Buddhist Meditation: A Forbidden Path For Muslims?

The question of whether Buddhist meditation is haram in Islam is a complex one. On the one hand, some Muslims argue that any practice associated with Buddhist polytheistic rituals is prohibited. They believe that Muslims should avoid imitating the disbelievers in their peculiar practices, even if they do not share the same intentions. However, others suggest that as long as these meditation practices do not involve any polytheistic rituals and have a scientific basis, they can be permissible and even beneficial. Islamic sources emphasise the importance of muraqabah, or mindfulness, which involves being fully aware of Allah's presence and constantly remembering Him. While the word meditation may carry different connotations and be associated with conflicting religious beliefs, the practice of mindfulness is not inherently opposed to Islamic teachings. In fact, it can be argued that certain forms of meditation, stripped of their religious context, can be compatible with Islam if they help Muslims enhance their worship and improve their mental and spiritual well-being.

The origin of mindfulness meditation

Mindfulness meditation is rooted in ancient Eastern and Buddhist philosophy and dates back around 2500 years. The concept of mindfulness is inspired by many, but Jon Kabat-Zinn and his colleagues at the University of Massachusetts have been influential in establishing it in the Western world.

Kabat-Zinn first encountered mindfulness through practising with Zen Buddhist meditation teachers Philip Kapleau and Korean Zen Master Seung Sahn Haengwon. He then had further extensive training with teachers from various Buddhist traditions, as well as Soto and Rinzai Zen traditions, Chögyam Trungpa's "Meditation in Action", Thich Nhat Hanh's "The Miracle of Mindfulness", and the yogic traditions.

Kabat-Zinn secularised historical Buddhist mindfulness principles by untangling them from the cultural, religious, and ideological factors associated with Buddhism and orienting them to the "Western mind" and culture. This led to the development of the first formalised mindfulness-based intervention (MBI), called Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR).

Mindfulness is derived from the word "sati", a significant element of Hindu and Buddhist traditions, and is based on Zen, Vipassanā, and Tibetan meditation techniques. It is often translated as "bare attention", but in the Buddhist tradition, it has a broader meaning and application.

In a Buddhist context, the keeping of moral precepts is an essential preparatory stage for mindfulness or meditation. Vipassanā includes contemplation and reflection on phenomena such as dukkha, anatta, and anicca, and reflections on causation and other Buddhist teachings.

The English term "mindfulness" already existed before it came to be used in a Western Buddhist context. It was first recorded as "myndfulness" in 1530, "mindfulnesse" in 1561, and "mindfulness" in 1817.

The benefits of mindfulness meditation

Mindfulness meditation has been found to have a wide range of benefits for emotional and physical well-being. The practice originated in Buddhist meditation and has been adopted by psychologists and psychotherapists as a means of improving mental health and overall happiness.

Reducing Stress and Anxiety

Mindfulness meditation has been shown to reduce stress and anxiety. Studies have found that the practice can alter the affective and cognitive processes that underlie multiple clinical issues. By focusing on the present moment, those who practice mindfulness learn to accept their experiences, including painful emotions, rather than reacting to them with aversion and avoidance.

Improving Sleep and Lowering Blood Pressure

Mindfulness-based treatments have been shown to improve sleep and lower blood pressure. The practice can also help people cope with pain and reduce chronic pain.

Boosting Working Memory and Focus

Research has shown that mindfulness meditation improves working memory and focus. One study found that a group of military personnel who practiced mindfulness meditation for eight weeks saw an increase in working memory capacity, while a non-meditating military group experienced a decrease in working memory capacity over the same period.

Reducing Rumination and Emotional Reactivity

Mindfulness meditation has been found to reduce rumination and emotional reactivity. One study found that participants who meditated for 10 days experienced fewer depressive symptoms and less rumination, as well as improved working memory capacity and attention. Another study found that participants who meditated were better able to disengage from emotionally upsetting pictures and focus on a cognitive task.

Improving Relationship Satisfaction

Practicing mindfulness can also improve relationship satisfaction. Research has found that mindfulness helps people respond well to relationship stress and communicate their emotions to their partner. It also protects against the emotionally stressful effects of relationship conflict.

Enhancing Self-Compassion and Empathy

Mindfulness-based stress reduction training has been found to enhance self-compassion and empathy. One study found that health care professionals who participated in an eight-week mindfulness-based stress reduction training reported significantly higher self-compassion and empathy than a control group.

Treating Mental Health Disorders

Psychotherapists have turned to mindfulness meditation as an important element in the treatment of a number of mental health problems, including depression, substance abuse, eating disorders, anxiety disorders, and obsessive-compulsive disorder.

The scientific basis of mindfulness meditation

Mindfulness meditation has become a popular way to manage stress and improve overall well-being. It is rooted in Buddhist thought and theory and was popularized in the West in the 1970s by Jon Kabat-Zinn, a cognitive scientist at the University of Massachusetts. While the practice has been subject to some skepticism and overstated claims, there is a growing body of scientific research that points to its potential benefits. Here is what we know so far about the scientific basis of mindfulness meditation:

Improved Mental Health

Research suggests that mindfulness meditation can improve mental health and reduce symptoms of anxiety and depression. A meta-analysis of 47 studies found that mindfulness meditation programs effectively reduce the negative components of psychological stress, with effects comparable to those of antidepressants. Additionally, mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT) has been found to reduce relapse rates among patients with recurrent depression. MBCT combines elements of mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) and cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT).

Enhanced Cognitive Functioning

Mindfulness practices have been linked to improved cognitive functioning. Research indicates that meditation helps counter habituation, or the tendency to stop paying attention to new information in our environment. It can also reduce mind-wandering and improve problem-solving abilities. Furthermore, the benefits of improved attention can last up to five years after mindfulness training.

Boosted Immune Function

Mindfulness meditation may also have a positive impact on immune function. A study by Richard A. Davidson and Jon Kabat-Zinn found that meditators who underwent an eight-week mindfulness training program had significantly more flu antibodies than their non-meditating peers after receiving a flu vaccine. Additionally, David Cresswell and colleagues at the University of California, Los Angeles, found that MBSR improved immune function even in individuals with HIV.

Reduced Chronic Pain

Mindfulness meditation has been shown to be effective in reducing chronic pain. Research suggests that mindfulness practice alleviates the processing of pain, from the site of injury up the spinal cord to the brain. It also helps mitigate the emotional components of pain, such as the thoughts and feelings associated with it. Studies have found that mindfulness meditation can decrease pain sensitivity and change the way the brain experiences and processes pain.

Positive Brain Changes

Mindfulness meditation has been found to induce positive changes in the brain. Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies have shown that meditation can lead to changes in brain activity, even when individuals are not actively meditating. Specifically, changes have been observed in the amygdala, a part of the brain involved in emotional processing. Additionally, long-term meditators have been found to have structural features in their brains that are proportional to their number of hours of practice, suggesting that mindfulness may change the structure and function of the brain.

Better Sleep

Mindfulness meditation practices may also help reduce insomnia and improve sleep quality. A meta-analysis of 18 studies found that mindfulness meditation improved sleep quality more than education-based treatments. However, the effects were not significantly different from those of evidence-based treatments such as cognitive behavioral therapy and exercise.

Other Benefits

Mindfulness meditation has been linked to a range of other benefits, including improved heart health, enhanced treatment for mental health conditions such as obsessive-compulsive disorder and drug addiction, and reduced cellular aging. Additionally, mindfulness practices can increase self-confidence and leadership skills, improve mood, and reduce bias and negative attitudes.

The permissibility of mindfulness meditation in Islam

Mindfulness meditation, or muraqabah in Arabic, is a practice that can be permissible in Islam as long as it does not involve any polytheistic rituals. While some Muslims may be hesitant about the word "meditation" due to its association with religious beliefs that contradict Islam, the concept of mindfulness is not inherently incompatible with Islamic teachings. In fact, the practice of muraqabah is deeply rooted in Islamic tradition and can be seen as a form of worship and spiritual introspection.

Muraqabah is derived from the root meaning "to watch, observe, or regard attentively" and refers to the constant knowledge and conviction that Allah is aware of one's outward and inward states. It involves cultivating a state of vigilant self-awareness in one's relationship with Allah, knowing that He is always watching. This awareness leads to greater attention and care for one's actions, thoughts, feelings, and inner states of being.

According to Islamic scholars, it is permissible for Muslims to engage in mindfulness meditation as long as it does not involve any polytheistic rituals or imitations of disbelievers' practices. If these conditions are met, mindfulness meditation can be a beneficial practice for Muslims, helping them to discipline their minds, enhance their worship, and improve their overall well-being.

The practice of mindfulness meditation in Islam typically involves choosing a quiet and comfortable posture, focusing on one's natural breathing, and bringing awareness to the present moment. It is often combined with remembrance of Allah (dhikr) and supplications (dua’), which help to anchor the practitioner in a state of muraqabah. This type of meditation can be done at any time of the day and for any duration, although regular practice is recommended to solidify it as a long-term habit.

While the benefits of mindfulness meditation are well-documented in modern science, including improved focus, reduced stress, and enhanced emotional regulation, it is important to note that the ultimate goal of mindfulness in Islam is to cultivate a deeper connection with Allah and achieve spiritual excellence (al-ihsan). This involves striving for a state of constant awareness of Allah's presence and striving to worship Him as if one sees Him, as instructed by the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him).

In conclusion, mindfulness meditation can be permissible in Islam as long as it does not contradict Islamic teachings or involve polytheistic rituals. When practised with the right intentions and within an Islamic framework, it can be a powerful tool for spiritual growth and personal development.

The Islamic alternative to mindfulness meditation

Muraqabah

Muraqabah is a form of Islamic mindfulness, derived from the root meaning "to watch, observe, regard attentively". It is the constant knowledge that Allah is aware of a person's outward and inward states. A Muslim in a state of muraqabah is in continuous full knowledge that Allah is aware of them, and as a consequence, they develop greater attention and care for their own actions, thoughts, feelings, and inner states of being.

Reflection (Taffakur)

Taffakur means to think intentionally, constructively, purposefully, and positively. It is the practice of sitting still for five minutes after prayer, closing your eyes, and thinking about how Allah is always watching you. It is a way to bring awareness, encourage gratitude, and ease the daily stress of life.

Dhikr

Dhikr is the repetitive utterance of words that praise and glorify Allah. This common Islamic meditation practice is often done robotically without thinking. By making dhikr in a state of meditation, you will increase the effectiveness of this wonderful practice.

Qur'an Recitation

Reading the Qur'an is one of the most powerful and rewarding forms of meditation. It is referred to as remembrance, and a renewed sense of positive energy comes from reciting it.

Seclusion and Silence

Seclusion and silence are important aspects of Islamic mindfulness. The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) spent days in the Cave of Hira before his prophethood, and he prescribed I'tikaf in Ramadan as something men and women should do. Breaking away from others and spending time in silence helps to enhance concentration in prayer and other acts of worship.

Islamic Meditation vs Buddhist Meditation

While some forms of Buddhist meditation may be permissible for Muslims if they do not involve any polytheistic rituals, Islamic meditation practices are grounded in the remembrance and awareness of Allah. Islamic meditation involves various mental activities such as reflecting, remembering, examining, meditating, contemplating, deliberating, and pondering, all of which lead to the purification of the heart and mind.

Frequently asked questions