Understanding The Analogy Of Faith: A Theological Exploration

The analogy of faith is a biblical concept that refers to the interpretation of scripture. It is based on the idea that the Bible is a harmonious text with no contradictions, and as such, any interpretation of a passage must be consistent with the teachings found in other parts of the Bible. This principle, also known as the analogy of Scripture, guides Christians in understanding difficult or unclear passages by comparing them with clearer ones that address similar topics. The analogy of faith is not about individual verses interpreting each other, but rather about recognising the unity and harmony of the Bible's teachings as a whole.

The Analogy of Faith is a biblical phrase

The Analogy of Faith is associated with the one unchanging faith of the Church and is closely related to the notion of Tradition. It became a norm for the early Christian writers, who saw a "proportion" in the manner in which the New Testament complements the Old Testament, and in which each particular truth contributes to the inner unity of the entire Christian revelation.

The phrase came to indicate a rule or guide for the exegesis of Scripture, particularly in difficult texts where the teachings of tradition and the analogy of faith must be considered. The Catholic exegete, conscious of their faith, recognises the intimate relationship between Scripture and Tradition, striving to explain Scriptural passages in a way that does not set the sacred writers in opposition to one another or to the faith and teaching of the Church.

The Analogy of Faith is also referred to as the "Analogy of Scripture", a principle in hermeneutics which states that all scriptures exist in harmony, united without essential contradictions. Every proposed interpretation of any passage must be compared with what the other parts of the Bible teach. God speaks in the Scriptures as the supreme judge of all cases, and Scripture will inform Scripture as to its use of words, phrases, etc. The faith once entrusted to the saints is non-contradictory in this light.

The Analogy of Faith is not the principle that Scripture interprets Scripture, but that all Scripture is in agreement and will not contradict itself. It assumes the unity and harmony of teaching throughout the Bible. This means that when multiple passages speak about a topic, they will be consistent and not contradictory. For example, Psalm 34:15 speaks of God having eyes and ears, whereas John 4:24 says God is a spirit. The Analogy of Faith means these passages are not contradictory; in Psalm 34:15, the author is using a figure of speech, asserting that God watches over His people and hears their cries for help. In John 4:24, Jesus is asserting that God is not a physical being, therefore, the physical location of His worshippers is not what is most important to Him.

The Analogy of Faith also brings with it the idea that unclear passages should be interpreted in light of clear passages, not the other way around. Milton Terry, in 'Biblical Hermeneutics: A Treatise on the Interpretation of the Old and New Testaments', says that the expression analogy of faith "denotes that general harmony of fundamental doctrine which pervades the entire Scriptures.…No single statement or obscure passage of one book can be allowed to set aside a doctrine which is clearly established by many passages. The obscure texts must be interpreted in the light of those which are plain and positive."

It means all Scripture is in agreement and will not contradict itself

The analogy of faith is a biblical phrase that has always been associated with the "one unchanging faith" of the Church. It is closely related to the notion of Tradition and became a norm for early Christian writers. The analogy of faith is a rule or guide for the exegesis of Scripture, leading the way when teachings of tradition are unclear.

The analogy of faith is a reformed hermeneutical principle that states that all scriptures are in harmony and united, with no essential contradictions. This means that any interpretation of a passage must be compared with what the other parts of the Bible teach. The "faith" or body of doctrine that the scriptures proclaim will not be contradicted in any way by any passage.

For example, Psalm 34:15 speaks of God having eyes and ears, whereas John 4:24 says God is a spirit. The analogy of faith means these passages are not contradictory. In Psalm 34:15, the author is using a figure of speech, asserting that God watches over and hears his people. In John 4:24, Jesus is asserting that God is not a physical being. The analogy of faith forces us to dig further to understand how passages that appear contradictory should be understood.

The principle of the analogy of faith assumes the unity and harmony of teaching throughout the Bible. When multiple passages speak about a topic, they will be consistent and will not contradict each other. This is also known as the "analogy of Scripture".

It is a reformed hermeneutical principle

The "analogy of faith" is a reformed hermeneutical principle. It is based on the biblical phrase in Romans 12:6, which speaks of the "charism of prophecy" and the importance of following the "one faith" of the "one body in Christ". The principle of the analogy of faith is that all scriptures are harmoniously united, with no contradictions. Thus, any interpretation of a passage must be compared with the teachings of other parts of the Bible.

The analogy of faith is often misunderstood as meaning "Scripture interprets Scripture", or "Scripture interprets itself". However, this is not entirely accurate. While it is true that some passages of Scripture may be clarified by other passages, not all Scriptures are interpreted by another Scripture. For example, 1 Corinthians 15:29 mentions "baptism for the dead", which is not mentioned elsewhere in the Bible.

Instead, the analogy of faith asserts that all Scripture is in agreement and does not contradict itself. This means that when multiple passages speak about the same topic, their messages will be consistent and not contradictory. For instance, Psalm 34:15 and John 4:24 seem to present conflicting images of God, with the former depicting God as having eyes and ears, and the latter stating that God is a spirit. The analogy of faith encourages a deeper interpretation, recognising that in Psalm 34:15, the author uses figurative language to emphasise that God watches over and hears his people, while John 4:24 emphasises that God is not limited by physical location or form.

The analogy of faith also guides interpretation by suggesting that unclear passages should be interpreted in light of clearer ones, not the other way around. This means that when a passage is ambiguous or difficult to understand, other passages that address the same topic more clearly can be used to aid understanding.

The principle of the analogy of faith is a tool for interpreting Scripture, helping to ensure that interpretations are consistent with the overall teachings of the Bible and do not contradict essential doctrines. It is a valuable approach for understanding and reconciling seemingly contradictory passages, as well as for providing context and clarity to ambiguous verses.

It is not the same as the analogy of being

The analogy of faith is a biblical concept, with Romans 12:6 speaking of the "charism of prophecy" and other gifts such as "teaching" and "exhorting". The term "analogy" comes from the Greek word for "proportion", which was borrowed by philosophers to refer to the relationship between concepts that are partly the same and partly different. This is distinct from the analogy of being (Latin: analogia entis).

The analogy of faith is often misunderstood to mean "Scripture interprets Scripture", or "Scripture interprets itself". However, this is not entirely accurate. While Scripture can provide context and clarity to other passages, not every Scripture is interpreted by another Scripture. For instance, 1 Corinthians 15:29 mentions "baptism for the dead", which is not elaborated on in any other Scripture.

The analogy of faith asserts that all Scripture is in harmony and will not contradict itself. This means that when multiple passages speak about a topic, their messages will be consistent and not contradictory. For example, Psalm 34:15 and John 4:24 seem to present conflicting ideas about God's physical form, but the analogy of faith encourages a deeper interpretation that resolves this apparent contradiction.

The analogy of faith, therefore, serves as a guide for interpreting Scripture, particularly when dealing with difficult or unclear passages. It emphasizes the internal consistency and unity of the Bible, ensuring that any interpretation aligns with the broader teachings and principles found within Scripture.

It is closely related to the notion of Tradition

The analogy of faith is closely related to the notion of Tradition. The phrase stems from the biblical Romans 12:6, which speaks of the "charism of prophecy" and other gifts of the Spirit, such as teaching and ministering. Prophets were guided by the Spirit to gain insight into the faith and recognise tasks to be undertaken.

The analogy of faith has always been associated with the "one unchanging faith of the Church". It became a norm for early Christian writers, who recognised a "proportion" in the way the New Testament complements the Old Testament, and how each truth contributes to the inner unity of the entire Christian revelation. This "proportion" became a rule or guide for the exegesis of Scripture, especially in difficult texts, where the teachings of tradition and the analogy of faith must be heeded.

The Catholic exegete, for example, is conscious of his faith and recognises the intimate relationship between Scripture and Tradition. He strives to explain Scriptural passages in a way that does not set the sacred writers in opposition to one another or to the faith and teaching of the Church.

The analogy of faith is also related to the notion that "Scripture interprets Scripture", or "Scripture interprets itself". This means that all Scripture is in agreement and will not contradict itself. It assumes the unity and harmony of teaching throughout the Bible. When multiple passages speak about the same topic, they will not be contradictory. For instance, Psalm 34:15 speaks of God having eyes and ears, while John 4:24 says God is a spirit. The analogy of faith means these passages are not contradictory; in Psalm 34:15, the author is using a figure of speech to assert that God watches over and hears his people, while in John 4:24, Jesus is asserting that God is not a physical being, so the physical location of His worshippers is not most important to Him.

The analogy of faith also suggests that unclear passages should be interpreted in light of clear passages. For example, in John 10:24-36, Jesus says, "I and the Father are one", which the Jews understand as a claim to divinity. Many commentators interpret this as a quote from Psalm 82:6: "I said, 'you are gods, and all of you are sons of the Most High'". However, by examining related passages, we can understand that Jesus is not claiming to be a god in the same sense as the judges of Israel in Psalm 82, but rather asserting His divinity as the Son of God.

Frequently asked questions