Inappropriate Reading: Sinful Or Personal Choice?

Whether reading inappropriate things is a sin or not is a highly debated topic among Christians. Some Christians believe that reading erotic literature is a sin, as it is similar to watching pornography and can lead to immoral thoughts and actions. On the other hand, some Christians argue that sex is an important part of the human experience, and there is nothing inherently wrong with exploring it in literature as long as it does not become an obsession. Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to engage in such literature is a personal one, and Christians are advised to pray and seek guidance from God to make an informed decision.

Is reading erotic literature the same as watching porn?

There are differing opinions on whether reading erotic literature is the same as watching porn. Some people believe that both are imaginative acts, with men typically being more visually stimulated and women more imaginative. However, others argue that the two are ""morally equivalent".

Some sources suggest that reading erotic literature is not the same as watching porn, as reading is not the same as watching. However, written porn can have negative effects on readers, depending on the individual and the content. It can create unrealistic expectations for sex and normalise abusive behaviour. It can also affect the reader's brain and relationships in similar ways to watching porn, by introducing unrealistic and violent fantasies.

From a Christian perspective, some believe that reading erotic literature is a sin, as it is contrary to the things upon which a Christian is to think and meditate to glorify God. It is argued that erotic literature promotes lust, adultery and fornication, and does not promote the mind of Christ.

On the other hand, some Christians argue that erotic literature is permissible if it is not violent and is profitable, edifying and done for the glory of God. They suggest that it is important to consider whether the content is true, honourable, just, pure, lovely, commendable, excellent and worthy of praise.

Can reading explicit content lead to a corrupt, ungodly mind?

The Bible has several references that can be used to argue that reading explicit content can lead to a corrupt, ungodly mind. In Philippians 4:8, Paul laid out instructions that can help guard our minds: "whatever is true, whatever is honorable, whatever is just, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is commendable, if there is any excellence, if there is anything worthy of praise, think about these things." Similarly, in Proverbs 4:23, we are told to "guard your heart, for everything you do flows from it."

The Gospel of Christ states that reading explicit content is sinful because it is contrary to the things upon which a Christian is to think and meditate to glorify God. The descriptive scenes of fornication and uncleanness in these books are very detailed and erotic. They are meant to arouse the works of the flesh in the reader, promoting lust, adultery, and fornication. Reading and thinking about these things do not promote the mind of Christ.

Additionally, according to Marshall Segal of Desiring God, reading such content "might feel like a fun and harmless fantasy, but it’s not so subtly redefining the power and beauty of sex, creating spiritual blockages in your heart…and impairing your ability to enjoy real and lasting pleasure."

Furthermore, reading explicit content can lead to unrealistic expectations, which can create dissatisfaction and challenges in future romantic partnerships. It can also hinder the development of critical thinking skills, leading to impulsive decisions and engagement in risky behaviors.

However, it is important to note that the interpretation of what constitutes "explicit content" may vary among individuals and religious denominations.

Is it permissible for a Christian to occasionally enjoy erotic reading?

There is a range of views on whether it is permissible for a Christian to occasionally enjoy erotic reading. Some Christians believe that reading erotic literature is a sin, as it is considered pornographic and can lead to immoral thoughts and behaviours. This view is supported by several Bible passages, including Matthew 5:28, where Jesus says that "any man who looks at a woman with lustful intent has already committed adultery with her in his heart".

However, other Christians argue that sex is an important part of the human experience, and there is nothing inherently wrong with exploring it in literature. They believe that as long as the erotic reading is not pornographic or violent, and it is not the main focus of the literature, it can be acceptable. This view is supported by the inclusion of erotic love poetry in the Song of Solomon in the Bible.

Some Christians suggest that the key consideration is the intention behind the reading. If the erotic literature is being read with the sole intention of sexual arousal, it is likely to be considered a sin. However, if it is being read as part of a serious work of literature or to explore human sexuality in a healthy way, it may be permissible.

Ultimately, the decision of whether to engage in erotic reading is a personal one for Christians, and they may need to pray and reflect on whether it aligns with their values and beliefs.

What is the difference between erotica and pornography?

The distinction between erotica and pornography is highly subjective and often misunderstood. However, there are some key differences to note.

Erotica is a broad term that encompasses any depiction (visual, tactile, aural, olfactory, etc.) that aims to elicit a sexual response, usually muted. It often uses inference, imagery, and symbolism to suggest sexual actions rather than explicitly depicting them. Erotica is typically considered more tasteful and acceptable, often viewed as an artistic expression of sexuality. It can include written fiction of a sexual nature, but it may also include visual or auditory elements.

Pornography, on the other hand, is often seen as "stronger" than erotica. It usually involves a direct and graphic description or depiction of sexual activity, focusing on explicit and realistic details. Pornography is primarily intended to stimulate sexual release rather than exploration or emotional connection. It is often associated with crude or immoral content and is typically viewed as a means to satisfy libido. While pornography usually refers to visual or video content, it can also include written materials.

In terms of intent, erotica tends to be sexually suggestive and evocative, drawing the audience into an embrace of sexuality. Pornography, on the other hand, aims for a more direct physical response, providing explicit content designed to lead the audience to a physical climax.

It's worth noting that the line between erotica and pornography is blurry and can vary depending on individual perspectives and moral codes. Some people may consider certain materials erotic, while others may view them as pornographic. Additionally, the context and cultural norms play a role in shaping these definitions. For example, in Germany, "Erotik" spans a wide range of artistic interpretations, including nude bodies, simulated sex acts, and what Americans typically refer to as "softcore porn".

From a religious perspective, some Christians consider reading erotic or pornographic books sinful, as it contradicts the values of purity and glorifying God. They believe that such materials arouse lustful thoughts and promote behaviours that clash with a faithful Christian life.

Is it a sin to read books with sexual content?

There are a variety of views on whether it is a sin to read books with sexual content. Some Christians believe that reading erotic literature is a sin as it is considered pornographic, and written with the intention to titillate and arouse the reader. This view holds that such literature promotes lust and adultery, and is contrary to the values of Christian faith.

However, there are differing opinions on this matter. Some believe that reading about sex and exploring it in literature is not inherently wrong, and that it is a natural part of the human experience. Others suggest that reading erotic literature is acceptable as long as it is not done with the intention of sexual arousal.

Some Christians also differentiate between erotic literature and works of serious literature that contain sexual content. They argue that it is acceptable to skip over sexual passages in a book that is not primarily focused on sexual content. This view holds that Christians should use their judgement and be vigilant about what they expose their minds to, but that it is not necessary to avoid all literature with sexual content.

The Bible offers some guidance on this matter, with some interpreting passages such as Philippians 4:8 as instructing Christians to focus their thoughts on what is "true, honourable, just, pure, lovely, commendable, excellent, and worthy of praise". However, the interpretation of these passages and their application to literature with sexual content is a matter of individual belief and context.

Frequently asked questions