The Sea Of Faith: Arnold's Vision Explained

In his poem 'Dover Beach', Matthew Arnold uses the metaphor of a sea of faith to describe the loss of religious faith in the Victorian era. Arnold, writing in the context of the recent publication of Darwin's On the Origin of Species, reflects on the decline of religion and the rise of scientific discovery. The sea of faith was once full, but now it is withdrawing, leaving humanity without the protection and certainty it once provided. Arnold's speaker senses this change and feels that the world, despite its beauty, is filled with pain and suffering. The poem is an expression of alienation, doubt, and melancholy, and a precursor to 20th-century existentialist and absurdist crises of faith.

The Victorian conflict between science and religion

The Victorian Era witnessed a notable conflict between science and religion, with the publication of Darwin's "On the Origin of Species" in 1859 serving as a pivotal moment that intensified this tension. This intellectual clash had a profound impact on society, giving rise to a crisis of faith that was eloquently captured by the poet Matthew Arnold in his renowned work, "Dover Beach."

Arnold, a contemporary of Tennyson and Browning, is regarded as the third great Victorian poet. His poem "Dover Beach," written during his honeymoon in 1851 and published in 1867, reflects on the diminishing role of Christianity in the face of scientific advancements. The speaker in the poem senses this shift almost subconsciously, perceiving it in the sea that stretches before him.

The poem opens with a serene scene, where the moonlit sea appears calm and beautiful. However, as the poem progresses, Arnold employs the sea as a metaphor for the inevitable decline of humanity, stripping away the illusion of beauty and revealing the underlying danger. He compares the ebb and flow of the sea to the rise and fall of humanity, reflecting on how faith in humanity is being eroded by doubts and questions arising from scientific discoveries.

In the famous "Sea of Faith" stanza, Arnold laments the loss of religious faith that once dominated the world:

> "The Sea of Faith

> Was once, too, at the full, and round earth's shore

> Lay like the folds of a bright girdle furl'd;

> But now I only hear

> Its melancholy, long, withdrawing roar,

> Retreating, to the breath

> Of the night-wind, down the vast edges drear

> And naked shingles of the world."

Here, Arnold uses the image of the sea to symbolize religious faith, suggesting that it was once abundant and widely respected, just as the English Channel appears full and serene. However, in Victorian times, religious faith was increasingly challenged by the influences of materialism and scientific discoveries, leaving it engulfed in doubts and questioning.

The impact of this conflict between science and religion on Victorian society was profound. It led to a crisis of faith, with many individuals struggling to reconcile their religious beliefs with the emerging scientific explanations of the world. This tension is reflected in Arnold's poetry, particularly in "Dover Beach," where he presents a pessimistic outlook on the degradation of human life due to the loss of faith.

In conclusion, the Victorian conflict between science and religion had far-reaching consequences, shaping the intellectual and cultural landscape of the era. Matthew Arnold's poetry, especially "Dover Beach," captures this turmoil with remarkable foresight, expressing the alienation, doubt, and melancholy brought about by the waning influence of religion in an increasingly scientific age.

The decline of religious faith

In his poem, Arnold uses the image of the sea as a metaphor to describe the decline of faith. He compares the sea, which was once full and calm, to religious faith that was once strong and widely respected. However, just as the sea can become turbulent and destructive, Arnold observes that faith is being engulfed by doubts and questioning, retreating like the "melancholy, long, withdrawing roar" of the tide.

The speaker in the poem acknowledges the diminished standing of Christianity, recognising that it cannot withstand the rising tide of scientific discovery and intellectual inquiry. This crisis of faith is expressed through a sense of alienation, doubt, and melancholy, as the speaker grapples with the realisation that the world is not as beautiful as it once seemed.

The loss of faith is further emphasised in the poem's final stanza, where Arnold appeals to love as the only remaining value in a world devoid of joy, love, light, and peace. The lovers' vow is portrayed as a glimmer of hope in a world of broken faith.

Through his poem, Arnold captures the pessimism and criticism of his time, reflecting on the impact of scientific and intellectual advancements on religious faith. The "Sea of Faith" is withdrawing, leaving humanity on a "darkling plain" where "ignorant armies clash by night".

The comparison of the sea to faith

In his poem "Dover Beach", Matthew Arnold uses the image of the sea to symbolise religious faith. Arnold, who lived during the Victorian era, experienced a time of conflict between science and religion. The publication of Darwin's "On the Origin of Species" in 1859 caused a crisis of faith, with many people questioning their religious beliefs.

In the poem, Arnold describes the sea as calm and full, reflecting a time when religious faith was strong and widely respected. However, he also acknowledges the diminishing standing of Christianity, which he sees as being unable to withstand the rising tide of scientific discovery. The speaker in the poem senses this change, almost subconsciously, hearing it in the sea that he is looking out upon.

The speaker in the poem hears the grating roar of the waves, which brings the eternal note of sadness. This sound is compared to the turbid ebb and flow of human misery, reflecting the speaker's realisation that faith is not static but rather something that rises and falls, just as the tides do.

The image of the "Sea of Faith" retreating and withdrawing reflects the speaker's sense that religious faith is being engulfed by doubts and questioning. The once powerful sway of spiritual faith over people's minds is now giving way to the influences of materialism and science.

In conclusion, Arnold's comparison of the sea to faith serves as a powerful metaphor for the rise and fall of religious belief. The vastness and depth of the sea mirror the strength and reach of faith, while the ebb and flow of the tides symbolise the changing nature of human belief and understanding.

The pessimism of Arnold's reflection

The speaker in the poem senses the change in faith almost subconsciously, seeing and hearing it in the sea that he is looking out upon. The once-powerful "Sea of Faith" is now reduced to a "melancholy, long, withdrawing roar," retreating down the "vast edges drear." The speaker's perception of the world as a "land of dreams, so various, so beautiful, so new" is revealed to be an illusion. This realisation leads to a sense of existential crisis and despair.

Arnold's pessimism is further emphasised in the final stanza, where he calls for truth and loyalty between lovers, as the world offers no joy, love, or light. The speaker's appeal to love as the only remaining value in a world of broken faith underscores the depth of his pessimism.

The historical context of the Victorian Age, with its conflict between science and religion, also influences Arnold's reflection. The publication of Darwin's "Origin of Species" in 1859 had a significant impact on religious faith, creating doubts and questions that challenged traditional beliefs. Arnold's contemporary, William Butler Yeats, directly responds to Arnold's pessimism in his poem "The Nineteenth Century and After" (1929), acknowledging the "keen delight in what we have" despite the absence of the "great song."

In conclusion, Arnold's reflection in "Dover Beach" is characterised by a deep pessimism that stems from his observation of the decline of religious faith and the subsequent sense of alienation and loss. The speaker's appeal to love as a source of solace in a world devoid of meaning highlights the depth of his despair.

The crisis of faith

In his poem "Dover Beach," Matthew Arnold captures a crisis of faith, reflecting on the diminishing stature of Christianity in the face of advancing scientific discoveries. This internal conflict is emblematic of the broader conflict between science and religion that characterised the Victorian Age, a period of profound religious doubt and questioning.

Arnold's "Sea of Faith" metaphor poignantly conveys the idea that religious faith, once as vast and encompassing as the sea, is now receding like the ebbing tide. This powerful image underscores the sense of loss and uncertainty that permeates the poem. The speaker in the poem, gazing out at the tranquil sea, senses the changes in faith almost subconsciously, hearing them in the soft roar of the waves.

The Victorian Age witnessed a significant shift in religious faith due to the influences of materialism and scientific advancements, notably including the publication of Darwin's "On the Origin of Species" in 1859. These developments created a crisis of faith, causing many to question their long-held religious beliefs and the special role of humankind in the universe.

Arnold's poem, with its themes of alienation, doubt, and melancholy, is often seen as a precursor to 20th-century existentialist and absurdist philosophies. It is a profound exploration of what it means to be alive during a time of spiritual crisis. The speaker in the poem finds solace in personal values and the fundamental bond between lovers, urging faithfulness and truth in a world that seems devoid of joy, love, and light.

The "Sea of Faith" metaphor is a powerful expression of the speaker's sense of loss and the broader cultural shift away from religion. It captures the essence of a faith that once surrounded and sustained humanity, now withdrawing and leaving people adrift on a darkling plain.

Frequently asked questions