Helplessness: An Emotion Or A State Of Mind?

Feeling helpless is a common experience, often accompanied by anxiety and depression. It can be caused by traumatic events, grief, stress, mental health conditions, or other factors. Helplessness can manifest as a sense of being unable to act or react to a negative situation, and it can have significant mental health consequences. It is characterised by feelings of powerlessness, paralysis, and devastation. This emotion can be understood through the concept of learned helplessness, which occurs when individuals are repeatedly exposed to uncontrollable stressors or traumatic events, leading them to believe they have no control over their circumstances. While it is a challenging emotion to navigate, there are strategies such as psychotherapy, self-care, and social support that can help individuals cope with and move beyond feelings of helplessness.

Learned helplessness

Feeling helpless is a common human emotion, often accompanied by anxiety and depression. While it is a natural feeling in certain circumstances, it can be challenging to work through. Helplessness can manifest as a sense of powerlessness, feeling frozen in time, and unable to change what is happening.

In humans, learned helplessness is often the result of experiencing stress or trauma. It is frequently seen in individuals who have experienced repeated traumatic events such as childhood neglect, abuse, or domestic violence. It can also be observed in children with unreliable or unresponsive caregivers, leading to a poor sense of personal agency. Overparenting can also contribute to learned helplessness, as children who are not allowed to try things independently may believe they are unable to do things and, therefore, put forth no effort.

To overcome learned helplessness, individuals can benefit from interventions such as therapy, particularly cognitive-behavioural therapy (CBT). CBT helps individuals identify negative thought patterns and replace them with more optimistic and rational thoughts. Additionally, self-care strategies such as exercise, adequate sleep, stress management, and a healthy diet can foster a greater sense of control over one's life. Building a support network and seeking social encouragement can also help individuals feel more motivated and encouraged to keep trying.

Trauma and its effects

Trauma can be defined as an event or circumstance that results in serious injury, harm, or the threat of harm or injury to an individual. Trauma can affect an individual's emotional, physical, cognitive, behavioural, social, and spiritual well-being. It is important to note that trauma has no boundaries and can affect anyone regardless of age, gender, socioeconomic status, race, ethnicity, or sexual orientation.

Emotional and Cognitive Effects of Trauma

Trauma can have a significant impact on an individual's emotional and cognitive state. Emotional reactions to trauma vary greatly and are influenced by the individual's sociocultural history. Common emotional responses include anger, fear, sadness, shame, guilt, and a sense of betrayal. Cognitive effects of trauma include changes in thought patterns, such as feeling incompetent, damaged, or unsafe. Trauma can also lead to cognitive errors, such as misinterpreting situations as dangerous, and intrusive thoughts and memories associated with the traumatic event.

Physical Effects of Trauma

Trauma can also manifest in physical symptoms, including aches and pains, changes in eating habits and sleep patterns, and dizziness or changes in vision. Additionally, trauma can lead to an increase in stress levels, with elevated cortisol and adrenaline hormones released by the body.

Behavioural Effects of Trauma

Trauma can affect an individual's behaviour in various ways. Some people may engage in avoidant or self-medicating behaviours, such as substance abuse, to cope with the trauma. Others may exhibit self-harming or impulsive behaviours as a way to manage their emotional distress. Trauma can also lead to a sense of learned helplessness, where individuals feel unable to control or change their situation.

Social and Interpersonal Effects of Trauma

Trauma often disrupts relationships and social connections. Survivors may pull away from others, feeling ashamed of their stress reactions or fearing that they cannot predict their own behaviour. Trauma can also lead to increased bonding with family and community, as individuals seek support and a sense of belonging.

Long-Term Effects of Trauma

The effects of trauma can be long-lasting and may come and go over time. Individuals may experience difficulties in various aspects of their lives, including self-care, maintaining relationships, understanding their traumatic experience through a religious lens, and enjoying leisure activities. Trauma can also have a serious impact on an individual's ability to work and function effectively in different areas of their life.

In conclusion, trauma can have far-reaching consequences on multiple aspects of an individual's life, and it is important to recognise and address these effects to promote healing and recovery.

The biological basis of helplessness

Helplessness is the belief that one lacks agency in a situation. While it is not a mental health condition in and of itself, it is often a symptom of depression and anxiety. It is characterised by an inability to tolerate frustration and a sense of powerlessness. This sense of powerlessness arises from the perception of a lack of control over a situation, which can be the result of repeated exposure to adverse stimuli or stressors beyond one's control.

The Neurobiology of Helplessness

Neuroscience has provided insights into the biological basis of helplessness. Research has shown that the brain's default state is to assume a lack of control, and the presence of control is learned. Prolonged exposure to adverse stimulation can lead to "unlearning" this sense of control.

Neurobiologically, increased activity in the dorsal raphe nucleus, which is involved in serotonin production, plays a critical role in learned helplessness. Other key brain regions implicated in the expression of helpless behaviour include the basolateral amygdala, central nucleus of the amygdala, bed nucleus of the stria terminalis, medial prefrontal cortex, dorsal hippocampus, septum, and hypothalamus.

The Role of Serotonin

The role of serotonin in helplessness is complex and not yet fully understood. Serotonin, or 5-HT, is a neurotransmitter that influences various brain functions, including mood and emotion regulation. In the context of helplessness, studies have found both increases and decreases in 5-HT activity, leading to conflicting results.

Some research suggests that inhibiting 5-HT function through the use of 5-HT1A agonists or overexpression of 5-HT1B receptors can have antidepressant-like effects, reducing helplessness behaviours. On the other hand, knockout of 5-HT1A receptors, which would be expected to enhance serotonergic function, has also been shown to have antidepressant-like effects.

The Role of Dopamine

In addition to serotonin, dopamine may also play a role in helplessness. Dopamine is a neurotransmitter involved in reward, motivation, and reinforcement learning. Studies have suggested that changes in subjective, affective, or motivational states can alter expectations for outcomes, potentially influencing dopamine release. Specifically, feelings of helplessness may be related to decreased mesencephalic dopamine release, which is associated with the experience of uncontrollable and unavoidable stressful situations.

Genetic and Psychological Factors

Genetics may also contribute to the development of learned helplessness. Certain genetic variations could structure the brain in a way that makes individuals more susceptible to feelings of helplessness. Additionally, psychological factors such as pessimism, low self-efficacy, and attributing outcomes to unstable and uncontrollable factors have been linked to feelings of helplessness.

Strategies for Managing Helplessness

While the biological basis of helplessness is important to understand, it is also crucial to consider strategies for managing and preventing it. Identifying the source of helplessness, focusing on what one can control, and seeking social support are some strategies that can help individuals overcome feelings of helplessness. Additionally, cognitive-behavioural therapy can be effective in challenging negative thought patterns and replacing them with more optimistic and rational thoughts.

Victimhood and manipulation

Feeling helpless is a common human emotion, often accompanied by anxiety and depression. It can leave people feeling frozen, devastated, and unable to change their situation. This emotion can be triggered by repeated exposure to uncontrollable stressors or traumatic events, leading to a sense of defeat and powerlessness.

Victim playing involves the exaggeration or fabrication of victimhood to justify abuse, seek attention, or manipulate others. Manipulators often portray themselves as victims to evoke pity, sympathy, or compassion from others. By playing on people's emotions, they can gain cooperation, assistance, or privileges that would otherwise be unobtainable. Victim players may also engage in dehumanization, blaming their abusive behavior on the bad behavior of their victims, or grooming others to support or enable their abuse.

The advantages of victim playing include immunity from criticism, increased compassion and understanding from others, and the perception of legitimacy and truthfulness. However, this strategy tends to be less successful over time as people become frustrated and walk away. Victim players may also struggle to break free from their passive role and take responsibility for their desires and actions.

To recognize a victimizing manipulator, there are several signs to look out for. They may send indirect messages or complaints instead of directly asking for what they want, leaving others feeling guilty or responsible. Victim players also tend to be suspicious and distrustful, often alerting others about bad intentions and justifying their actions through past suffering. They may make sacrifices for others and showcase their efforts, indicating a sense of powerlessness and unhappiness with their situation.

To help someone with a victim mentality, it is important to approach them with empathy and understanding. Avoid labeling them as a victim and instead, focus on specific behaviors and feelings. Offer help by acknowledging their feelings, asking about their goals, and brainstorming possible solutions together. Encourage them to seek therapy to address underlying causes, build self-compassion, and develop personal goals.

Strategies to reduce feelings of helplessness

Yes, helplessness is an emotion. It is often accompanied by anxiety and depression, and can be a symptom of a mental illness such as depression.

Understand the Trauma

Trauma can affect the mind and body in ways that make you feel helpless. Understanding how trauma impacts your neurobiology can help you deal with your situation better. When faced with trauma, your mind will try to problem-solve, sending messages to your body to prepare to fight or flee. Sometimes, trauma can cause a third option where your mind dissociates, fragments, or shifts into denial, leaving your body numb and limp.

Identify Stressful Triggers

When you are aware of your environment and the triggers that cause you stress, you can find healthy ways to react and reduce feelings of helplessness. Reflect on the issues and experiences that have been upsetting to you.

Practice Healthy Self-Talk

The way you talk to yourself can help you move through trauma. When it's unhealthy, self-talk keeps us stuck and makes us feel helpless. Healthy self-talk inspires healthy action and is proactive and empowering.

Become Attuned to Your Senses

Tuning into your senses and learning how to command them helps you develop stronger reaction skills, which in turn helps you reduce helplessness.

Recognise Patterns

Pinpointing your personal patterns helps you feel empowered and avoid feeling helpless. Focus on daily habits and reflect on the events that preceded the circumstance. Ask yourself: were you pressed for time, rushed, or unprepared? Is there a pattern that you can identify that keeps you in a helpless state?

Focus on What You Can Control

Focusing on the things you can control can help you feel more capable and empowered. For example, you can't solve climate change, but you can get in touch with your local representatives to learn about steps they're taking to support climate change initiatives. Other things within your control include the way you talk to yourself, how you spend your time, how you take care of yourself, and how you treat other people.

Seek Professional Help

If your feelings of helplessness are causing distress, making it difficult to function, or are accompanied by other symptoms, talk to your doctor. They may recommend treatment options such as psychotherapy, medication, and lifestyle modifications to help you start feeling better and improve your well-being.

Frequently asked questions