Hitting Parents: Catholic Sin Or Not?

Hitting one's parents is not explicitly mentioned as a sin in Catholic doctrine, but the Bible does state to “honour thy father and thy mother. The Catechism of the Catholic Church defines grave matter as specified by the Ten Commandments, which include honour thy father and thy mother. Therefore, it can be inferred that hitting one's parents would be considered a grave sin, or mortal sin, in Catholic theology. However, it is important to note that the Church also teaches that unintentional ignorance can diminish or even remove the imputability of a grave offense and that sin committed through malice, by deliberate choice of evil, is the gravest. Thus, the context and intent behind the act of hitting one's parents would also need to be considered when determining if it constitutes a mortal sin.

Hitting parents is a grievous sin

Hitting your parents is considered a grievous sin in the Catholic faith. According to the Catholic Answers Encyclopedia, children who strike their parents, or even raise their hands to do so, commit a grievous sin. This is based on the interpretation of the Fourth Commandment, "Honor thy father and thy mother," which is understood to mean not only respect and submission but also the manifestation of affection that children owe their parents.

The concept of "pietas," or dutiful observance, further emphasizes the obligation of children towards their parents. This virtue, as explained by St. Thomas, inculcates the attitude of reverence, love, and obedience that children should hold towards their parents, who are considered delegates of God. Therefore, any form of physical violence against parents is seen as a grave violation of this duty.

Additionally, the Catechism of the Catholic Church states that children should obey their parents in all matters that are reasonable and good for their well-being or that of the family. While this obligation of obedience typically ceases when children reach adulthood or are legally emancipated, the duty of respect towards parents remains lifelong.

It is worth noting that the duty of respect and honor is not unilateral. Parents also have responsibilities towards their children, including the duty to love and care for them, provide for their education, and correct them when necessary. Mutual respect and honor between parents and children are essential in upholding the values taught by the Catholic Church.

Striking parents is forbidden by the Fourth Commandment

The Fourth Commandment, "Honor thy father and thy mother", is interpreted by the Catholic Church as meaning that children must show respect, submission, and affection to their parents. This obligation is enjoined by the virtue which St. Thomas calls "pietas", or dutiful observance. The violation of this obligation is considered a grievous sin.

Striking one's parents is explicitly forbidden by the Fourth Commandment. Children who strike their parents, or even raise their hands to do so, are guilty of grievous sin. This interpretation of the Fourth Commandment is based on the Christian concept of parents as being the delegates of God, which carries with it the inference that they are to be treated with peculiar respect.

The duty of children to honour their parents is not absolute, however. While children are obliged to obey their parents in matters pertaining to their proper rearing, parents have no power to order their children to do what is sinful. Moreover, obedience to parents ceases when children pass from under parental authority, typically when they attain their majority or are legally emancipated. Nonetheless, even after emancipation, children are still bound to respect their parents.

In addition to the Fourth Commandment, the duty of children to honour their parents is also rooted in the natural law, which clearly inculcates the duty of parents to love their children. This duty is so fundamental that parents who lack this affection are considered unnatural. The natural law also imposes on parents the duty to diligently care for the proper rearing of their children, providing for their bodily, mental, and spiritual well-being. Parents who treat their children with cruelty, or who exhibit unreasonable preferences for one child over another, are guilty of grievous sin.

Children must obey parents, but only when it doesn't cause harm

The Catholic Church teaches that children have a threefold obligation of love, reverence, and obedience toward their parents. This is based on the Fourth Commandment, "Honor thy father and thy mother," which is interpreted to mean respect, submission, and the manifestation of affection. However, this does not mean that children should obey their parents at all costs.

The duty of obedience is limited to matters that contribute to the proper rearing of the child. Parents have no power to command their children to do something sinful or impose a particular life path on them. Theologians consider the gravity of the matter when determining if disobedience is a mortal or venial sin. If an act of disobedience seriously harms parents, disrupts domestic discipline, or jeopardizes the child's temporal or spiritual welfare, it is considered a mortal sin.

In cases of abuse, children are not obligated to maintain contact with their parents. While hating anyone is considered a sin, it is not sinful to distance oneself from abusive parents or to take steps to protect oneself. The Bible also instructs parents not to provoke their children to anger.

While the Church emphasizes the importance of filial obedience, it is not without limits. Children must obey their parents, but only when it does not cause harm or require them to act against their conscience.

Children must respect parents, even after emancipation

Catholicism teaches that children have a threefold obligation of love, reverence, and obedience toward their parents. This is derived from the virtue that St. Thomas calls "pietas", which is translated as "dutiful observance". As children grow up, they should continue to respect their parents, seek their advice, and accept their admonitions. While obedience towards parents ceases with the child's emancipation, respect is always owed to them.

The Bible states, "Honor thy father and thy mother, as the LORD thy God hath commanded thee" (Deuteronomy 5:16a). Disrespectful actions of children are abhorred by God. Children who strike their parents, give them reason for great sorrow, or refuse to recognize them are considered to be committing grievous sins.

However, it is important to note that the duty of love and respect is not one-sided. Parents also have obligations towards their children. They must love their children, provide for their bodily, mental, and spiritual well-being, and diligently care for their proper rearing. Parents who treat their children with cruelty, exhibit notable and unreasonable preferences among their children, or fail to provide for their basic needs are guilty of grievous sins.

In cases of abuse or mistreatment by parents, children are allowed to distance themselves and are not obligated to maintain contact. While hating anyone, including parents, is considered a sin, it is understood that forgiveness does not always entail reconciliation or continued interaction.

In summary, children, even after emancipation, are expected to respect their parents and honor them by seeking their advice and accepting their admonitions. However, this does not mean that children should tolerate abuse or cruelty from their parents. The obligation of respect is meant to be reciprocated by parents through their loving care and provision for their children's well-being.

Parents must also respect their children

Parents have a duty to love their children and provide for their bodily, mental, and spiritual well-being. This includes ensuring their children receive an elementary education and religious instruction. Parents are also responsible for correcting their children when they err.

However, parents must not abuse their authority or use it to justify cruel or hateful treatment of their children. They must not neglect their children or exhibit an unreasonable preference for one child over another.

Children, in turn, are expected to honour and respect their parents, even into adulthood. This includes obeying their parents' rules and commands, as long as these commands are not sinful. Children should also care for their parents in old age, providing for their material, emotional, psychological, and spiritual needs.

The relationship between parents and children is a sacred bond that should be nurtured and respected by both parties. While children are expected to obey and honour their parents, parents also have a duty of care and respect towards their children, creating a stable and loving environment for them to grow and mature.

Parents should lead by example, demonstrating virtue and genuine goodness so that their children can look up to them and admire them. This will foster a healthy dynamic of honour and respect from their children.

As children grow into young adults, the dynamic shifts. While they still need to respect their parents, they also need to be allowed to take on more responsibility for their lives, making their own decisions about friends, careers, and other aspects of adult life.

In summary, the Catholic view of family life emphasises the mutual respect and honour that should be present between parents and children. While children are expected to obey and honour their parents, parents also have a duty of care and respect towards their children, creating a stable and loving environment for them to grow and mature.

Frequently asked questions