Meditation's Dark Side: Exploring Evil In Spiritual Practice

Meditation has been a topic of debate among Christians, with some believing that it can be a pathway to evil or demonic forces. This notion stems from the association of meditation with eastern religions and philosophies, which may conflict with Christian doctrine. However, others argue that Christian meditation, or contemplative prayer, is a legitimate practice with a rich history in Christianity, and that it can bring one closer to God. While some Christians fear that meditation may open one's mind to evil spirits or leave one vulnerable to the devil, proponents of Christian meditation assert that the presence of God in their practice prevents any darkness from entering.

Meditation can lead to encounters with evil presences or forces of darkness

Meditation has been practised by humans for millennia, with Buddhists, Hindus, believers in transcendental meditation, atheists, and Christians all partaking in it. However, the intentions and methods of meditation differ across these groups.

For example, some Christians believe that meditation can lead to encounters with evil presences or forces of darkness. This belief stems from the idea that meditation, particularly non-Christian meditation, can leave one's mind empty and susceptible to being filled by the devil or evil spirits. This notion is encapsulated in the proverb, "An idle mind is the devil's workshop."

However, it is important to note that not all Christians share this view. Some Christians argue that when one approaches God with the intention to savour quiet time with Him, there is no room for the devil or evil spirits. They believe that their surrender of time and intention to God acts as a protective force against evil influences.

Additionally, some Christians differentiate between Christian meditation and non-Christian meditation. They argue that while non-Christian meditation focuses on losing oneself and feeling a oneness with everything, Christian meditation should strive to push oneself towards wisdom and the love of God. They believe that non-Christian meditation denies the central Christian doctrine of the need for Jesus Christ as a mediator between mankind and God.

Despite these differing views, it is clear that the perception of meditation as a potential encounter with evil forces stems from a Christian perspective. This perspective is influenced by the association of meditation with eastern religions and philosophies, which some Christians consider to be a valid reason to avoid it.

It is worth noting that the perception of meditation as a pathway to evil encounters is not universally accepted, even within Christian circles.

It is associated with eastern religions, which some Christians are wary of

Meditation has been practised by humans for millennia, and it is performed by people of various faiths, including Buddhists, Hindus, believers in transcendental meditation (TM), atheists, and Christians. However, the way it is practised and the intentions behind it differ between these groups.

Christian meditation often involves spiritual reading or discursive meditation, such as deep reflection on spiritual writing or the life of Jesus. This type of meditation is meant to engage thought, imagination, and feelings. Examples include lectio divina or praying the rosary. Another form of Christian meditation is quiet receptive prayer without words, thoughts, or feelings, which is practised to help experience and respond to the presence of God. This form of meditation is often referred to as "contemplation".

Meditation is also commonly associated with eastern religions, and some Christians are wary of this practice due to its origins in non-Christian traditions. For instance, the utterance "Om" is significant in Dharmic religions, and some Christians may be uncomfortable with the influence of these practices. While some Christians view meditation as a way to meet God and be filled with light and love, others worry that it could open one's mind to the devil and evil spirits. They believe that an empty mind can easily be filled by evil thoughts and influences.

However, some Christians argue that when one approaches God with the intention to savour quiet time with Him, there is no room for the devil or evil spirits. They believe that the presence of God repels evil and that their surrender of time to God through meditation opens themselves up to Him and pushes away evil influences.

Some Christians believe meditation empties the mind, leaving it vulnerable to the devil

Some Christians believe that meditation is evil because it empties the mind, creating a void that can be filled by the devil. This belief is based on the idea that an idle mind is vulnerable to evil influences, as suggested in the Hand-Book of Proverbs (1855): "An idle mind is the devil's workshop".

However, not all Christians share this view. Some argue that when one approaches God with the intention to spend quiet time with Him, there is no room for the devil. They believe that the presence of God and the devil cannot coexist, and that meditation can be a way to meet God and be filled with light and love. This is supported by the Psalm 46:10, "Be still and know I am God", which indicates that by being still, one can know God.

Furthermore, some Christians differentiate between non-Christian and Christian meditation practices. They argue that non-Christian meditation focuses on losing the self and feeling oneness with everything, which contradicts the Christian doctrine of the gulf between mankind and God. In contrast, Christian meditation should strive to push the self towards wisdom and the love of God, filling the mind with God's word rather than emptying it.

Additionally, some Christians acknowledge the benefits of meditation for health and well-being, supported by scientific research. They view meditation as a form of prayer, such as lectio divina or praying the rosary, which involves deep reflection on spiritual writing or the life of Jesus. This type of meditation has been practised by Christians for millennia and is mentioned in the Bible.

While there are differing views among Christians regarding the nature and risks of meditation, it is clear that many Christians do not consider it to be inherently evil. Instead, they see it as a valuable tool for enhancing their relationship with God and improving their overall well-being.

Non-Christian meditation focuses on oneness, denying the Christian doctrine of the gulf between God and mankind

Meditation has been practised by humans for millennia, with Buddhists, Hindus, believers in transcendental meditation, atheists, and Christians all engaging in the practice. However, the methods and intentions behind meditation can vary between different groups.

Christian meditation often involves spiritual reading or discursive meditation, with prayer practices that involve deep reflection on spiritual writing or the life of Jesus. This can include lectio divina or praying the rosary. Another form of Christian meditation is quiet receptive prayer without words, thoughts, or feelings, which is practised to help experience and respond to the presence of God. This is sometimes referred to as contemplation or Centering Prayer.

Non-Christian meditation, on the other hand, often focuses on the oneness of everything, which is not in line with central Christian doctrine. Christian doctrine emphasises the gulf between God and mankind, which also highlights the need for Jesus Christ as a mediator. While non-Christian meditation aims to lose the self entirely, Christian meditation should instead push the self towards wisdom and the love of God.

Additionally, some non-Christian meditation traditions place euphoric feelings as the ultimate goal of meditation. However, Christians are cautioned against seeking dopamine highs, and instead encouraged to seek wisdom and understanding in their meditation practices, rather than becoming slaves to emotions.

Some types of meditation aim to deconstruct the individual and their connection to reality

Some types of meditation have been criticised for their focus on deconstructing the individual and their connection to reality. This characterisation is often applied to meditation practices from the 'Far East', including those of Buddhists, Hindus, and Jains.

This interpretation stems from a perception that the goal of these Eastern practices is to "deconstruct the individual and [lose] all connections to reality". In other words, to erase a person's sense of self and their understanding of the world. This characterisation is disputed by some, who argue that the point of such meditation is, in fact, to "fully understand and awaken to reality".

In contrast, Western meditation practices are viewed as more individualistic. For example, Christian meditation often involves deep reflection on spiritual writing or the life of Jesus, or a quiet prayer without words, thoughts, or feelings, with the intention of experiencing and responding to the presence of God.

Frequently asked questions