The Complex Web Of Fear And Pain: Are They Primary?

Human emotions are a complex and powerful force, with the ability to fuel everything from sports championships to acts of violence. While there are many different emotions, they can be broadly categorized into primary and secondary emotions. Primary emotions are instinctual responses to stimuli and are usually very strong and easy to identify. They include fear, anger, happiness, and sadness. Secondary emotions are reactions to primary emotions and are more complex, often influenced by personal experiences and thoughts. They can include anger, frustration, irritation, and anxiety. While fear and pain are certainly two very powerful emotions, they are not the only primary emotions.

Primary emotions are instinctual and immediate

Primary emotions are adaptive because they make us react in a certain way without our thoughts or habits influencing our response. They are universal and often linked to specific events or situations. For instance, the basic emotions of fear, anger, happiness, and sadness are recognised and experienced by individuals across cultures.

Psychologists have proposed different sets of primary emotions. Paul Ekman identified six primary emotions: anger, disgust, fear, happiness, sadness, and surprise. He theorised that these emotions are innate and shared by everyone across cultures. Robert Plutchik identified eight primary emotions, grouping them into four pairs of polar opposites: joy-sadness, anger-fear, trust-disgust, and surprise-anticipation.

Primary emotions are the core, underlying feelings in a given situation. They are not reactions to other emotions but are the original, direct emotional responses. For example, if you receive some bad news unexpectedly, you may feel a surge of sadness. These emotions are the body's first response, directly connected to the event or stimulus.

While primary emotions are instinctual and immediate, secondary emotions are more complex and influenced by personal experiences, beliefs, and thoughts. Secondary emotions are reactions to primary emotions and are often learned responses that we acquire as we grow up. For example, after feeling anger, you may feel shame; instead of joy, you may feel relief or pride; or instead of fear, you may feel hatred.

It is important to recognise and understand primary emotions because they provide helpful information about our likes, dislikes, triggers, and needs. By identifying and expressing primary emotions, we can build deeper connections with others and improve our emotional stability and integrity.

Secondary emotions are learned and complex

While fear and pain are both considered primary emotions, they are not the only two primary emotions. Other primary emotions include joy, sadness, anger, surprise, and disgust.

Secondary emotions are reactions to primary emotions and are more complex. They are often influenced by personal experiences, beliefs, and thoughts. For example, after feeling the primary emotion of anger, you may feel shame, or instead of feeling joy, you may feel relief or pride. These emotions are considered secondary because they are not direct reactions to an event or situation but are instead reactions to our primary emotions.

Secondary emotions are also more intense and tend to push people away or protect oneself in some way. They are learned or habitual responses that we acquire throughout our lives, often from our parents or caregivers. For instance, as children, we learn that when we cry, a parent will come to soothe us. As we grow older, we continue to use the facial expressions, body language, and physiological responses associated with crying when we need that soothing or sense of security.

Secondary emotions can also be harmful in the long run, as they can ruin relationships, keep our guard up, or wall off our hearts. They can lead to feelings of anger, numbness, exhaustion, and loneliness. They are also harder to identify than primary emotions as they saturate the primary emotion with complex reactions. They can influence our behaviour, increase the intensity of our reactions, and last much longer than primary emotions.

Primary emotions are adaptive

Primary emotions are the core, underlying feelings that are most fundamental to an individual’s experience in a given situation. They are not reactions to other emotions but are the original, direct emotional responses. For example, if you win a competition, you may feel extreme joy, or if you receive unexpected bad news, you may feel a surge of sadness. These primary emotions are the body’s first response, directly connected to the event or stimulus.

Primary emotions are often very strong, making them easy to identify. They are instinctive, primal, and sensitive. They are also transient, which makes them less complicated and easier to understand. The first thing we feel is directly connected to the event or stimulus, but as time passes, we struggle to connect the same emotion with the event because our emotions have changed.

Even when they are painful, primary emotions serve an adaptive purpose. They provide important information about one’s needs, goals, and concerns. When experienced fully, primary emotions bring a sense of clarity and authenticity. They feel “right,” even if they are difficult.

Secondary emotions can be harmful

Secondary emotions are reactions to primary emotions and are more complex. They are often influenced by personal experiences, beliefs, and thoughts. While primary emotions are instinctual and primal, secondary emotions are learned or habitual. They are a way to cover up or defend against primary emotions, which can be too sensitive or vulnerable to share.

An example of a secondary emotion is anger. Anger is a common secondary emotion because it is convenient to cover up feelings of hurt, fear, embarrassment, worry, or sadness, especially for boys and men who have been taught that it is not okay to express these emotions. Another example is shame, which is a common secondary emotion among women who are not allowed to express their anger outwardly.

It is important to recognize and express primary emotions healthily. This can be achieved through self-awareness, exploration, and guidance from a skilled therapist or emotion coach. By understanding and accepting primary emotions, individuals can build deeper connections and improve their overall well-being.

Secondary emotions can be protective

Secondary emotions are a protective mechanism. They are a way to cover up sensitive primary emotions with less sensitive emotions. For example, fear is a sensitive emotion and hate is less sensitive. Secondary emotions are about self-protection, but in the long run, they can hurt us more by ruining relationships, keeping our guard up, or building walls around our hearts, which often leads people to feel angry, numb, exhausted, and lonely. Secondary emotions can lead to more pain and suffering.

Secondary emotions are often harder to name than primary emotions as they saturate the primary emotion with complex reactions. They can influence your behaviour, increase the intensity of your reactions, and last much longer than primary emotions. They can also get in the way of solving problems and feeling better.

Secondary emotions are learned or habitual responses. They are usually more intense emotions that push people away or protect yourself in some way. They can include anger, frustration, irritation, withdrawing, anxiety, and fear. Any feeling can be a primary or secondary emotion, but secondary emotions tend to push someone away or protect a more profound emotion that might be too difficult to share.

Secondary emotions are not a form of self-control, they are just another way to be reactive. This is because secondary emotions don't take the time to notice or explore the emotion, they just want it to go away at any cost. They keep us from knowing what we are feeling. When we act out of secondary emotions, we tend to attack, criticize, demand, or blame. This leads to constant problems like bad relationships, loneliness, more stress, and addiction. Acting on secondary emotions pushes others away and makes it seem impossible to solve problems.

However, covering up true feelings with secondary emotions can be damaging over time. It can lead to breakdowns in relationships and push others away. For example, if someone close to you hurts you, you may turn this hurt into hate, which means you may blame and criticise them. Acting on secondary emotions alone may not solve any problems and can lead to going around in circles. Pushing away difficult emotions such as sadness and fear and not being able to recognize them can increase the risk of harming one's mental health.

Frequently asked questions