Childfree Catholics: Sin Or Personal Choice?

The Catholic Church teaches that the primary purpose of sex is procreation, with the unitive aspect being secondary. This means that, while a couple need not intend to have a child every time they have sex, they must never actively impede the possibility of conception. This is known as Natural Family Planning (NFP) and is considered acceptable by the Church. However, the Church does not condone the use of contraception or other artificial means of birth control. While it is not considered a sin to not have children, it is considered sinful to actively avoid having children.

Natural family planning (NFP)

NFP is an umbrella term for certain methods used to achieve and avoid conception. These methods are based on the observation of the naturally occurring signs and symptoms of the fertile and infertile phases of a woman's menstrual cycle. No drugs, devices, or surgical procedures are used to avoid pregnancy.

There are three main types of NFP: symptom-based methods, calendar-based methods, and the breastfeeding or lactational amenorrhea method. Symptom-based methods rely on biological signs of fertility, while calendar-based methods estimate the likelihood of fertility based on the length of past menstrual cycles. The lactational amenorrhea method (LAM) is a method of avoiding pregnancy based on the natural postpartum infertility that occurs when a woman is amenorrheic and fully breastfeeding.

NFP reflects the dignity of the human person within the context of marriage and family life, promotes openness to life, and recognizes the value of the child. By respecting the love-giving and life-giving natures of marriage, NFP can enrich the bond between husband and wife. It calls for shared responsibility, is based on scientific research, treats each menstrual cycle as unique, and has no harmful side effects.

The Catholic Church considers the use of contraception to be against God's will for Catholic marriage as it interrupts the procreative aspect of the sexual union, making it unnatural. However, the Church allows for periodic abstinence, which is deemed moral for avoiding or postponing pregnancy for just reasons. Couples may engage in sexual intercourse during a woman's naturally occurring infertile times, such as during portions of her ovulatory cycle.

Effectiveness can vary depending on the method used, the quality of training, and how carefully the couple follows the protocol. While NFP is a valid approach to family planning within the Catholic Church, it is important to note that it is not a form of contraception and should not be used indefinitely to avoid pregnancy without a valid reason.

Contraception and the Catholic Church

The Catholic Church's stance on contraception has been a topic of debate for decades, with the Church hierarchy consistently opposing all forms of artificial birth control. This position was solidified in 1968 with the publication of the encyclical Humanae Vitae by Pope Paul VI, which stated that artificial birth control methods could lead to "marital infidelity and a general lowering of moral standards." Despite this, a majority of Catholics have used some form of birth control in their lives, with 98% of Catholics in the United States having used contraception at some point. This discrepancy between the Church's teachings and the practices of its followers has led to a stand against the hierarchy by ordinary Catholics, who argue that birth control is a "lifeline" rather than a sin.

The Church's opposition to contraception stems from its belief that the primary end of sexual intercourse is procreation, with the unitive aspect being secondary. According to this view, while a couple need not always intend to procreate, they must never actively impede the sexual act from being ordered toward producing a child. This belief is reflected in the Church's endorsement of natural family planning (NFP) methods, which allow couples to avoid pregnancy during the woman's infertile periods without using artificial barriers.

However, the acceptance of NFP among Catholics is not unanimous. Some argue that using NFP to avoid having children indefinitely is a sin and that it should only be used to space out pregnancies for legitimate "grave" concerns. There is also a recognition that not everyone is capable of raising children, whether due to mental, emotional, or financial instability. In such cases, abstinence is recommended until the couple is ready to be open to the possibility of pregnancy.

The Church's stance on contraception has had a significant impact globally, especially in efforts to contain HIV/AIDS in Africa. Despite scientific evidence that condoms are critical in HIV prevention, the Vatican has refused to relax its ban on contraceptives, stating that abstinence is the only morally acceptable way to avoid HIV outside of marriage. This position has been criticised by pro-choice advocacy groups, who argue that the ban has detrimental effects on global health.

While the Catholic Church's teachings on contraception remain unchanged, the complex interplay between religious doctrine and individual conscience continues to shape the attitudes and practices of Catholics worldwide.

The Church's stance on birth control

The Catholic Church's stance on birth control has been one of constant change and development over the course of its history. While Catholic moral theology has consistently condemned contraception, it has not always been a church battleground as it is today.

The Church teaches that the sexual act itself must always have its intrinsic ordering toward the generation of children. This means that couples can never do anything to intentionally thwart the procreative end of sex, since procreation is what sex is for. To do so would be to violate human nature, and thus to violate God’s will.

In 1968, Pope Paul VI banned contraception for Catholics in the encyclical "Humanae Vitae". This prohibited all forms of artificial birth control, including condoms, diaphragms, the rhythm method, and the withdrawal method. The only acceptable form of birth control was abstinence.

However, the Church does allow for natural family planning (NFP), where couples can have sex during the woman's infertile periods if they have just reasons for not wanting to have children at a particular time. NFP is considered acceptable because it does not frustrate nature’s design for sex, and because the woman’s infertility during this time is due to nature, not human intervention.

Childless by choice

The Catholic Church teaches that procreation and child-rearing are the primary ends of sex, with the unitive aspect being secondary. This means that while a couple need not intend to have a child with every act of sexual intercourse, they may never actively impede the possibility of producing a child. This is called Natural Family Planning (NFP) and is considered acceptable by the Church.

The Church's position is that the sexual act itself must always retain its intrinsic ordering toward the generation of children. To intentionally thwart the procreative end of sex would be to violate human nature and, thus, to violate God's will.

However, if a couple has just reasons for not having children at a particular time, they may express their love through sexual intercourse during the woman's infertile periods. This is considered acceptable as it does not frustrate nature's design for sex and, therefore, is in agreement with God's will.

While the Church teaches that marriage should be open to life, it is not considered a sin to not have children. It is, however, considered a sin to actively prevent conception through artificial means.

The Church's teaching on this matter is summarised as follows: "Being open to life is an intrinsic requirement of married love." This means that no married couple should intentionally remove the possibility of having children.

The desire not to have children is often seen as a result of a hedonistic, narcissistic society that glorifies individual accomplishments and views children as burdensome. However, the Church teaches that children are always a gift and should be welcomed as a priority, as they open up new dimensions in family life.

The biblical view of parenthood

Parenthood is a sacred responsibility in the Bible, with children viewed as a gift from God and entrusted to parents for their nurture and development. The Bible outlines several key principles for effective biblical parenting, which I will now explore in detail.

Perspective, Priorities, and Purpose of the Home

According to Psalm 127:3-5, children are a gift from God, and parents are tasked with raising them from dependence to independence so they can eventually leave the family and live their own lives. This perspective helps parents avoid unbiblical attitudes such as possessiveness, overprotectiveness, and living vicariously through their children. Instead, the focus should be on providing a stable and loving environment that prepares them for adulthood and their relationship with God.

Spiritual and Personal Development

Deuteronomy 6 outlines a program for spiritual development, emphasizing the importance of parents' relationship with God and their ability to impart spiritual truths to their children. Parents are to be living models of Christian values, teaching their children through both example and instruction. This includes sharing experiences of God's work in their lives and integrating the Word of God into their daily conversations.

Evangelism and Discipleship

Parents are responsible for evangelizing and discipling their children, praying for them, and guiding them towards a personal relationship with Christ. This involves teaching them biblical values, helping them develop their own walk with the Lord, and instructing them in the way of the Lord.

Discipline and Instruction

Biblical parenting requires a balance of discipline and love. While discipline is crucial, it must be administered in a way that does not provoke or embitter children (Colossians 3:21). Positive reinforcement and rewards are encouraged, while negative practices such as humiliation, perfectionism, withdrawal of affection, and anger are to be avoided. Discipline should be fair, consistent, and administered with love, teaching children to respect authority and make wise decisions.

Family Worship and Recreation

Family worship and recreation are essential elements of Christian growth and family unity. Spending time together, whether in devotional activities or shared interests and hobbies, strengthens family bonds and provides a context for spiritual growth. Recreation renews and restores the family, adding vitality and joy to their relationships.

Sex Education

Parents have a responsibility to provide accurate and healthy sex education to their children, teaching them about their bodies, sexuality, and biblical values. This is crucial in a culture where children are exposed to distorted information and immoral values from various media sources. Open and honest communication about sexuality, within a biblical framework, is essential to counter these influences.

In conclusion, biblical parenthood is a high calling that involves nurturing, teaching, disciplining, and guiding children towards spiritual maturity and a personal relationship with God. It requires a delicate balance of discipline, love, instruction, and practical examples of Christian values in action.

Frequently asked questions