The Catholic Conundrum: Withdrawal, Sin, And Contraception

The withdrawal method, or coitus interruptus, is a form of contraception where a man removes his penis from the vagina before ejaculation, preventing the sperm from coming into contact with the egg. While this method is popular among teens and in countries where contraceptives are not easily available, it is considered sinful by the Catholic Church. The Church's teaching on birth regulation states that contraception is an intrinsic evil, and any action intended to prevent procreation is absolutely excluded as a lawful means of regulating the number of children. The sinful aspect of the withdrawal method, according to the Church, lies in the intent to deny the possibility of life and make the sexual act purely for pleasure, which is considered a lustful and immoral act.

The Catholic Church's stance on the pull-out method

The Catholic Church's teaching on birth regulation states that the pull-out method is a sin, as it falls under the category of contraception, which is considered an intrinsic evil. This is reaffirmed in Pope Paul VI's encyclical letter, Humanae Vitae (On Human Life, 1968), as well as Pope Pius XI's 1930 encyclical, Casti Connubii (On Chastity in Marriage). The Catechism of the Catholic Church (2399) also states that "legitimate intentions on the part of the spouses [regarding birth regulation] do not justify recourse to morally unacceptable means (for example, direct sterilization or contraception)".

The Church defines contraception as "any action which either before, at the moment of, or after sexual intercourse, is specifically intended to prevent procreation—whether as an end or as a means". Such actions are considered unlawful means of regulating the number of children and are not acceptable to the Church.

The pull-out method is seen as a violation of the natural order of human sexuality and, therefore, a sin against God. The primary goal of sex within the Catholic Church is procreation, and any action taken to intentionally prevent conception is considered a mortal sin, as it reduces sex solely to a source of pleasure and intimacy. However, the Church does encourage Natural Family Planning (NFP), which involves abstaining from sex during a woman's fertile period.

While the pull-out method may seem like a practical solution for couples who wish to avoid pregnancy, the Catholic Church considers it a sin due to its contradiction of the Church's teachings on the purpose of sex and the intrinsic evil of contraception.

The Bible and pull-out method

The Bible and the Pull-Out Method

The Bible does not explicitly mention the pull-out method or any other form of contraception. However, there is an interpretation of a passage in the Book of Genesis that is used to argue that the pull-out method is a sin. This interpretation centres around the story of Onan, who, according to the Bible, was killed by God for "spilling his seed on the ground" instead of impregnating his brother's widow, as was his duty according to Mosaic law.

The passage in question, Genesis 38:9-10, states: "And Onan knew that the offspring would not be his; so whenever he went in to his brother's wife, he wasted his seed on the ground, so as not to give offspring to his brother. And what he did was wicked in the sight of the Lord, and He slew him also."

Some Christians, particularly Catholics, interpret this passage as a condemnation of the pull-out method, or "coitus interruptus", as it is sometimes called. They argue that Onan's sin was not in failing to uphold the Mosaic law, but in violating the natural order of human sexuality by actively frustrating the procreative purpose of sex. This interpretation is supported by the fact that the penalty for not raising up offspring for a deceased brother was public humiliation, not death, according to Deuteronomy 25:9.

However, it is important to note that not all Christians interpret the story of Onan in this way. Some argue that the sin lay in Onan's refusal to fulfil his duty to his brother and provide an heir, rather than in the method he used to avoid impregnating his brother's widow. Additionally, most Protestants do not have a moral objection to the pull-out method when used within marriage.

In Catholic theology, the pull-out method is considered a sin because it is a form of contraception, which is seen as an intrinsic evil. The Catholic Church teaches that any action taken to intentionally frustrate conception is a mortal sin, as it reduces sex to a purely lustful and pleasurable act, rather than one that is open to the possibility of life. This teaching is based on the belief that the primary end goal of sex is procreation, with unity and intimacy as secondary goals.

In summary, while the Bible does not directly address the pull-out method, some Christians interpret the story of Onan as a condemnation of this practice. The Catholic Church, in particular, considers the pull-out method to be a sin because it violates the procreative purpose of sex and is a form of contraception, which is deemed morally unacceptable.

Contraception as a sin

Contraception is considered a sin in the Catholic Church, as it goes against the natural order of human sexuality and, therefore, God's will. This is based on the biblical story of Onan, who was killed by God for practising the "sin of Onan", or "onanism", which involves spilling one's seed on the ground outside of the body during intercourse to avoid procreation.

The Catholic Church's teaching on the regulation of births is clear that the withdrawal method (coitus interruptus) is a sin, as stated in Pope Paul VI's encyclical letter, Humanae Vitae (On Human Life, 1968), which reaffirmed the Church's stance that contraception is an intrinsic evil. This is further supported by Pope Pius XI's 1930 encyclical, Casti Connubii (On Chastity in Marriage), and the Catechism of the Catholic Church (2399), which states that legitimate intentions do not justify the use of morally unacceptable means of contraception.

The Church defines contraception as "any action that is specifically intended to prevent procreation, whether as an end or a means". Such actions are considered unlawful means of regulating the number of children and include various methods such as condoms, spermicides, birth control pills, intrauterine devices, and sterilisation, in addition to the withdrawal method.

The primary end goal of sex in the Catholic Church is procreation, with unity, intimacy, and the quieting of concupiscence as secondary goals. Any action taken to intentionally frustrate conception, such as contraception or coitus interruptus, is considered a mortal sin, as it reduces sex to merely a source of physical pleasure and intimacy.

Natural Family Planning (NFP) is encouraged by the Church as an alternative to contraception. NFP involves abstaining from sexual intercourse during a woman's fertile window, as determined by ovulation tracking. While this method may result in periods of abstinence, it is considered a sacrifice that strengthens the bond and builds discipline within a marriage.

It is important to note that the sin associated with contraception is based on intent rather than outcome. Even if contraception fails and results in pregnancy, the act of using it with the intention to prevent procreation is still considered a sin.

Natural Family Planning (NFP)

The calendar, basal body temperature, and cervical mucus methods are combined to give awareness of when a body is most fertile. As users become familiar with their body's ovulation and fertile window, they can abstain from sexual intercourse or use a barrier method during that time.

The female fertility cycle can be divided into three phases. Phase I begins on the first day of menstrual bleeding and normally includes a few infertile days after menstruation. Phase II begins as soon as a woman’s daily observations detect the onset of signs of fertility. This fertile time lasts up to and a few days after ovulation. Phase III is the post-ovulation time and is a time of infertility.

The Sympto-Thermal Method (STM) is based on three key signs of fertility: cervical mucus, basal body temperature, and changes in the cervix. By observing and recording these signs, couples can identify Phase I, II, and III and, therefore, know if they are in a time of fertility or infertility.

NFP is practised by a small fraction of women. Some women may choose these methods because they have a religious objection to contraception that involves drugs, devices, or surgical procedures. Others may use them because they prefer a hormone-free method. However, NFP is less effective than other forms of contraception such as the oral contraceptive pill, IUD, implant, and condoms.

Pull-out method and abstinence

The withdrawal method, also known as coitus interruptus or the pull-out method, is a contraceptive method where the man removes his penis from the vagina before ejaculation and releases semen away from his partner. This method is popular among teenagers and in countries where contraceptives are not easily available. While the pull-out method has no side effects or health risks, it does carry a risk of sexually transmitted diseases as STDs can be transmitted through pre-ejaculate fluids.

The Catholic Church considers the pull-out method a sin, as it falls under the category of contraception, which is deemed "intrinsically evil". The Church's teaching on the regulation of births states that legitimate intentions do not justify the use of morally unacceptable means to prevent procreation. This is based on the belief that the primary end goal of sex is procreation, and any action taken to intentionally prevent conception is a mortal sin, as it reduces sex to an act solely for pleasure and intimacy.

Natural Family Planning (NFP) is encouraged by the Church as an alternative to contraception. NFP involves abstaining from sex during a woman's fertile period, which can be determined through ovulation tracking. While NFP may require periods of abstinence, it is considered a sacrifice that strengthens the bond and builds discipline within a marriage.

Some Christians may object to the pull-out method as it is often used by unmarried teenagers, who would be safer practicing abstinence. However, most Protestants do not have a moral objection to this method of contraception when used within marriage.

In summary, the pull-out method is considered a sin by the Catholic Church due to its classification as contraception, which is believed to violate the natural order of human sexuality as intended by God. Abstinence during fertile periods, as practised in NFP, is encouraged as an alternative that aligns with the Church's teachings.

Frequently asked questions