Lesbianism And Sin: Exploring Religious Perspectives

Lesbianism is a topic that has sparked much debate among religious groups, particularly those who follow the Bible. While some interpret the Bible as condemning lesbianism as a sin, others argue that it is not explicitly mentioned or condemned in the scriptures. This question has led to strong opinions and discussions within religious communities, with some declaring spiritual warfare on gay marriage and others advocating for acceptance and inclusion. The interpretation of religious texts and their application in modern society remains a complex and divisive issue.

Lesbianism is not mentioned in the Bible

Most people who are familiar with what the Bible says in context admit that no verse in the Bible says shrine prostitutes were gay men or lesbians. Many Christians falsely assume that if Leviticus 18:22 and 20:13 prohibit gay male partnerships, then the same verses, by inference, must also prohibit lesbian partnerships. For that reason, many Christians believe that Paul's allegedly anti-lesbian statement in Romans 1:26 is based on his Jewish understanding of Lev 18:22.

However, the problem with that line of thought is that ancient Jews did not understand Leviticus 18:22 and 20:13 as prohibitions of lesbianism. Leviticus 18:22 and 20:13 were written around 1450 BC, yet no Jewish rabbi linked those verses to same-sex couples until 2500 years later (around AD 1100). If those verses were speaking of lesbians, wouldn't some secular Jewish writer or one of the human authors of the Old Testament have mentioned that important fact? Moses Maimonides made the link in the 12th century AD but still insisted that lesbian conduct did not disqualify a woman from marrying a Jewish priest.

Therefore, every modern preacher who reads a prohibition of lesbianism into the Leviticus passages and then transfers that false assumption over to Romans 1:26 will always get Romans 1:26 wrong. Paul's argument in Romans 1:26 is about idolatry, not lesbianism, homosexuality, bisexuality, or transgenderism. The sexual conduct Paul deplores in Romans 1:26 and 1:27 is conduct linked to idolatry. The specific idolatrous conduct that Paul refers to, and which both women and men shared, was shrine prostitution.

Rabbi Jacob Milgrom, a Jewish scholar and author, presents eight reasons why lesbians are not mentioned in Leviticus 18:22 and 20:13 or elsewhere in the Old Testament:

• There is no penetration by the male.
• There is no transfer of semen.
• Women were an underclass, so lesbianism posed no danger to family structure since women were compelled to marry a man.
• Since female-female sexuality carried no risk of procreation, lesbianism posed no problem in determining paternity of children.
• Some assert (falsely) that lesbianism may have been unknown to the Israelites and Canaanites. Because lesbianism is not mentioned in any legal materials from this time period in the ancient Near East, there was no reason to legislate against it.
• A woman could not lose her ‘manly honour’ in a sexual relationship with another woman.
• Female same-sex activity did not challenge male domination.
• The male authors of scripture were more interested in males and their behaviour than in females and their behaviour.

Romans 1:26 is about idolatry, not lesbianism

In the Bible, Romans 1:26-27 is often interpreted as a denunciation of lesbianism and homosexuality. However, this interpretation is not supported by the historical or biblical context. The passage is part of a larger argument by Paul about idolatry and the worship of false gods, specifically addressing shrine prostitution associated with fertility goddess worship in first-century Rome.

The verses in question state:

> "For this cause [idolatry] God gave them up unto vile affections: for even their women did change the natural use into that which is against nature: And likewise also the men, leaving the natural use of the woman, burned in their lust one toward another; men with men working that which is unseemly, and receiving in themselves that recompense of their error which was meet." - Romans 1:26-27

Paul is not condemning lesbianism or homosexuality here but is instead describing the "degrading passions" and "shameful lusts" that result from idolatry. The specific sexual conduct he is referring to is shrine prostitution, which was endemic in the Roman society of his time.

This interpretation is further supported by the fact that early Christians who lived within 100 years of Paul, such as Aristides and Justin Martyr, understood his words in this context. Additionally, there are no references to Sodom in the Old Testament that mention homosexuality or lesbianism, even though God is assumed to be condemning it.

Therefore, it is incorrect to assume that Romans 1:26-27 is a universal condemnation of lesbianism and homosexuality. The passage is specifically addressing the idolatrous practices of shrine prostitution, not consensual same-sex relationships.

Gay marriage is legal, but some churches refuse to officiate same-sex unions

The legalisation of same-sex marriage has been a contentious issue for many years, with religious institutions often at the centre of the debate. While some churches have welcomed the change, others have refused to officiate same-sex unions, citing religious doctrine as their reason for doing so.

The Christian Church

The Bible teaches that sexual practices between people of the same sex are sinful and that holy matrimony can only exist between people of different sexes. This interpretation has been contested, with some arguing that the Bible, when read in its original Hebrew and Greek, does not condemn homosexuality. Instead, it is argued that the Biblical references to homosexuality were made in the context of non-consensual and coercive sexual practices.

The disagreement between Christian leaders is centred on the interpretation of various scripture passages related to homosexuality, sacred tradition, and, in some churches, on varying understandings of homosexuality in terms of psychology, genetics, and other scientific data.

The Catholic Church

The Catholic Church has consistently opposed the legal recognition of same-sex unions, stating that it is gravely immoral for Catholic politicians to vote in favour of such legislation. The Church maintains that homosexual acts are "intrinsically disordered" and "sins gravely contrary to chastity". It teaches that marriage is instituted by God and can only exist between a man and a woman.

Other Religious Institutions

Other religious institutions have taken a more progressive stance, with a growing number of organised religious groups in the United States officially welcoming LGBTQ+ people as members and extending marriage rites to them. These include the Episcopal Church, the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, the Presbyterian Church (USA), the Unitarian Universalist Association, and the United Church of Christ, among others.

While gay marriage may be legal in some places, the refusal of certain churches to officiate same-sex unions highlights the ongoing tension between religious doctrine and societal changes. This tension is particularly pronounced in religious institutions that oppose gay marriage, as they navigate between their religious beliefs and the legal recognition of same-sex unions.

Some Christians believe lesbianism is a sin, but not all

Lesbianism is a topic that has been widely debated among Christians, with some believing it to be a sin and others not. While some Christians interpret certain Bible passages as condemning same-sex relationships, others argue that these verses are taken out of context and do not apply to loving, committed lesbian partnerships. This discrepancy in interpretation has led to differing views within Christianity regarding the sinfulness of lesbianism.

Those who consider lesbianism a sin often cite verses like Leviticus 18:22 and 20:13, which they interpret as prohibiting same-sex relationships. They view these verses as universally applicable, seeing lesbianism as a violation of God's design for human sexuality and a threat to traditional family structures. Some Christians, particularly those from more conservative denominations, hold strongly to this belief and actively oppose gay marriage, seeing it as a compromise of religious liberty. They may also worry about being perceived as bigoted or hateful due to their stance, but they maintain that their opposition stems from their religious beliefs rather than intolerance.

On the other hand, many Christians do not view lesbianism as a sin. They argue that the Bible, when interpreted correctly, does not condemn lesbian relationships. For instance, Rabbi Jacob Milgrom, a Jewish scholar, presents eight reasons why lesbians are not mentioned in Leviticus 18:22 and 20:13, including the absence of male penetration and the lack of risk associated with female-female sexuality in terms of procreation and paternity. Additionally, he highlights that ancient Jews did not understand these verses as referring to lesbianism, and that no Jewish rabbi linked them to same-sex female couples until the 12th century AD.

Another argument against the interpretation of these verses as condemning lesbianism is that they are addressed specifically to Jews and, even within that context, do not mention lesbianism. This suggests that lesbianism was not seen as a violation of Biblical law. Furthermore, some Christians argue that Paul's statement in Romans 1:26, which has been used to condemn homosexuality, is actually about idolatry and shrine prostitution, not same-sex relationships.

While there is a diversity of opinions among Christians, those who do not view lesbianism as a sin emphasize the importance of love, compassion, and non-judgment. They believe that God's love extends to all, regardless of sexual orientation, and that it is not their place to judge others. Instead, they focus on their own relationship with God and leave judgment to Him.

Some Christians believe that God created lesbianism

While some Christians believe that lesbianism is a sin, others argue that the Bible does not condemn it. In fact, some Christians believe that God created lesbianism. This interpretation stems from a careful examination of the Biblical text and its context.

Firstly, it is important to note that the Bible never mentions lesbians or lesbianism in a negative light. The verses often used by anti-gay Christians to condemn homosexuality refer to cult shrine temple prostitutes, who were pagan worshippers of the fertility goddess. These individuals were not lesbians or gay men. In fact, ancient Jews did not interpret these verses as prohibiting lesbianism. The absence of any mention of lesbianism in the Old Testament, despite the existence of lesbian communities, suggests that it was not considered a sin.

Secondly, lesbianism does not violate Biblical law in the same way that gay male partnerships are argued to do so. Lesbianism does not involve male penetration or the transfer of semen, which are key factors in the interpretation of verses in Leviticus. Additionally, lesbianism did not pose a threat to the family structure or paternity of children, as women were expected to marry men regardless.

Furthermore, lesbianism did not challenge male domination or the "manly honour" of women. The absence of male involvement meant that lesbian relationships were of less interest to the male authors of scripture, who focused primarily on male behaviour.

Rabbi Jacob Milgrom, a Jewish scholar, provides additional context. He argues that the prohibition against homosexual acts in Leviticus is specifically addressed to Jews and is not intended to be applied universally. He also highlights the fundamental difference between homosexual acts of men and women, with lesbianism not involving the "spilling of seed" and therefore not resulting in the symbolic loss of life.

In conclusion, some Christians believe that God created lesbianism and that it is not a sin. This belief is supported by a careful reading of the Bible, taking into account the historical and cultural context of the time. While there are varying interpretations of scripture, it is important to approach this topic with empathy and understanding, allowing individuals to form their own spiritual connections and relationships with God.

Frequently asked questions