Atheist And Believer: Can They Be Friends?

Is it a sin for Christians to be friends with atheists? This is a question that has been asked by many Christians, especially those who have found themselves in close relationships with non-believers. While some Christians may feel conflicted about having atheist friends, others have found that building positive relationships with people of different beliefs can be a rewarding and enriching experience. Ultimately, the decision to be friends with an atheist is a personal one, and there is no clear-cut answer as to whether it is a sin or not. However, it is worth exploring the perspectives of both Christians and atheists on this topic to gain a deeper understanding of the complexities involved.

Atheists can be good people

However, some Christians on the same forum expressed discomfort at the idea of being friends with non-Christians. One user said that they would feel conflicted about being friends with an atheist because they want to "live a holy Christian life". Another user said that they would not want to be friends with an atheist if that person had "ulterior motives" such as trying to "spread the gospel".

Atheists can certainly have a sense of morality and be "good" people. In fact, one atheist on a Reddit forum recounted a story about how they had convinced a Christian that atheists can have a sense of morality, even without God as their guide. During the conversation, the Christian in question refused to admit that things like slavery and genocide were bad because, as a human, they were not qualified to judge. They even said that they would kill 42 children if God commanded it because "it's better than going to hell". This demonstrates that a belief in God does not automatically make someone a "good person" and that atheists are capable of making their own moral judgements.

In response to the question "What are some good principles with which to ground ethics in an atheist framework?", another user on the same forum suggested empathy as a starting point for morality. They also said that "suffering is the top thing that people avoid" and that preventing suffering is therefore a good moral principle. Another user suggested that atheists could ground their ethics in "human well-being".

Christians believe some weird stuff

It's easy to forget when you're a Christian, but some of the things we believe can sound pretty strange to non-Christians. For example, the idea of eating Jesus' flesh and blood, or that Jesus is both God and God's Son, and that he had to be tortured and killed to save us from our sins. These are core tenets of the faith, but when you take a step back, it's easy to see how they might sound odd to outsiders.

Another example is the concept of the Trinity: the idea that God is one being, but exists in three distinct Persons (Father, Son, and Holy Spirit). This is a fundamental mystery of the Christian faith, but it can be challenging to wrap your head around and may seem peculiar to those outside the faith.

Then there's the idea of original sin and the fall of humanity. Christians believe that due to the disobedience of Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden, all humans are born into a state of sin and separation from God. This doctrine forms the basis for the need for salvation through Jesus Christ, but it can seem like a rather grim view of human nature to those outside the faith.

Additionally, Christians hold certain beliefs about the end times and the second coming of Christ that can seem unusual. Ideas like the Rapture, the Antichrist, and the Battle of Armageddon are all part of Christian eschatology, but they can sound quite fantastical to those who don't share these beliefs.

Finally, there's the notion of heaven and hell. Christians believe in an afterlife where people will either spend eternity in heaven with God or suffer in hell, separated from God. While this doctrine provides hope and motivation for living a righteous life, it can also seem like a rather extreme concept to those who don't share these beliefs.

Christians have a bad reputation

Christians are called to be known by their love, but instead, they are labelled as judgmental, intolerant, and close-minded. Biblical stances can be politically incorrect, and in a "cancel culture", some are hesitant to identify with the faith.

Christians also have a bad reputation because of the association with political actors. In the US, for example, the majority of Evangelicals voted for Donald Trump, who is seen as taking away the rights of others and creating minority rule.

Atheists doubt their beliefs sometimes

However, it is important to distinguish atheism from agnosticism. Agnostics leave open the question of whether a god exists, professing that the matter is unanswered or unanswerable. In contrast, atheists actively deny the existence of a god, believing it to be false or highly improbable. This distinction highlights the spectrum of doubt and certainty within atheism. Some atheists may be more ardent in their non-belief, similar to fundamentalists in their faith.

Additionally, it is worth noting that atheism is not limited to the rejection of monotheistic religions like Christianity, Islam, and Judaism. It also encompasses the denial of spiritual beings and religious beliefs in polytheistic and non-theistic traditions, such as classical Greece and Rome, Hinduism, and Buddhism.

When considering friendship between Christians and atheists, it is essential to respect each other's beliefs (or lack thereof). While some Christians may struggle with doubt, atheists also experience doubt about their non-belief at times. This shared capacity for doubt can serve as a point of connection and understanding between Christians and atheists, fostering meaningful relationships and mutual growth.

Atheism takes some guts

Atheists have to face life's challenges without the comfort of believing in a higher power or divine intervention. They have to find strength and purpose within themselves, which can be daunting, especially during difficult times. Atheists have to rely on their own resources and inner fortitude to persevere through hardships. It is a testament to their resilience and determination to face life's struggles without the assurance of divine support.

Additionally, atheists often face social challenges due to their lack of religious affiliation. In many parts of the world, religion plays a significant role in people's lives, and atheists may feel isolated or excluded from certain communities. They may have to deal with judgment, discrimination, or even ostracism from religious individuals or groups. Standing firm in their non-belief despite potential social consequences requires courage and conviction.

Furthermore, atheists often embrace a rational and critical thinking approach to understanding the world. They seek truth and knowledge through scientific inquiry, philosophical exploration, and logical reasoning. This intellectual journey can be demanding and may involve constant questioning and skepticism. Atheists must have the courage to challenge established ideas, religious doctrines, and societal norms. They must be willing to forge their own path, even if it means going against the grain.

Atheists also grapple with existential questions and the uncertainty of not knowing what lies beyond this life. They face the unknown without the comfort of religious dogma or the promise of an afterlife. They must confront the finite nature of human existence and make sense of their place in the universe without relying on supernatural explanations. This requires a certain bravery and willingness to embrace the unknown.

Lastly, atheists often face the challenge of finding like-minded individuals who share their worldview. Building a supportive community of atheist friends can be difficult, especially in regions where religious beliefs are prevalent. Atheists must be courageous enough to seek out these connections, foster secular communities, and create their own support systems.

In conclusion, atheism indeed takes some guts. Atheists face life's challenges without the comfort of religious belief, relying solely on their inner strength and resilience. They navigate social pressures, embrace critical thinking, confront existential questions, and seek out like-minded communities. Their courage and determination to forge their own path, guided by reason and conviction, are admirable qualities that should not be underestimated.

Frequently asked questions