Pirating: Sin Or Not? Exploring The Moral Dilemma

Piracy is a problem that costs businesses billions of dollars a year. It is easily done from the privacy of one's own home with usually a very minimal chance of consequences. But is it a sin? The Bible tells us that we are to obey the laws of the government we live under (Romans 13:1–7). That is one of the key issues at stake here. God commands us to obey the governmental authorities. The Bible also says the “laborer is worthy of his wages” (1 Timothy 5:18). The principle is that those who work—whether by providing an immediate service or creating music, software or games—are to be compensated appropriately. Their services are not to be taken from them for nothing. The Eighth Commandment is clear: “You shall not steal” (Exodus 20:15).

Piracy is a form of theft

Piracy occurs when individuals bypass legal channels to access or distribute content, facilitated by online platforms and peer-to-peer networks. While it allows users to access content freely, it violates copyright laws and undermines the creators' and industries' financial interests, potentially impacting the quality and availability of future content. Piracy leads to significant revenue losses for creators and industries, depriving them of income they rightfully earned. It also strips creators of their right to control how their work is used and distributed.

The debate around whether piracy is stealing encompasses legal, economic, ethical, and accessibility considerations. While the legal and economic arguments support the view of piracy as a form of theft, ethical considerations and issues of accessibility and affordability provide a counterpoint, suggesting that the issue is complex and nuanced.

From a religious perspective, the Bible tells us that we are to obey the laws of the government we live under. God commands us to obey governmental authorities, and since copyright laws make it legally wrong to download, pirate, or share copyrighted material without permission, the practice of digital internet piracy can be considered a sin where it is illegal.

It is illegal

Piracy is illegal. Copyright law protects the value of creative work. When you make unauthorised copies of someone's creative work, you are taking something of value from the owner without their permission. This is intellectual theft. The Bible tells us that we are to obey the laws of the government we live under (Romans 13:1–7). God commands us to obey the governmental authorities. The only allowance we have for disobeying the authorities is if they demand that we disobey something God has commanded (Acts 5:29).

Federal law provides severe civil and criminal penalties for the unauthorised reproduction, distribution, rental or digital transmission of copyrighted sound recordings. A civil lawsuit could hold you responsible for thousands of dollars in damages. Criminal charges may leave you with a felony record, accompanied by up to five years of jail time and fines of up to $250,000.

In the US, the RIAA (Recording Industry Association of America) works to protect artists and the music community from online piracy and counterfeit goods. A long series of court rulings has made it very clear that uploading and downloading copyrighted music without permission on P2P networks constitutes infringement and could be a crime.

In Canada, the laws are more liberal. For example, it is technically illegal to use a PVR in the USA, but not in Canada. However, this does not mean that Canadians can escape punishment for piracy. In Canada, most sites that host abandonware make money from ads. They also usually tell the original publisher that they will remove the game if requested by the owner of the IP.

In the UK, the government has been granted the power to block websites that host pirated content. In 2014, the High Court ordered five of the UK's biggest internet service providers to block several sites that facilitated the illegal downloading of music.

It is unethical

Pirating copyrighted material is unethical. The Bible tells us that we are to obey the laws of the government we live under (Romans 13:1–7). That is one of the key issues at stake here. God commands us to obey the governmental authorities. Since pirating is illegal, it is a sin.

Pirating is a form of stealing. Taking someone else's property without permission is stealing—and intellectual property is still property. The songwriter who worked to produce a song has earned compensation, because “the worker deserves his wages” (Luke 10:7). When a song is copied and given to someone else, that is one less sale that could have been made. The artist loses whatever small percentage of the royalties they have earned. The same principle holds true for pirating a movie, photocopying a play script, sharing Sunday school curricula, and loading software. A Christian should never want to steal the property of others—but that’s what happens when we download songs without the permission of the publisher.

Pirating also hurts the wider community. Piracy exacts a high cost on businesses and jobs. As more people copy digital media, sales of the original will decrease, creating a loss to those producing the content. It raises costs on honest consumers. Because of piracy, companies are forced to invest in extra layers of protection for their products in order to stay one step ahead of pirates. Also, considerable costs are incurred fighting piracy through monitoring, courts and lawsuits. These extra costs add up and are passed on to consumers who don’t steal. It stifles innovation. Piracy can cause small businesses and young entrepreneurs to be discouraged from producing their absolute best content—because they are expecting it to just be stolen by thousands (maybe millions) of people.

Piracy can also facilitate the spread of malware. The FBI has warned that much of the pirated media contains malware (malicious software). Once installed on your device, malware is very difficult to remove and can be very dangerous. Malware can be used to steal usernames, passwords, credit card details and social security numbers. It can log your keystrokes, redirect Internet search results to dangerous sites, gather your contact information and send fake emails from your computer, identify and steal confidential information, and allow hackers free access to your system.

Piracy can also fund terrorist and criminal organizations. Piracy is a very lucrative business. The Guardian reports that terrorists and criminal organizations often use piracy to fund their operations. In fact, these organizations can make more money in piracy than they can in drug trafficking!

It can be dangerous

Piracy is often viewed as a harmless act of rebellion against big corporations. However, this perception is misleading, as piracy can have dangerous consequences for individuals, businesses, and entire industries.

Firstly, piracy exposes individuals to significant legal risks. Engaging in content piracy, such as downloading or distributing illegal content, is a direct violation of the law and can lead to lawsuits, substantial fines, and even criminal charges. The legal consequences of piracy can be financially draining and stressful, with the potential for high legal fees and reputational damage.

Secondly, pirated digital content, especially counterfeit software, often contains malicious software or malware. Downloading such content puts individuals at risk of data loss, personal information theft, and identity fraud. This compromises online security and can have severe repercussions.

Additionally, piracy can result in poor-quality and incomplete content. Pirated movies or software are often low-resolution or incomplete, leading to a subpar experience for users. This issue also extends to inadequate or missing product documentation, a lack of technical support, and ineligibility for software upgrades offered to licensed users.

Piracy also has economic implications, directly harming content creators and industries. Each illegal copy represents lost revenue, leading to reduced funding for future projects, job losses, and a decline in content quality. It stifles innovation by hindering the ability of creators and companies to invest in new projects.

Furthermore, accessing pirated content often involves dealing with unreliable and unethical sources, such as dubious and illegal streaming sites or file-sharing platforms. By doing so, individuals indirectly support these operations, which can have moral and ethical implications.

In conclusion, piracy is a complex issue with far-reaching consequences. It is essential to understand the risks involved and make informed, ethical choices to protect oneself and support the hard work of content creators and the integrity of industries.

It can fund terrorism

Piracy is a sin, as it is a form of theft and goes against the Bible's teachings. The Bible tells us to obey the laws of the government we live under, and copyright laws dictate that pirating is illegal.

Piracy can also have far-reaching consequences, as it can fund terrorism. Terrorism needs cash to buy arms, finance operatives, and bribe officials. Counterfeiting and piracy are significant sources of income for terrorist groups. For example, in India, criminal infiltration of the film industry has led to Bollywood film piracy funding terrorism. The D-Company, a criminal organization, has infiltrated Bollywood and controls much of the black market in counterfeit films. The profits from these illegal activities have been used to fund extremist actions, such as the "Black Friday" Mumbai bombings in 1993.

The Provisional Irish Republican Army (PIRA) is another example of a paramilitary group that leveraged civil unrest and violence to engage in organized crime, including counterfeiting and film piracy. The proceeds from these activities have contributed to financing their operations.

Terrorist groups like Al Qaeda and Hezbollah have also been linked to IP piracy and counterfeiting of luxury goods. The distribution of counterfeit goods is widespread in many large U.S. tourist cities, and even a small percentage of the profits can provide substantial funding for terrorist organizations.

To combat this issue, governments need to increase their political will, strengthen legislation, improve consistent enforcement, implement deterrent sentencing, and explore innovative solutions. These measures aim to reduce the demand for pirated goods and curb the supply of counterfeit products, thereby disrupting the funding sources for terrorist activities.

Frequently asked questions