Meditation: Sinful Or Spiritual? Understanding The Stigma

Meditation is a practice that has been scientifically proven to reduce stress, anxiety, and depression, increase focus, and cultivate kindness and compassion. However, some Christians associate meditation with Eastern religions such as Buddhism and Hinduism, and therefore consider it a sin. This is because these religions do not believe in God or believe in multiple gods, which goes against the First Commandment: Thou shalt have no other gods before me. Additionally, some Christians believe that meditation involves emptying the mind, which goes against the Bible's instruction to be sober-minded and alert. However, others argue that meditation is not inherently sinful and can even be beneficial for Christians, as it helps them focus solely on God and deepen their relationship with Him.

Meditation is associated with Eastern religions, such as Buddhism and Hinduism

Meditation is often associated with Eastern religions, such as Buddhism and Hinduism, and their respective practices. This association has led to some Christians questioning whether meditation is a sin.

In the religious traditions of Asia, meditation has been developed to a high degree of sophistication and complexity, especially in Buddhism. Meditation is so central to Buddhism that many people think of it as a Buddhist practice. Buddhist meditation practices include breathing exercises, focusing on certain symbols, sacred sounds or mantras, and visualising death or the decomposition of a corpse.

Hinduism's central texts, including the Upanishads and the Bhagadva-Gita, also refer to meditation, and it is often encountered as part of a more general practice of yoga. In the Yoga Sutras of Patanjali, meditation techniques are basically indistinguishable from the practice of yoga.

The reasons for the difference between Western and Asiatic meditation may be due to the greater emphasis that Western religions place on an individual's personal relationship with God. Asiatic meditation, on the other hand, tends to emphasise technical traditions, such as reciting sounds without content or visualising geometrical figures.

The First Commandment states: Thou shalt have no other gods before me

The First Commandment, "Thou shalt have no other gods before me", is one of the Ten Commandments, a set of religious and ethical directives given by God to Moses, according to the Hebrew Bible. These commandments form the basis of Jewish law and are considered to have divine authority by most Christian traditions.

The First Commandment prohibits the worship of any other gods before Yahweh, the God of Israel. This commandment is primarily directed at polytheistic religions, such as Hinduism, which believe in multiple gods. By forbidding the worship of other gods, the commandment also establishes Yahweh as the one true God, demanding exclusive devotion and obedience from his followers.

The commandment has been interpreted in various ways by different religious traditions. For example, the Eastern Orthodox Church includes a recitation of the Ten Commandments at the beginning of confession, while Baptist Christians view the commandments as a summary of the requirements of a works covenant between God and humanity.

In the context of the question "Is meditation a sin?", some Christians may view certain forms of meditation as conflicting with the First Commandment. Meditation is often associated with Eastern religions such as Buddhism and Hinduism, which are polytheistic. Therefore, Christians who practice meditation may be seen as engaging in an activity that violates the First Commandment by giving precedence to other gods or religious practices.

However, it is important to note that not all forms of meditation are the same. Biblical meditation, as described in the Bible, involves focusing one's mind on God and His Word, deepening one's relationship with God, and growing in one's understanding of His truth. This type of meditation is considered a valuable practice by many Christians and is distinct from Eastern meditation, which often involves emptying the mind of all thoughts.

In conclusion, while some Christians may view meditation with skepticism due to its association with Eastern religions and the potential conflict with the First Commandment, others distinguish between Eastern and Biblical meditation, finding the latter to be a beneficial spiritual practice that draws them closer to God.

Biblical meditation focuses on God and His Word, whereas Eastern meditation involves emptying the mind

Some Christians worry about the act of meditation because of its association with New Age practices and eastern religions. However, meditation is not inherently sinful or anti-Christian. In fact, the Bible mentions meditation many times, and Jesus himself could be seen as an example of someone who meditated deeply on God's word.

Biblical meditation is a spiritual exercise focused on Scripture. It involves quieting the heart and contemplating certain verses, asking what they mean for one's life and situation, and what they reveal about God. It can include prayer, Bible memory, and reading.

Eastern meditation, on the other hand, often involves "emptying the mind" and chanting certain phrases repetitively. It is often associated with New Age practices and eastern religions such as Buddhism and Hinduism. This type of meditation can be seen as sinful from a Christian perspective because it does not focus on God or His Word, and may include elements that conflict with Christian beliefs. For example, some forms of eastern meditation use mantras or focus on achieving a state of ecstasy, which could be seen as conflicting with the Christian idea of "sober-mindedness" and the warning against "vain repetitions" in Matthew 6:7.

Biblical meditation, therefore, focuses on God and His Word, while Eastern meditation involves emptying the mind and may include elements that conflict with Christian beliefs. It is important for Christians who wish to meditate to ensure that their practice is rooted in Christ and does not veer into sinful territory.

Some Christians believe that meditation is sinful if it does not focus on God

Biblical meditation, on the other hand, involves focusing one's mind on God and His Word, deepening one's relationship with God, and growing in one's understanding of His truth. This can be achieved by reading and reflecting on Scripture, memorizing Scripture passages, and using meditation journals, among other methods.

Some Christians express concern about the act of meditation due to its portrayal in Hollywood and the media, often associating it with Eastern religions. However, Christian meditation or Christ-centered meditation is about surrendering the soul to go deeper into the heart where Christ's Spirit dwells. It is a way to experience and awaken to the transformational teachings of Jesus and to know spiritual truths.

The Bible mentions "meditate" or "meditation" several times, with the Psalms containing the most uses of these words. For example, Joshua 1:8 says, "Keep this Book of the Law always on your lips; meditate on it day and night, so that you may be careful to do everything written in it." This encourages Christians to meditate on God's Word and deepen their relationship with Him.

Meditation can be seen as a form of worship, which should be reserved for God

Meditation can be seen as a form of worship, and as such, it should be reserved for God. This view is particularly prevalent among Christians, who often associate meditation with New Age practices and eastern religions, such as Buddhism and Hinduism. The First Commandment in the Bible states, "Thou shalt have no other gods before me," which some Christians interpret as a prohibition against the practice of meditation as it is often associated with non-Christian religions.

However, it is important to note that meditation is mentioned in the Bible in several places, indicating that it is not inherently sinful or incompatible with Christianity. The Bible uses the word "meditate" or "meditation" multiple times, particularly in the Psalms. In the Old Testament, the Hebrew word for "meditate" is "hāgāh," which means to ponder, muse, or reflect. In the New Testament, the Greek word for "meditate" is "meletān," which means to study, think about, or consider.

Biblical meditation is not the same as Eastern meditation. Eastern meditation often involves emptying the mind of all thoughts, while biblical meditation focuses on God and His Word. Christians who meditate in a biblical way seek to deepen their relationship with God and grow in their understanding of His truth. They may read and reflect on Scripture, memorise Scripture passages, or use a meditation journal to record their thoughts and insights. By meditating on God's Word, Christians can transform their minds and hearts, reducing stress and anxiety and increasing their compassion for others.

While some Christians may view meditation as sinful due to its association with other religions, others argue that it is not the act of meditation itself that is sinful, but rather the intention and focus of the meditation. As long as the goal and focus of the meditation are on God, it can be a beneficial and transformative practice for Christians.

Frequently asked questions