Ignorance: A Sinful Trait Or Not?

Is ignorance a sin? This question has been contemplated by many, with some arguing that ignorance is not a choice and therefore cannot be a sin. However, others argue that in an era of readily available information, ignorance is becoming a choice, blurring the lines of sinfulness. The Bible acknowledges sins of ignorance, but it is important to distinguish between unintentional sins and those committed with knowledge of wrongdoing. While ignorance may not be a sin in itself, it can lead to sinful behaviour and is considered an obstacle to becoming more fully human in God's image.

Sins of ignorance are still sins

While ignorance is not one of the seven deadly sins, it is still considered a sin in some contexts. In the Bible, there are mentions of "sins of ignorance", referring to sins committed without awareness.

In the Catholic tradition, sin typically refers to a free act of the will against God, other people, or the cosmos, for which one incurs guilt. Ignorance, however, is not a choice, and therefore cannot be a sin. It is, however, considered an obstacle to becoming more fully human in God's image and lays the groundwork for sin. As such, living in ignorance is connected to sinful behaviour.

In Luke 12:47-48, Jesus speaks of "readiness" and being ready when the Lord comes. He differentiates between two types of slaves: the one who knew his master's will but did not act accordingly, and the one who did not know his master's will but still acted in a way that deserved punishment. Both slaves are guilty and will be punished, but the one who knew his master's will shall receive many lashes, while the ignorant slave will receive few. This implies that even though ignorance is not a sin, those who are ignorant should still take responsibility and make an effort to learn God's will.

In Leviticus 4, there are instructions regarding "unintentional sin", which can be interpreted as sins committed in ignorance or without understanding that an action was against God's will. In such cases, sacrifices were required to obtain forgiveness from God. While ignorance did not excuse sin, it could mitigate the punishment.

Therefore, while ignorance in itself may not be a sin, it is still connected to sinfulness and can lead to sinful behaviour. It is important for individuals to seek knowledge and understanding of God's will to avoid committing sins of ignorance.

Ignorance is not a choice

While the Bible does refer to "sins of ignorance", ignorance in itself is not a choice and therefore cannot be a sin. In the Catholic tradition, sin usually refers to a free act of the will against God, other people, or the world, for which we incur guilt. However, ignorance is the foundation for human complicity in structural sin and evil.

Living in ignorance, however, is connected to sinful behaviour. Ignorance can enable our sinful habits and lead us to become spiritually and morally stunted adults who have habits of injuring others. Once we become aware of the consequences of our actions, we are no longer fully ignorant, and as we know better, we are freer to choose either good or sin.

Ignorance is more similar to what the Christian tradition calls "original sin". In Eastern traditions, influenced by theologians such as St. Gregory of Nyssa and St. Maximus the Confessor, original sin is often connected to the darkness of ignorance into which we are born and that we must overcome through the light of Christ.

As part of original sin, ignorance can lead us to sin and inflict harm. But it is a part of being human that we must accept and attempt to overcome through Christ’s light and the wisdom of our teachers and elders in the faith.

Ignorance is an obstacle to becoming more fully human

Ignorance is not a sin in itself. In the Catholic tradition, sin is usually defined as a free act of the will against God, other people, or the cosmos, for which we incur guilt. Ignorance is not a choice, and therefore cannot be a sin. We are all ignorant to some extent. However, living in ignorance is connected to sinful behaviour. Ignorance is the foundation for human complicity in structural sin and evil.

In the Bible, Jesus speaks about "readiness" in Luke chapter 12, verses 47 and 48. Here, he differentiates between the slave who knew his master's will and the one who did not. Both slaves are guilty and receive punishment, but the slave who knew his master's will is punished more severely. This suggests that those who have been given more knowledge and understanding are expected to use it to do God's will.

While ignorance is not a sin, willful ignorance is considered sinful by some. In an age of easily accessible information, many ignorant people actively avoid gaining knowledge, making ignorance a choice rather than an unavoidable condition.

Additionally, the Bible makes provisions for those who sin in ignorance. Leviticus 4 outlines God's provision for those who sinned unintentionally or in ignorance, and Numbers 15:22-29 gives details about the special sacrifices required to obtain forgiveness in such cases. However, ignorance does not excuse sin, as seen in Leviticus 5:17: "If someone sins and violates any of the Lord's commandments even though he was unaware, he is still guilty and shall bear his punishment."

Ignorance is the foundation for human complicity in sin and evil

Ignorance itself is not a sin. In the Catholic tradition, sin is usually defined as a free act of the will against God, other people, or the cosmos, for which guilt is incurred. Ignorance is not a choice, and therefore, it cannot be a sin. However, ignorance can lead to sinful behaviour.

Living in ignorance is linked to sinful behaviour. Ignorance is the foundation for human complicity in structural sin and evil. This includes white supremacy, patriarchy, homophobia, economic exploitation, ecological devastation, consumerism, denigration of life, and what Pope Francis calls a "throwaway culture". Ignorance can enable sinful habits and lead to spiritual and moral stunting, resulting in the injury of others.

While ignorance is not a sin, it can be argued that willful ignorance is. In the modern era, with the widespread availability of information, ignorance is increasingly becoming a choice. People can now easily access information and educate themselves, but some choose not to. This choice to remain ignorant can be considered sinful.

Additionally, the Bible acknowledges "sins of ignorance", where people commit sins that they are unaware of. For example, Leviticus 4 outlines God's provision for those who sinned unintentionally or in ignorance, requiring special sacrifices for atonement. While ignorance does not excuse sin, it can mitigate the punishment. The punishment for unintentional sin was less severe than that for deliberate rebellion or blasphemy.

In conclusion, while ignorance itself is not a sin, it can lead to sinful behaviour and complicity in structural sin and evil. The availability of information in the modern era makes ignorance a choice, and choosing to remain ignorant can be considered sinful.

Ignorance is not an adequate excuse for sin

The Bible acknowledges that "sins of ignorance" exist, or, in other words, sins that people are unaware they are committing. However, ignorance does not excuse sin.

In the Old Testament, Leviticus 5:17 states: "If someone sins and violates any of the Lord's commandments even though he was unaware, he is still guilty and shall bear his punishment." This is reiterated in Numbers 15:22–29, which outlines the special sacrifices required to obtain forgiveness from God when someone has sinned in ignorance.

In the New Testament, Luke 12:47–48, Jesus says: "The servant who knows the master's will and does not get ready or does not do what the master wants will be beaten with many blows. But the one who does not know and does things deserving punishment will be beaten with few blows." Here, Jesus distinguishes between those who sin with knowledge of their wrongdoing and those who sin in ignorance. While both are guilty and will be punished, the punishment is lighter for those who act in ignorance.

The Bible also makes clear that ignorance is not an excuse for not believing in God. Romans 1:20 states that there is no excuse for not believing in God's existence as "the invisible qualities of God are 'clearly seen' in creation."

While ignorance is not a sin in itself, it can lead to sinful behaviour. It is considered an obstacle to becoming more fully human in God's image and can enable sinful habits to form. As people become less ignorant, they are freer to choose between good and sin.

In summary, while ignorance may not be a sin, it is also not an adequate excuse for sin. People are expected to take responsibility for their ignorance and learn God's will.

Frequently asked questions