Understanding "Good Faith": Exploring Its True Meaning

Acting in 'good faith' is a term used to describe a subjective behaviour that is expected of parties in a business or legal agreement. While there is no universal legal definition, acting in good faith generally involves dealing with each other honestly, reasonably, and fairly. This means that all parties must exercise their powers reasonably and not arbitrarily or for an irrelevant purpose, and must not pursue any ulterior motives. Acting in good faith is especially important in insurance law, where it is central to all aspects of the contract, from inception to the terms of the contract and each party's responsibilities in the event of a claim.

Acting in good faith means being honest and sincere

In contract law, for example, the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing assumes that all parties will deal with each other honestly, fairly, and in good faith. This means not withholding information, acting arbitrarily, or doing anything that would deny the other party the benefits outlined in the contract. Acting in good faith in this context also means considering the interests of the other party without having to subordinate one's own interests.

In insurance, the duty of utmost good faith is central to the contract, requiring both the insurer and the insured to act towards each other with honesty, fairness, and decency. This includes the duty of disclosure, where both parties must disclose all relevant information to ensure a fair assessment of the contract.

For company directors, acting in good faith involves making decisions that are in the best interests of the company as a whole, rather than for personal gain. This means being loyal to the company and its shareholders, avoiding conflicts of interest, and acting with reasonable care and diligence.

Overall, acting in good faith means being honest, sincere, and fair in your dealings with others. It is about upholding integrity and trust, ensuring that your actions do not harm or deceive others, and considering the interests and well-being of all involved parties.

It does not mean acting against your own interests

Acting in good faith is a broad concept that varies across different contexts and jurisdictions. However, it is understood that acting in good faith does not mean acting against your own interests. This means that while you should consider the interests of the other party, you are not required to subordinate your own interests to theirs.

In the context of contracts, acting in good faith is often associated with fairness and honesty in dealings between the parties involved. This includes being honest and cooperative during negotiations, making timely decisions, and avoiding arbitrary or capricious behaviour. It is important to note that acting in good faith does not mean that you have to make changes or additions to an agreement to favour the other party.

For example, in the case of a franchise agreement, a franchisor deciding not to offer a franchisee an option to renew or extend their agreement does not necessarily mean they have acted in bad faith. As long as the decision is made honestly and with a reasonable belief that it is in the best interests of the company as a whole, it can be considered acting in good faith, even if it also benefits the franchisor personally.

Acting in good faith also does not require you to act against your own legitimate commercial interests. For instance, in the case of Gold Group Properties v BDW Trading Ltd., the court ruled that an obligation "to act at all times in good faith" does not imply a fiduciary duty, where a party would need to abandon the pursuit of its own self-interest.

In summary, acting in good faith involves considering the interests of the other party and treating them fairly and honestly, but it does not mean putting their interests before your own or acting against your own legitimate interests.

Good faith is required in pre-contractual negotiations

The obligation to act in good faith applies to any matter arising in the franchising relationship, including pre-contractual negotiations, performance of the contract, and the end of an agreement. For example, in the context of a franchise agreement, good faith requires parties to act honestly and cooperatively during negotiations. This means that they must consider the other party's interests and make timely decisions.

In France, the duty to act in good faith during pre-contractual negotiations was introduced for the first time in the 2016 reform of the civil code (Article 1112 of the French Civil Code). This article states that the initiative, conduct, and interruption of pre-contractual negotiations remain free. However, there is a specific obligation to satisfy the requirements of good faith. If one party interrupts the negotiations without a valid reason and the other party has valid reasons to expect a successful outcome, the interrupting party may be required to compensate the other for expenses incurred.

In the common law world, there is no general duty to negotiate contracts in good faith. However, this situation may be changing, especially in England and Wales and Canada, where case law in the last decade has indicated a movement towards the acceptance of express and implied duties of good faith in relation to contractual performance. For example, in Yam Seng Pte Limited v International Trade Corporation Limited, the court found an implied duty of good faith in a long-term distributorship contract.

While the concept of good faith negotiation is not fully defined, it generally means that parties desire to reach an agreement and commit to meeting the deal terms. It is important to note that negotiators are not required to act against their own interests to negotiate in good faith.

Good faith is also required when ending a contract

While there is no universal legal definition of acting in 'good faith' during business dealings, it is a well-established concept in contract law. Good faith is often implied in contracts to ensure that parties deal with each other honestly, fairly, and in a way that does not destroy the right of the other party to receive the benefits of the contract. This means not pursuing ulterior motives, exercising power in an arbitrary way, or acting dishonestly.

In Canadian contract law, the duty of honest contractual performance, also known as the doctrine of abuse of rights, requires parties to act in good faith and with honesty when exercising their rights and delivering their obligations under a contract. This duty is rooted in the civil law doctrine of abuse of rights and is applicable in both Québec's civil law and the common law jurisdictions.

In the United States, the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing is an important legal concept. It is incorporated into the Uniform Commercial Code and was codified by the American Law Institute. While most U.S. jurisdictions view a breach of this covenant as a variant of breach of contract, certain jurisdictions also allow for a tort action, particularly in insurance law, where an insurer's breach may give rise to a tort action known as insurance bad faith.

Overall, while the specific implications may vary based on the jurisdiction, good faith is generally required when ending a contract, and parties must continue to act honestly, fairly, and with consideration for the interests of the other party.

Acting in good faith does not mean subordinating your interests to those of others

Acting in good faith is a broad concept that varies across jurisdictions. However, it generally involves parties to a contract dealing with each other honestly, sincerely, and fairly, without intending to deceive or destroy the rights of the other party. This includes the obligation to not act arbitrarily or for an irrelevant purpose and to consider the legitimate interests of the other party without subordinating one's own interests to theirs.

For example, in the context of insurance, acting in good faith would mean that the policyholder must make full disclosure of all relevant facts when taking out the insurance, and the insurer must respond to a claim in a timely manner. In the context of business dealings, acting in good faith would mean not pursuing an ulterior motive, not exercising power in an arbitrary way, and not denying the other party the benefits of a contract.

In the context of a company director, acting in good faith means making decisions that are genuinely believed to be for the benefit of the company as a whole, rather than for personal gain. This does not mean that the decision cannot benefit the director as well, as long as it is not made solely for personal interest. The director has a fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the company and its shareholders, which includes avoiding conflicts of interest and acting with reasonable care and diligence.

Overall, acting in good faith involves dealing fairly and honestly with others, considering their interests without subordinating your own, and making decisions that are believed to be beneficial to all parties involved.

Frequently asked questions