Understanding The Bishop's Unique Power Of Forgiveness

The question of whether a bishop or a priest can forgive sins is a contentious one, with different interpretations in different religions. In the Catholic Church, it is believed that priests have the power to forgive sins as they are acting in the person of Christ and have been given the authority to do so by Jesus himself. However, some argue that this is not explicitly stated in the Bible and that only God can forgive sins. In Eastern Orthodox Christianity, while bishops and priests can forgive sins, it is believed that they do not act in the person of Christ and that God forgives sins through them. In this view, the bishop or priest is seen as a medium or translator between God and humans. Ultimately, the question of whether a bishop or priest can forgive sins depends on the specific religious context and interpretation.

Only God forgives sins, but he does it through bishops

While it is true that only God can forgive sins, the Bible does indicate that Jesus has the authority to forgive sins. In Mark 2:1–12, Jesus heals a paralytic and forgives his sins. The scribes object, asking, "Who can forgive sins except God alone?". Jesus responds by performing a miracle to demonstrate "that the Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive sins".

In John 20:19–23, Jesus passes this authority on to his apostles: "If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained".

However, it is important to note that the ability to forgive sins is not the same as having the authority to do so. A priest can confer or convey the forgiveness of God through the power of the Holy Spirit but not by their own power.

In the Catholic Church, certain sins are considered canonical "crimes" and thus carry canonical penalties that need to be lifted by a bishop or, in some cases, the pope. These include apostasy, heresy, schism, violation of consecrated species, physical attack on a pope or bishop, and unauthorized ordination of a bishop, among others.

Bishops have the authority to forgive sins on God's behalf

In the Bible, Jesus says to the apostles, "If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained" (John 20:23). This passage demonstrates that Jesus gave the apostles the authority to forgive sins on His behalf.

Additionally, in the epistle of James, there is a passage about going to the elders of the church (presbyters/priests) for healing and forgiveness: "Is any among you sick? Let him call for the elders of the church, and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord; and the prayer of faith will save the sick man, and the Lord will raise him up; and if he has committed sins, he will be forgiven" (James 5:14-15). This passage provides an example of how Christ's forgiveness is extended to those who have sinned after Baptism.

Bishops are part of the apostolic succession and are thus authorized by Jesus to forgive sins. They act as intermediaries between God and humans, conveying God's forgiveness to those who confess their sins.

However, it is important to note that not all sins can be forgiven by any bishop. Certain sins, such as abortion, apostasy, heresy, schism, and physical attack on a pope or bishop, are considered canonical "crimes" and require the lifting of canonical penalties, which may be reserved for the pope or a higher authority.

While bishops have the authority to forgive sins, it is crucial to understand that they are not infallible and are also susceptible to sin. They are chosen by the church and are not appointed directly by God. Therefore, while they play a crucial role in guiding and forgiving parishioners, they are not equal to God and cannot replace God's authority.

Bishops can forgive sins but cannot replace God

Bishops and priests can forgive sins, but they cannot replace God. While it is true that certain sins are considered canonical "crimes" and require canonical penalties to be lifted, it is important to understand that only God has the ultimate authority to forgive sins. In the Bible, it is written, "You're absolutely right. Only God can forgive sins" (Mark 2:1–12). This power of forgiveness is inherent in God's nature as the Creator and Holy One, separate from the imperfections of humanity.

The ability of bishops and priests to forgive sins stems from the authority given to them by God. In John 20:23, Jesus says to his disciples, "If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained." This passage indicates that Jesus bestowed upon his followers the power to forgive sins on His behalf. This authority was passed down through the generations in a practice known as apostolic succession, where the apostles laid hands on their successors, who then continued this tradition.

However, it is crucial to recognize that the power to forgive sins does not originate from the bishops or priests themselves but is derived from Christ. They are acting as intermediaries or "translators" between God and humanity. As such, they are not infallible and are subject to the same sinful nature as the rest of humanity. They are not exempt from committing sins and seeking forgiveness from their fellow clergy members.

While bishops and priests play a vital role in guiding and leading parishioners, their position does not elevate them to the level of God. They are human beings who have been corrupted by sin, just like everyone else. Their role is to facilitate the process of confession and provide pastoral advice, but the act of forgiveness ultimately comes from God alone.

In conclusion, while bishops and priests have been granted the authority to forgive sins, they are not a replacement for God. Their role is to act as conduits of God's forgiveness and to guide people towards spiritual growth and a closer relationship with God.

Bishops are not appointed by God

While priests and bishops are believed to have the power to forgive sins on God's behalf, they are not appointed by God. Bishops and priests are selected from within the church or are seminary graduates. They are not chosen by God, nor are they mentioned in the Bible as having the power to forgive sins.

In the Bible, God personally designates those He chooses to do His work. For example, Moses was chosen by God to lead the Israelites out of Egypt, as mentioned in Exodus 3:7–10. Similarly, Peter was chosen by God and given the "keys to the heavenly kingdom" and the authority to "forgive people's sins." However, there is no mention of God passing on this authority to the Pope, cardinals, bishops, or priests.

The Catholic Church's hierarchy, including the Pope, cardinals, bishops, and priests, is not established by God but by later generations. The power to forgive sins is reserved for God, as sins are offenses committed against Him. While priests and bishops can guide and advise, they are not appointed by God and cannot forgive sins on His behalf.

The power to forgive sins is given to the apostles, who were the first bishops, and they, in turn, pass on this authority to others. This is known as apostolic succession. However, it is important to note that not all sins can be forgiven by priests or bishops. Certain sins, such as abortion, apostasy, heresy, schism, and physical attacks on a pope or bishop, are considered canonical "crimes" and require the lifting of canonical penalties, which may be reserved for the Pope.

In conclusion, while priests and bishops play a crucial role in guiding and advising parishioners, they are not appointed by God and do not have the inherent authority to forgive sins on His behalf. Their role is to support and facilitate spiritual growth, but the power to forgive sins ultimately rests with God alone.

Bishops cannot forgive sins committed against God

In the Bible, sin is defined as a transgression of God's law (1 John 3:4; Romans 4:15). Sin is against God because it means violating God's prohibitive commands or omitting to practice His positive commands (James 4:17). Since God's law is a reflection of His holy nature, transgressing His law offends Him personally.

In Genesis 39:9, Joseph was tempted to commit adultery with Potiphar's wife. In resisting her, he said, "How then could I do such a wicked thing and sin against God?". Joseph's greater loyalty was to God and His laws. Similarly, in 2 Samuel 11, David said something similar after he had sinned with Bathsheba. When confronted with his sin, David repented in great sorrow, saying to God, "Against You and You only have I sinned" (Psalm 51:4).

Sin is a perversion of God's perfect design. We were created to be mirrors of God's glory (Ephesians 2:10; 4:24; Hebrews 2:7). Sin is a big smudge on the mirror, diminishing the beauty and holiness we were designed to reflect. When we sin, we step outside the purpose for which we were created, violating God's moral law, and are accountable to Him for the trespass.

Therefore, only God can forgive sins committed against Him. While bishops can forgive sins, they are not appointed by God and cannot forgive sins committed against God.

Frequently asked questions