Arguing In The Bible: Sin Or Not?

The Bible offers conflicting messages on whether arguing is a sin. While some verses advise against quarrelsomeness and foolish controversies, others encourage defending the faith and correcting misinterpretations. Ultimately, the Bible suggests that the intention and manner of arguing determine whether it is sinful or not. Arguing for God's glory and truth, with humility and gentleness, is considered biblical, while arguing out of anger or hostility is discouraged.

Arguing over Scripture

Arguing is generally not presented as a good thing in the Bible. The Bible tells Christians to avoid arguments and quarrels, and to be peaceful, kind, and caring. For example, 2 Timothy 2:23-24 says:

> Don't have anything to do with foolish and stupid arguments, because you know they produce quarrels. And the Lord's servant must not be quarrelsome but must be kind to everyone, able to teach, not resentful.

Similarly, Proverbs 29:22 says, "An angry person stirs up conflict, and a hot-tempered person commits many sins."

However, there are appropriate ways to argue Scripture. The Bible also calls Christians to defend the faith and correct people who are teaching erroneous information about it. This must be done in love and good faith, not flippantly, and without being argumentative, hostile, or angry. As 1 Peter 3:15 says:

> But in your hearts revere Christ as Lord. Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with gentleness and respect.

Jesus himself often engaged in arguments to challenge his opponents with the truth of God's Word. Paul frequently argued with others for the truthfulness of the gospel and for the resurrection of Jesus. Peter encourages his readers to always be ready to defend their faith, and that often requires making arguments.

When arguing over Scripture, it is important to argue from Scripture, using the text to support your claim. For example, if someone wants to demonstrate that theft is wrong, they can point to verses from both the Old and New Testaments that demonstrate that taking something from someone else is a sin, such as Exodus 20:15, Leviticus 19:11, Mark 10:19, and Matthew 19:18.

It is also important to be careful not to twist Scripture or take verses out of context to support your own agenda. As Paul wrote to Titus:

> Avoid foolish controversies and genealogies and arguments and quarrels about the law, because these are unprofitable and useless.

Ultimately, the Bible instructs Christians to use "sweetness" in their speech (Proverbs 16:21) and to not be quarrelsome (2 Timothy 2:23). Whether it is okay to argue depends on whether you are arguing with a heart of humility and for God's glory and truth.

Defending the Scriptures

The Bible is clear that some types of arguing are sinful. For example, the Bible instructs Christians to use "sweetness" in their speech and to not be quarrelsome. However, there is a biblical way of arguing. Jesus often engaged in arguments to challenge his opponents with the truth of God's Word. Paul frequently argued with others for the truthfulness of the gospel and for the resurrection of Jesus. Peter encourages his readers to always be ready to defend their faith, and that often requires making arguments.

The Bible also provides guidance on how to argue in a biblical way. For example, 1 Peter 3:15 says, "But in your hearts revere Christ as Lord. Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with gentleness and respect." This verse emphasizes the importance of defending the faith with gentleness and respect.

Additionally, when correcting someone who is teaching erroneous information about the Bible, it is important to speak the truth in love and to avoid presenting oneself as argumentative, hostile, or angry. As believers, we are called to correct false teachings, but we must do so in a way that aligns with biblical principles.

The Bible also warns against those who try to twist Scripture for their own purposes or use it to mislead others. In these cases, it is important to engage in honest dialogue, carefully examine the Scriptures, and seek guidance from the Holy Spirit to discern when and how to engage in debate or argument.

Furthermore, it is important to approach discussions about the Bible with integrity, patience, and humility, modeling the example of Christ. Believers should be careful not to take verses out of context or interpret them in a way that supports their own agenda. Instead, we should seek to understand the true meaning of Scripture and use it to explain who God is and what He has done for humanity.

In conclusion, while arguing can be sinful in certain contexts, there are also biblical ways of arguing that involve defending the faith, correcting false teachings, and engaging in honest dialogue about the Scriptures. By following the guidance provided in the Bible, we can argue in a way that glorifies God and aligns with His will.

Arguing with non-believers

The Bible is clear that some types of arguing are sinful. For example, the Bible instructs Christians to use "sweetness" in their speech and not be quarrelsome. It also condemns arguing about things that are not worth arguing about, labelling such disputes as “foolish controversies".

However, there is a biblical way of arguing. Jesus often engaged in arguments to challenge his opponents with the truth of God's Word. Paul frequently argued with others for the truthfulness of the gospel and for the resurrection of Jesus. Peter encourages his readers to always be ready to defend their faith, and that requires making arguments.

When it comes to arguing with non-believers, it is important to approach the discussion with humility and a sincere desire to seek truth. The Bible warns against arguing just for the sake of being argumentative, hostile, or angry. Instead, Christians should speak the truth in love, with gentleness and respect. The concept of defending the faith is called apologetics, and it is encouraged for all Christians.

When correcting someone who is teaching erroneous information about the Bible, it is important to do so without being hostile or argumentative. Jesus himself corrected his disciples many times during his ministry, but he was never hostile towards them. Instead, he gently instructed them with love and compassion.

Additionally, it is crucial to choose your arguments wisely. The Bible warns against arguing with fools, as it will only lead to more folly. Instead, look for sincerity and good-faith arguments in your discussions with non-believers. If someone is simply trying to stir up strife, it is best to take the higher road and not engage.

In conclusion, while arguing can be sinful in certain contexts, there are also biblical ways of arguing that involve humility, gentleness, and a sincere desire to defend the faith. When arguing with non-believers, approach the discussion with love, compassion, and respect, just as Jesus did when correcting his disciples.

Arguing with other Christians

The Bible does not promote arguing as a positive activity, instead instructing Christians to use "sweetness" in their speech and avoid quarrels (Proverbs 16:21, 2 Timothy 2:2324). It also discourages arguing about things that are not worth arguing about, labelling such disputes as \"foolish controversies\" (1 Timothy 6:4; Titus 3:9).

However, the Bible does provide examples of a biblical way of arguing. Jesus often engaged in arguments to challenge opponents with the truth of God's Word, and Paul frequently argued for the truthfulness of the gospel and the resurrection of Jesus (Acts 17:1–9, 22–34). Peter encourages readers to always be ready to defend their faith, which may require making arguments (1 Peter 3:15).

When considering whether it is okay to argue with other Christians, it is important to ask two key questions:

• Are you arguing with a heart of humility, or are you being contentious?
• Are you arguing for God's glory and truth, or for some other reason?

If you are arguing in humility for God's glory and according to God's truth, then you are arguing in a biblical way. It is important to approach discussions about the Bible with integrity, patience, and the example of Christ. Anger and self-righteousness, even if one's interpretation is correct, are considered sinful.

Additionally, it is crucial to be mindful of the other person's intentions. Are they open to the message of the Bible? Is the Holy Spirit guiding the discussion? Are they making good-faith arguments or being dismissive? If someone is teaching or believing erroneous information about the Bible, it is important to correct them, but this should be done in love and kindness (Ephesians 4:15). One should not present themselves as argumentative, hostile, or angry (2 Timothy 2:24).

In summary, while the Bible discourages arguing, there are times when defending the faith and correcting misinterpretations may require respectful and humble dialogue with other Christians. The key is to do so with the right motives and in a way that glorifies God.

God's Word vs. human weakness

The Bible is clear that some types of arguing are sinful. For instance, the Bible instructs Christians to use "sweetness" in their speech and avoid quarrelsomeness (Proverbs 16:21, 2 Timothy 2:23). It also warns against arguing about things that are not worth arguing about, labelling such disputes as "foolish controversies" (1 Timothy 6:4, Titus 3:9).

However, there is a biblical way of arguing. Jesus often engaged in arguments to challenge His opponents with the truth of God's Word. Paul frequently argued for the truthfulness of the gospel and the resurrection of Jesus (Acts 17:1–9, 22–34). Peter encourages Christians to always be ready to defend their faith, which may require making arguments (1 Peter 3:15).

The key distinction lies in the intention and manner of arguing. Arguing for God's glory and truth, with humility, is biblical. On the other hand, arguing out of contentiousness or anger is discouraged.

Human weakness comes into play when interpreting and applying God's Word. Believers and non-believers may disagree on the interpretation of Scripture, leading to contention. Some may even twist Scripture for their own purposes, rather than using it to explain who God is and what He has done for humanity.

To avoid human weakness in interpretation, it is essential to study the Bible carefully and argue from Scripture, using textual support for any claims made (2 Timothy 2:15). Honest disagreements about Scriptural meaning can lead to substantive debate and even consensus. However, arguing should be approached with integrity, patience, and the example of Christ, avoiding anger and self-righteousness (2 Timothy 2:23-25).

In conclusion, while arguing can be sinful, there is a biblical way to argue that glorifies God and defends the faith. Christians should be mindful of their intentions and approach, ensuring that their arguments are rooted in humility, love, and a sincere desire to uphold God's truth.

Frequently asked questions