Prayer Vs Meditation: Exploring Their Unique Differences

Prayer is an important activity in Christianity, and there are several different forms used for this practice. The Church teaches that there are three major expressions (or forms) of prayer: vocal, meditation, and contemplation. Vocal prayer is the most common form, described by the Compendium of the Catholic Church as a prayer that associates the body with the interior prayer of the heart. Meditation is a higher form of prayer than vocal prayer as it uses the power of imagination with a focus on holy truths. Contemplative prayer, on the other hand, is a divinely infused prayer that is a gift from God, and a moment of pure faith.

Meditation is a human mode of prayer, while contemplation is divinely infused

The terms "meditation" and "contemplation" are often used interchangeably, but they represent distinct modes of prayer. Meditation is a human mode of prayer, while contemplation is divinely infused.

Meditation as a Human Mode of Prayer

Meditation is an exercise in which one actively engages in reflection and discourse with God. It involves the use of thoughts, images, and words to understand God's revelations and respond to His will. This form of prayer requires effort and concentration, often focusing on specific passages of Scripture or spiritual writings. The Catechism of the Catholic Church describes meditation as "an effort of thought and will, a dialogue of the mind with the Lord" and "a form of prayerful reflection, a questioning that expects to receive a personal response from the Lord."

Meditation, as a human endeavour, utilises human faculties such as imagination and thinking power. It is a structured attempt to reflect upon God's revelations and deepen one's understanding of Scripture, God's love, and our relationship with Him. This cognitive exercise can involve reading and pondering Scripture, seeking to comprehend the truths of faith and their application in our lives.

Contemplation as Divinely Infused Prayer

On the other hand, contemplation is a divinely infused prayer, often considered the most challenging form to achieve. In contemplative prayer, one seeks to empty themselves and allow God's presence and love to fill them, leading to a union with God. This state of union, or "one-ed-ness," as described by the 14th-century mystic Julian of Norwich, is a gift from God rather than something that can be attained through human effort alone.

Contemplation is a spontaneous activity of the spirit, where the action belongs to the Holy Spirit. It is a wordless prayer, an awareness of the Divine within, a deep communion with God. It is characterised by a calm quietness, where one's thoughts and words are rested, and one simply loves and responds to God's love.

Relationship Between Meditation and Contemplation

While meditation and contemplation are distinct, they are also interconnected. Meditation often serves as a foundation for contemplation. In St. Teresa of Avila's analogy, meditation corresponds to the First Water, where one actively engages in spiritual growth, while contemplation is the Second Water, where the labour is lessened as one receives God's grace. John of the Cross describes the difference as "the difference between working and enjoyment of the fruit of our work."

In summary, meditation is a human mode of prayer that involves active reflection and discourse with God, while contemplation is a divinely infused prayer where one empties oneself to be filled with God's presence and love, leading to a union with the Divine.

Meditation uses images, concepts and reasoning to commune with God

Meditation is a human mode of prayer that uses images, concepts and reasoning to commune with God. It is an exercise and a form of prayer in which one tries to understand God's revelation of the truths of faith and the purpose of the Christian life, and how it should be lived, in order to adhere and respond to what the Lord is asking. It is a cognitive exercise, a form of prayerful reflection, and an inner dialogue with God.

Meditation uses concepts and reasoning to commune with God. For example, the Catechism of the Catholic Church defines meditation as a form of prayer in which one tries to understand God's revelation. This involves the deliberate use of thoughts and concepts. Similarly, Mattá al-Miskīn, an Oriental Monk, describes meditation as an activity of the spirit, which involves exerting effort with one's thinking power.

Meditation also uses images to commune with God. For example, as noted by James Finley, meditation involves praying using thoughts and images. This is also reflected in the Hebrew translation of Joshua 1.8, which instructs believers to "meditate on [the book of law] day and night".

Meditation is an active process that requires concentration and effort. It is a form of prayer in which human effort is quite active, and it can offer only a remote knowledge of God. It is a foundational practice that prepares one for the contemplative life, which is a deeper form of prayer that goes beyond words, thoughts, and images.

Contemplation is a spontaneous activity of the spirit

While the terms "prayer", "meditation", and "contemplation" have been used loosely by the church over the past several centuries, they are distinct acts. Prayer, in its specific meaning, refers to asking or beseeching God for something. Meditation is a human mode of prayer that involves intent concentration on an object worthy of consideration, such as a passage of scripture. Contemplation, on the other hand, is a divinely infused prayer. It is a spontaneous activity of the spirit, a wordless prayer in which the mind and heart focus on God's greatness and goodness in affective, loving adoration.

Meditation is an active process that requires effort. It is a cognitive exercise in which one tries to understand God's revelation of the truths of faith and the purpose of the Christian life. It is a form of prayerful reflection, a discursive inner dialogue with God using thoughts and images. In contrast, contemplation is a passive process in which one rests in the presence of God beyond talking, thought, and images. It is a form of silent, wordless love and adoration of God, recognising that God comes to us in many ways, often at a level deeper than the threshold of our conscious awareness.

Meditation is an exercise in which the mind and imagination are actively employed to gain a deeper understanding of Scripture, God's love, and our relationship with God. It often involves the repetition of short phrases or passages from Scripture, such as "Lord Jesus, have mercy upon me, a sinner" or "Be still and know that I am God". The purpose of meditation is to offer devotion to God, obtain deep understanding, and find tranquility. Many who practice this form of prayer claim to reach a spiritual presence and union with God.

Contemplation, however, is generally considered the most difficult form of prayer to achieve. In contemplative prayer, one seeks to empty their being, allowing God to fill them with His presence and love, and become one with God. This state of union or "one-ed-ness" is elusive, and the more one strives for it, the further away it seems to get. Contemplatives have found that full union is a gift from God, not something achievable through their own efforts.

Meditation serves as a foundation for the contemplative life. John of the Cross states that one is ready to move from meditation to contemplation when they go to their place of prayer, open the Scriptures, and notice three things: they are no longer satisfied by discursive prayer and reflective meditation; they are not spiritually nurtured by anything else; and they have difficulty concentrating and staying focused on prayer and meditation. Thus, contemplation can be seen as a progression from meditation, a spontaneous activity of the spirit that relieves man of all effort and allows him to rest in God's infinite love.

Meditation is a foundation for the contemplative life

The terms "meditation" and "contemplation" are often used interchangeably, but they are distinct practices in the Christian tradition. Meditation is a human mode of prayer, a cognitive exercise in which we try to understand God's revelation of the truths of faith and how to live the Christian life. It is a foundational practice for the contemplative life.

In meditation, the mind, imagination, and other faculties are actively employed to gain a deeper understanding of Scripture, God's love, and our relationship with God. This can involve the repetition of short phrases or the reading of Scripture, with the goal of offering devotion to God, obtaining deep understanding, and finding tranquility.

Meditation is a practice that prepares one for contemplation, which is a divinely infused prayer. Contemplation is a form of wordless prayer in which the mind and heart focus on God's greatness and goodness in affective, loving adoration. It is a spontaneous activity of the spirit, where human effort is set aside, and one simply rests in God's infinite love.

While meditation involves active concentration and reflection, contemplation is a passive state of receptivity, where the focus is on experiencing God's presence and love. Contemplation is often described as a "gaze of faith" or a "silent love". It is a normal, common experience of the Christian life, open to all, and not reserved for a privileged few.

In summary, meditation is a foundational practice that prepares one for the contemplative life. It involves active concentration and reflection on Scripture, leading to a deeper understanding of God. Contemplation, on the other hand, is a divinely-infused, wordless prayer, where the focus is on experiencing God's love and presence, rather than intellectual understanding.

Contemplation is a normal common experience of the Christian life open to all

Contemplation is a normal and common experience in the Christian life, open to all. It is a divinely infused prayer, a gift from God, and not something that can be forced or achieved through human effort.

Contemplative prayer is a wordless prayer, where the mind and heart focus on God's greatness and goodness in affective, loving adoration. It is a spontaneous activity of the spirit, where one rests in the presence of God beyond talking, thought, and images. It is a silent gaze, a wordless love and adoration.

In contemplative prayer, the activity of the mind is curtailed, and one simply loves God and responds to God's love. It is a state of union with God, where one becomes one with God, and allows God's presence and love to fill them. This can be an elusive state to reach, as the more one tries to clear their head of thoughts, the more aware they become of those thoughts.

However, the practice of contemplative prayer is valuable in and of itself, as it provides an opportunity to re-centre and focus. Those who experience it describe overwhelming feelings of peace and love, and vivid images carrying deep meaning.

Contemplative prayer is a common experience in the Christian life, available to all, and not just a privilege for a select few. It is God's gift, and the faithful are invited to strive for it and be receptive to it.

Frequently asked questions