Meditation's Dark Night: Exploring The Risks Amidst A Rise In Popularity

Meditation is widely regarded as a beneficial practice for mental health and spiritual well-being. It is commonly believed to uplift one's mood, heal emotional wounds, and promote mental peace. However, in recent years, concerns have been raised about the potential negative consequences of meditation on mental health. While the number of people affected is not clear, studies and reports suggest that meditation can have adverse effects on a small percentage of individuals, leading to increased anxiety, depression, and stress, as well as unusual experiences such as hallucinations.

Meditation can cause anxiety attacks by bringing back traumatic memories

While meditation is often hailed as a beneficial practice for mental health, it can also bring up difficult memories and cause anxiety. This is especially true for those who have experienced trauma or suffer from anxiety disorders.

Meditation, and in particular mindfulness meditation, involves paying close attention to one's thoughts and feelings. This increased self-awareness can be beneficial for dealing with emotions, but it can also lead to a heightened awareness of anxiety symptoms and trigger panic attacks in those prone to anxiety. For people with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), meditation can bring up traumatic memories and lead to intense emotional experiences.

During meditation, people may find themselves facing negative or traumatic experiences from the past, both conscious and subconscious. This is often due to the nature of repression—the things we resist tend to persist. In other words, when we experience something traumatic, we may not be ready or able to deal with the feelings that arise, so we repress them. However, when we let go and open up during meditation, all that has been repressed can come to the surface to be released.

While meditation can be a safe space to allow past trauma to arise, it is important to have support, especially when facing traumatic memories. Working with a teacher or professional can help guide you through the process and provide encouragement. It is recommended to start with short meditation sessions and gradually increase the duration. Additionally, combining meditation with other practices such as yoga or walking can be beneficial for those who find traditional sitting meditation triggering.

In conclusion, while meditation can be a powerful tool for managing stress and anxiety, it is not without its risks. For some, it can bring up traumatic memories and trigger anxiety attacks. It is important to be aware of these potential challenges and seek professional guidance when needed.

It can induce feelings of dissociation and an unwillingness to connect with others

While meditation has many positive impacts on the mind, it can also induce feelings of dissociation and an unwillingness to connect with others.

Dissociation is a term that indicates a disconnection from one's own self or from a part of one's self. On the mild end of the spectrum, dissociation is the spaciness we feel when we're on auto-pilot, walking the same route over and over — we are physically present but have no memory of the walk. In its extreme state, dissociation is the experience during a traumatic event of disconnecting from the body and self. It happens to all mammals caught in a life-or-death situation and is related to the fight/flight/freeze instinct.

Meditation can sometimes be confused with dissociation. Deep meditation can bring people to a euphoric state, transcending the body. Some people meditate with the goal of reaching this state in mind. However, the route to transcendence is not easy and requires commitment to the practice. There is a quicker route to feeling good, and that is through dissociation. All the tools needed to dissociate are within us and can be accessed without any discipline. This disembodied happy place can be mistaken for the transcendent state experienced in deep meditation.

Meditation teachers have noted that many of their students think that mindful breathing is the only meditation technique. This is due to the way meditation has been commodified and sold through apps and videos. However, traditional Buddhist monks would practice a variety of techniques, some of which would connect them to thoughts and feelings, such as Loving Kindness (Metta) and Compassion (Karuna).

Some research has found that meditation can induce feelings of negativity, which can sometimes lead to dissociation and an unwillingness to connect with others. However, other studies have found that meditation does not cause harm and can even be preventative of increased psychological and physical symptoms.

Lack of motivation can be a result of meditation and mindfulness

Meditation has become an increasingly popular practice in the Western world, with one in seven Americans reporting that they have a mindfulness practice. Rooted in 2,000-year-old Buddhism, mindfulness involves focusing the mind on the present moment and accepting things as they are. While meditation has been shown to have many benefits, such as reducing stress and improving focus, some people have questioned whether it can also have negative side effects.

One potential downside of meditation that has been reported is a lack of motivation. Since meditation and mindfulness encourage a person to live a life of detachment, it may also lead to a lack of interest in work, personal life, and other areas. This idea was explored in a study by researchers from INSEAD and the University of Minnesota, who found that participants who meditated before performing a small job showed less motivation to complete the task compared to those who did not meditate. The meditation group also reported that they didn't feel like doing the work and didn't want to spend much time on it.

However, it's important to note that the study only looked at the short-term effects of meditation on motivation and that the participants only meditated for a brief period (around 10 minutes). Some commentators have argued that longer-term and more regular meditation practice may have different effects on motivation. For example, one commentator on a Reddit thread about lack of motivation and meditation suggested that meditation can help eliminate fear and allow people to strive for improvement. They wrote, "Use meditation as a tool to eliminate your fear from trying something new, hard, or what the mind considers depressing. Continuous practice can bring out your true potential."

Another commentator on the same thread shared their experience of how meditation helped them let go of motivations that were rooted in negative thoughts: "Once I let these go, what kept me going was figuring out what WAS important to me (helping others, learning, improving). It took me a while to figure this out, and there are some systems that can help with this." This suggests that while meditation may reduce certain types of motivation (such as those driven by fear or anxiety), it can also help people discover deeper and more meaningful sources of motivation.

In conclusion, while meditation may lead to a lack of motivation in some cases, it is important to consider the context and the individual's overall meditation practice. More research is needed to fully understand the complex ways in which meditation can influence motivation.

Meditation can increase a sense of alertness and focus, which can lead to insomnia and other sleep problems

While meditation is often touted as a way to relax and unwind, some have found that it can have the opposite effect, increasing alertness and focus to the point of causing insomnia and other sleep problems.

A study published by The American Psychosomatic Society found that people who meditated frequently were more prone to damaged sleep cycles and had difficulty sleeping sufficiently. The extremities of alertness and focus can lead to a state of hyper-arousal, which can make it difficult to fall asleep and maintain a restful night's sleep.

Meditation can also help to bring up emotions and memories, including traumatic ones, which can disrupt sleep. It is important to note, however, that the link between meditation and increased alertness and focus has not been extensively studied, and more research is needed to fully understand the potential side effects.

That being said, it is worth considering the potential impact on sleep before starting a meditation practice, especially for those who already struggle with sleep issues. While meditation can be beneficial for many, it may not be the best practice for those who are looking to improve their sleep quality.

Additionally, it is important to be mindful of the potential for increased alertness and focus when meditating, especially in the evenings. Practicing meditation earlier in the day or choosing more relaxing forms of meditation, such as mindfulness meditation or body scan meditation, may help to mitigate the potential impact on sleep.

Physical symptoms such as pain, pressure, involuntary movements, headaches, fatigue, weakness, gastrointestinal problems, and dizziness have been reported by enthusiastic meditators

While meditation has been proven to have many benefits, it is important to be aware of the potential risks. In this regard, physical symptoms such as pain, pressure, involuntary movements, headaches, fatigue, weakness, gastrointestinal problems, and dizziness have been reported by enthusiastic meditators.

A 2017 study conducted by researchers from Brown University and the University of California found that meditation could lead to certain physical ailments. These physical symptoms were reported by people who were enthusiastic meditators, and the study highlights the need for further research to establish a causal link.

Meditation can bring back a range of emotions and memories, including traumatic ones, which can lead to negative feelings during practice. The study found that participants showed signs of anxiety, fear, and paranoia. Furthermore, meditation can induce feelings of negativity, leading to dissociation and a reluctance to connect with others.

It is important to note that these physical symptoms were reported by a small number of individuals, and the study did not establish a direct causal link between meditation and these physical symptoms. However, it underscores the importance of understanding the potential risks associated with meditation, especially for intensive practices.

While the benefits of meditation are well-documented, it is crucial to approach the practice with awareness and caution. Understanding the potential risks can help individuals regulate their meditation practices to ensure a healthy and sustainable routine.

Frequently asked questions