhance attention, emotional awareness, kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy, and mental calmness, even in difficult situations. Research has documented many health benefits of regular meditation practice, including reduced stress, improved memory, increased attention, enhanced willpower, better sleep, less pain, lower blood pressure, less anxiety, less depression, and greater compassion.

However, it is important to remember that meditation is not a cure-all. While it can be an effective tool for managing anxiety, it is not a cure for acute anxiety or other mental health disorders. In some cases, meditation can even make feelings of anxiety worse.

For people with high levels of anxiety, a basic meditation practice can be challenging. Mindfulness instructions often suggest that practitioners focus on their bodily sensations and "let go of judgment". This can be daunting for those whose anxiety is regularly at fever pitch. The intention behind meditation is to gradually open up to experiences and cultivate self-compassion, rather than suddenly damming up the flow of thoughts and emotions.

Additionally, it is important to recognize that meditation is not a replacement for medical treatment or therapy. While it can be a helpful adjunctive treatment, it should not be relied upon as the sole means of managing mental health issues.

Furthermore, the benefits of meditation are not always immediate. It takes time and practice to develop the skills needed to calm the mind and improve mental health. It is also important to find the right type of meditation and the correct "dose" for your particular situation. What works for one person may not work for another, so it is essential to be patient and experiment with different techniques.

Finally, too much meditation can have negative consequences. Spending too much time in mindful contemplation can interfere with sleep and even increase feelings of anxiety and panic. It is important to find a balance and not become overly reliant on meditation as the only tool for managing stress and anxiety.

In conclusion, while meditation can be a powerful tool for improving mental health and reducing anxiety, it is not a cure-all. It should be used in conjunction with other strategies and under the guidance of a qualified instructor or mental health professional.

It can be difficult to practice for those with acute anxiety

It can be difficult to practice meditation for those with acute anxiety

Meditation is often touted as a solution to stress and anxiety. While it can be an effective tool for many, it can be difficult to practice for those with acute anxiety. For people whose anxiety boxes them in, a basic meditation practice isn't always straightforward.

The challenges of meditation with acute anxiety

Those with acute anxiety may find it challenging to follow common meditation instructions, such as focusing on bodily sensations or "letting go of judgment." The intention behind these instructions is to help practitioners observe their thoughts and feelings without reacting or judging them. However, for those with high anxiety, this can be daunting and feel inaccessible.

Acute anxiety can also make it difficult to achieve the state of non-judgmental awareness that meditation aims for. The very presence of anxiety can trigger self-criticism and negative self-talk, hindering the intended benefits of the practice.

Overcoming the challenges

It is important to approach meditation with a revised perspective and intention. Instead of focusing solely on reducing suffering, view meditation as a process of gradually opening up to your experiences. This can help take the pressure off and reduce self-criticism if immediate relief is not achieved.

Embedding self-compassion or self-directed kindness into your meditation practice can also make it more accessible. Recognizing and validating the urgency of your suffering is an important step.

A structured practice for high anxiety

• Sit upright in a comfortable position. You can keep your eyes open or closed, whichever feels more comfortable.
• Acknowledge the reality of your anxiety by saying something like, "I've suffered a great deal. This pain is real and intense." Repeat this phrase quietly to yourself a few times.
• Focus your attention on a single breath, feeling the air coming in and leaving your body.
• Repeat the phrase "In this pain, I'm caring for myself."
• Expand your focus to two full cycles of breath, observing the sensations of the air coming in and going out.
• Add a self-compassion anchor, such as "This is hard, and right now I'm giving myself permission to understand that."
• Continue to expand your focus to three to five cycles of breath.
• Say to yourself, "Though the pain continues, may my practice and care for myself continue as well."
• Let self-compassion anchor your meditation practice, using it as a scaffold to stand in self-acceptance and disarm any inner criticism or feelings of failure.

Meditation requires discipline and skill

Meditation is a set of techniques that enhance attention, emotional awareness, and mental calmness, even in difficult situations. It is a process of learning to trust and stay with feelings of discomfort, rather than trying to escape or analyse them. It is a process of becoming more aware and letting go.

Meditation requires discipline in that it is a practice that must be done regularly to be effective. It is a commitment to taking time to be present and to go inside one's own life. It requires discipline to stay focused on the breath and to keep bringing the attention back to the breath when the mind wanders.

Meditation also requires skill. It is a skill to be able to observe the mind and thoughts as passing mental phenomena, like clouds in the sky. It is a skill to be able to observe without judgement, and to be aware of the present moment without getting caught up in it. It is a skill to be able to create space between oneself and what is being experienced, so that anxiety can soften.

Meditation is a practice that can be learned and developed over time. It requires discipline and skill, but it is a powerful tool for enhancing attention, emotional awareness, and mental calmness.

Frequently asked questions