Cremation: Religious Sin Or Personal Choice?

Cremation is a topic that has been widely debated among Christians, with some arguing that it is a pagan practice that goes against the idea of bodily resurrection, while others believe that it is a personal choice that does not contradict their faith. The Bible does not explicitly forbid or condone cremation, but it does provide insights into how people were laid to rest in ancient times. The question of whether cremation is a sin or not is a complex one that requires an examination of historical, biblical, and theological perspectives.

Cremation is not labelled as a sin in the Bible

While the Bible does not explicitly condone or condemn cremation, it is not labelled as a sinful practice. Cremation is not mentioned in the detailed lists of instructions for living and dying set forth by God in the Old and New Testaments. Biblical scholars assert that there are no passages that forbid cremation.

The Bible does, however, provide instances of cremation, such as in 1 Samuel 31, where the bodies of Saul and his sons are burned, and their bones are buried. John MacArthur, a Biblical scholar, explains that the people decided to cremate Saul and Jonathan, and then bury their ashes because their bodies had been mutilated by the Philistines.

Another example is found in the book of Joshua, where Achan and his family were cremated after being executed for sinning against Israel.

Some Christians may have reservations about cremation for various reasons, often rooted in their interpretation of religious teachings or cultural traditions. For instance, some Christians believe in bodily resurrection and view cremation as the destruction of the body, preferring traditional burial as a way to show respect for the body's eventual resurrection. Others see cremation as conflicting with the symbolism of the burial and resurrection of Jesus Christ.

Despite these differing perspectives, the fact remains that God is capable of resurrecting all who believe in Him, regardless of whether they are cremated or buried. As John MacArthur explains, "Obviously any buried body will eventually decompose (Ecclesiastes 12:7). So cremation isn’t a strange or wrong practice—it merely accelerates the natural process of oxidation."

In conclusion, while cremation may not be the preferred method of disposition for some Christians, it is not labelled as a sin in the Bible, and ultimately, God's power to resurrect the dead is not hindered by the method of corpse disposal.

Cremation is a pagan practice

Historically, cremation was the standard practice for most of the ancient world. However, Israel, along with Egypt and China, stood out for opposing the practice and preferring burial. In fact, the Mishnah, a collection of Jewish tradition, declared cremation a heathen practice, and Roman historian Tacitus observed that one of the distinguishing characteristics of the Jews was that they "prefer to bury and not burn their dead".

Since Christianity emerged from Judaism, it inherited the preference for burial over cremation. The church father Tertullian was one of the first Christian theologians to explicitly condemn cremation, claiming that only the heathen "burn up their dead".

The divide between Christian burial and pagan cremation is so stark that Francis Schaeffer noted that the spread of Christianity across the Roman Empire could be traced by observing the transition from cremation to burial as the cultural custom. As the gospel spread, cremation disappeared and was replaced by burial. This pattern held for nearly two millennia.

The practice of cremation has pagan roots, and ground burial has been the established custom among Jews and Christians since time immemorial. Abraham purchased a burial site for himself and his wife Sarah, Joseph commanded that his bones be carried out of Egypt, and the Lord provided for the burial of Moses. The same practice continued in the New Testament with the burial of John the Baptist, the Rich Man, Lazarus, Ananias and Sapphira, and Jesus Himself.

In the Bible, cremation is associated with pagan (demonic) religions and capital punishment. The corpse was placed upon towering funeral pyres and set ablaze, and supposedly, the essence of the deceased was sent to the afterlife through the smoke of their remains. Cremation was also a form of capital punishment for enemies of God and God's laws.

While the Bible does not explicitly forbid cremation, the fact that it is associated with pagan religions and capital punishment, and that burial is the normative practice in both the Old and New Testaments, suggests that Christians should favour burial over cremation.

Some Christians may have reservations about cremation for various reasons, often rooted in their interpretation of religious teachings or cultural traditions. Here are some common reasons why some Christians may be opposed to cremation:

• Resurrection Beliefs: Emphasising the importance of the physical body in the afterlife, some Christians may view cremation as the destruction of the body and prefer traditional burial as a way to show respect for the body's eventual resurrection.
• Symbolism of Burial: Traditional burial is seen by some as symbolic of the burial and resurrection of Jesus Christ. Christians who hold this view may feel that cremation does not align with this symbolism and may choose burial as a way to reflect their faith.
• Cultural and Denominational Differences: Christian beliefs and practices vary among denominations and cultures, and some denominations may have specific teachings or traditions regarding burial practices.
• Concerns About Irreversibility: Some Christians may feel uncomfortable with the irreversible nature of cremation, viewing it as a permanent and irreversible transformation of the body.

In conclusion, while cremation may not be explicitly forbidden in the Bible, it is associated with pagan practices and capital punishment. The normative practice in the Bible is burial, and some Christians may have reservations about cremation due to their religious or cultural beliefs. Therefore, Christians are generally encouraged to favour burial over cremation.

Burial is a better expression of the Christian faith

Theologically, the idea of burial is more consistent with the Christian belief in the importance of the human body. Early theologians argued that God created the physical body, Christ joined Himself to a body, and our bodies will one day be resurrected. This belief in the essential importance of the human body drove the preference for burial.

Historically, cremation was the standard practice for most of the ancient world, but Israel, along with Egypt and China, stood out in opposing the practice and preferring burial instead. The Mishnah, a collection of Jewish tradition, declared cremation a heathen practice, and Roman historian Tacitus observed that one of the distinguishing characteristics of the Jews was that they “prefer to bury and not burn their dead.”

In summary, while cremation may be a practical and increasingly common choice, burial is a better expression of the Christian faith and hope. It symbolises the sanctity of the body and the eventual resurrection and reunion of body and spirit.

Cremation is cheaper and more flexible than burial

Cremation is generally considered to be a cheaper option than burial. When choosing burial, you are paying for embalming, your choice of casket, and the opening and closing of the grave. With cremation, you are paying for the cremation itself and your choice of urn, and in some cases, a vault or crypt.

The National Funeral Directors Association’s (NFDA) survey of costs for funerals and cremations estimates the median cost of a funeral with burial to be around $9,420 and the median cost of a funeral with viewing and cremation to be about $6,970.

Direct cremations, which do not include a traditional ceremony, are the cheapest option, ranging from $700 to $3,500. The average cost of a traditional cremation ceremony ranges from $7,000 to $8,000, whereas a traditional burial service can cost between $10,000 and $12,000.

Cremation also offers more flexibility than burial. Ashes can be scattered, stored, or repurposed, whereas burial spots are permanent and set locations. Cremated ashes can be split among individuals and families to keep or spread as they like. They can also be placed in a columbarium or spread in a special location to act as a memorial or burial site.

Additionally, cremation does not require a casket, gravesite, headstone, or embalming, which further reduces costs compared to burial.

Cremation is irreversible

While the Bible does not explicitly mention cremation, it is clear that burial was the standard practice in both the Old and New Testaments. The biblical recordings of funerals explain that God's people were laid to rest in tombs and their bodies were left undisturbed to return to dust in a natural state.

Some Christians view cremation as a destruction of the body and believe that it does not align with their faith in the resurrection and the importance of the physical body in the afterlife. They believe that burial is a better expression of the Christian hope and faith, and a more respectful way to treat the body which is considered precious as it is the form in which God became flesh.

Additionally, cremation has historically been associated with pagan religions, where the corpse was burned and the essence of the deceased was believed to be sent to the afterlife through the smoke.

However, it is important to note that God can still resurrect a cremated body. As John MacArthur explains, "Obviously any buried body will eventually decompose... So cremation isn’t a strange or wrong practice—it merely accelerates the natural process of oxidation."

Ultimately, the decision between burial and cremation is a personal one and Christians are free to choose the option that best aligns with their beliefs and values.

Frequently asked questions