Speeding And Sin: A Catholic's Ethical Dilemma

Speeding is a contentious topic in Catholic circles, with some arguing that it is a sin only if it threatens harm to oneself or others. This is supported by the Catechism of the Catholic Church, which states that those who incur grave guilt...by a love of speed, endanger their own and others' safety on the road. However, others argue that speeding is a violation of the Fifth Commandment, which says thou shall not kill, and Jesus' commandment to love thy neighbour. While some claim that driving a few miles over the speed limit is generally safe, traffic authorities advise against exceeding the posted limit. Ultimately, it is up to the individual to examine their conscience and determine whether their actions warrant confession and repentance.

Speeding is a sin if it endangers others

Speeding is a sin for Catholics if it endangers the lives of others. This is because the Catechism of the Catholic Church says that "those incur grave guilt who, by drunkenness or love of speed, endanger their own and others' safety on the road, at sea, or in the air". This is further supported by the Fifth Commandment, which says "thou shall not kill", and Jesus' commandment to "love thy neighbour as thyself".

However, this does not mean that going a few miles above the speed limit is a sin, as this does not usually endanger others. In fact, driving below the predominant speed of the traffic can be more dangerous and thus more of a sin.

Some may argue that driving at all is inherently dangerous and thus always a sin. However, this is not a helpful argument as it is possible to minimise danger by driving with care and attention. This includes obeying traffic laws, which are generally intended to protect the travelling public. Therefore, it is a sin to violate traffic laws as this unnecessarily puts others in danger.

However, it is important to note that the concept of sin is complex, and there may be mitigating circumstances in individual cases. For example, in some states, the posted speed limit is merely presumed correct, and it is possible to show that a higher speed is safe and appropriate under the circumstances.

Reckless driving is a sin

The Catechism of the Catholic Church states that "those who, by drunkenness or a love of speed, endanger their own and others' safety on the road, at sea, or in the air, incur grave guilt" (CCC 2290). This highlights the seriousness of reckless driving, which can lead to harm or even death. As Christians, we are called to love our neighbors as ourselves, and this includes taking reasonable steps to ensure their safety.

Reckless driving can take many forms, such as speeding, drunk driving, texting while driving, or following another vehicle too closely. These actions can have devastating consequences and are considered sins because they put the lives of others at risk. For example, if you are driving under the influence of alcohol and cause an accident that results in someone's death, you have not only committed a grave sin but also potentially damned them to an eternal suffering in Hell.

Furthermore, reckless driving also shows a disregard for legitimate authority and undermines the community and the common good. Traffic laws are in place to protect the traveling public, and when we violate these laws, we are not only endangering others but also showing a lack of respect for the authority that has been established to maintain order and safety.

In conclusion, reckless driving is a sin because it fails to uphold the value of human life, disregards legitimate authority, and endangers the safety and well-being of others. As Christians, we are called to love our neighbors and protect life, and reckless driving directly contradicts these values. Therefore, it is important for us to drive with care and attention, always considering the potential consequences of our actions on the road.

Driving under the influence of alcohol is a sin

The Bible has many injunctions against drunkenness, with the strongest found in the book of Isaiah:

> Woe to those who rise early in the morning that they may pursue strong drink: Who stay up late in the evening that wine may inflame them! (Isaiah 5:11)

St. Thomas Aquinas writes:

> Every sin is voluntary [per St. Augustine]. But no man wishes to be drunk, since no man wishes to be deprived of the use of reason. Therefore, drunkenness is not a sin.

However, St. Thomas Aquinas also notes that drunkenness may result from inordinate concupiscence and use of wine, and in this way, it is accounted as a sin and is comprised under gluttony.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church states:

> The virtue of temperance disposes us to avoid every kind of excess: the abuse of food, alcohol, tobacco, or medicine. Those incur grave guilt who, by drunkenness or a love of speed, endanger their own and others' safety on the road, at sea, or in the air.

Therefore, driving under the influence of alcohol is a sin if it threatens harm to the driver or anyone else. Drunk driving is a grave sin because it deprives the drinker of the use of reason, and the drinker no longer has the freedom necessary to deliberate responsibly about what he should do or not do.

The Bible has little patience for those who lose control of themselves through the overindulgence of alcohol. Drunkenness evokes the anger of the Biblical authors, and they saw something in the drunkard's behaviour that was abominable to the Lord. In Leviticus, we read:

> Drink no wine or strong drink, you or your sons with you, when you go into the tent of meeting, lest you die. It shall be a statute forever throughout your generations. (Leviticus 10:9)

St. John Chrysostom, a fourth-century Doctor of the Church, once said in a homily:

> Let there be no drunkenness; for wine is the work of God, but drunkenness is the work of the devil. Wine makes not drunkenness; but intemperance produces it. Do not accuse that which is the workmanship of God, but accuse the madness of a fellow mortal... For what is more wretched than drunkenness! The drunken man is a living corpse. Drunkenness is a demon self-chosen...

Speeding is not a sin in itself

However, it is important to note that simply driving a few miles over the speed limit does not typically endanger others and therefore would not be considered a sin. As one source states, "driving below the predominant speed of the traffic is more endangering than driving above the speed limit." Additionally, traffic laws and speed limits are designed to ensure the safety of drivers and pedestrians, and violating these laws can put others in danger, which would be considered a sin.

Furthermore, speeding can be seen as a violation of the Fourth Commandment, which directs us to respect legitimate authority. Careless disregard for the law can undermine the community and the common good. Therefore, while speeding in and of itself may not be a sin, it can become one if it endangers the lives of others or shows a lack of respect for legitimate authority.

As with most things, common sense is crucial in determining whether one's actions are endangering others or being negligent. It is worth noting that driving itself is an inherently dangerous activity, and one should always exercise caution and follow traffic laws to ensure the safety of oneself and others.

Speeding is a sin if it breaks the law

Speeding is a sin for Catholics if it breaks the law and endangers others. The Catechism of the Catholic Church states that "those incur grave guilt who, by drunkenness or a love of speed, endanger their own and others' safety on the road, at sea, or in the air". This is because speeding violates the Fifth Commandment, which says "thou shall not kill", and Jesus' commandment to "love thy neighbour".

However, the key word here is "endanger". Going a few miles above the speed limit does not usually endanger others and would therefore not be considered a sin. Driving below the predominant speed of the traffic could be more dangerous than driving slightly above the speed limit.

Some people argue that technically, every time you drive a car, you are endangering others, because it would be safer to walk. Similarly, leaving your house increases risk for both you and others. Therefore, driving at all could be considered a sin.

However, this is not a commonly held view, and most people would agree that speeding is only a sin if it puts others in danger. This is supported by the Fourth Commandment, which directs us to respect legitimate authority. Careless disregard for the law undermines the community and the common good.

Frequently asked questions