Antigone's Crisis Of Faith: Questioning The Gods' Existence

Antigone is an Athenian tragedy written by Sophocles in 441 BC. It follows the story of Antigone, the daughter of Oedipus, who defies her uncle Creon's decree and attempts to bury her brother Polynices, going against the decision of her uncle and prioritising her familial duty over human laws. Antigone's faith in the gods is unwavering throughout the play, even in the face of Creon's threats of punishment and death. She argues that she holds honour and love for her brother higher than law and death, and that she fears offending the gods more than she fears the power of the state. Antigone's unwavering faith in the gods and her bold defiance of Creon's decree set up a dramatic conflict between religious and secular worldviews, with Antigone choosing to be obedient to the gods even at the cost of her life.

Antigone's loyalty to her brother vs. her loyalty to the state

In Sophocles' tragedy *Antigone*, the titular character's loyalty to her brother Polynices and her loyalty to the state are in conflict. Antigone's brother is killed in battle while attacking the city of Thebes, and as punishment, Creon, King of Thebes, forbids his burial. Antigone, however, is determined to give her brother a proper burial, which puts her at odds with the state.

Antigone's loyalty to her brother is evident in her willingness to defy Creon's edict and risk her life to bury Polynices. She believes that her duty to her family outweighs her loyalty to the state, stating, "I will bury him myself. And even if I die in this act, that death will be a glory." Antigone's loyalty to her family is further demonstrated by her refusal to obey Creon's law, which she sees as a betrayal of family trust.

On the other hand, Creon represents a strict definition of citizenship, prioritizing the state over individual loyalties. He believes that Polynices has forfeited his right to a proper burial as a citizen of Thebes by attacking the city. In Creon's eyes, the loyalty of citizens to the state must come first, and anyone who places their family above the good of the country is a traitor. He even goes so far as to sentence Antigone to death for her disobedience, demonstrating his unwavering commitment to upholding the laws of the state.

Antigone's actions in burying her brother have significant repercussions, highlighting the complex nature of loyalty in the play. Her sister, Ismene, accepts partial blame for the burial out of loyalty to Antigone, despite refusing to help. Additionally, Creon's devotion to his laws leads to the deaths of not only Antigone but also his son Haemon, who is betrothed to Antigone, and ultimately, his own wife, Eurydice, cursing Creon "as the killer of [his own] child."

The conflict between Antigone's loyalty to her brother and her loyalty to the state raises important questions about the duties of citizens and the role of family in ancient Greek society. Antigone's strong will and determination to honor her family, even in the face of harsh consequences, adds a layer of complexity to her character and invites sympathy from the audience. Ultimately, Antigone's choice to prioritize her family over the state leads to tragic consequences, underscoring the high stakes of loyalty in the play.

The power of the state vs. the power of the gods

Antigone is an Athenian tragedy written by Sophocles in 441 BC. It is the second oldest surviving play of Sophocles, and the story is a continuation of Aeschylus' Seven Against Thebes. The play is named after its main protagonist, Antigone, the daughter of Oedipus, the exiled king of Thebes.

Antigone's faith in the gods is unwavering throughout the play. She is steadfast in her belief that her duty to her family and the gods outweighs any human laws. Antigone's conflict with Creon, the current King of Thebes, centres on the burial of her brother, Polynices, whose body has been left unburied as punishment for his treason. Antigone's faith in the gods is so strong that she is willing to risk her life to perform the burial rites for her brother, despite Creon's edict.

Creon, on the other hand, represents the power of the state. He believes that the law is the guarantor of personal happiness and must be obeyed above all else. He argues that Polynices has forfeited his right to a burial by betraying Thebes. Creon's power as king is absolute, and he demands complete obedience from his subjects.

The conflict between Antigone and Creon pits the power of the gods against the power of the state. Antigone's unwavering faith in the gods leads her to defy Creon's edict, as she believes that her religious duty to her brother outweighs any human laws. Creon, on the other hand, is unyielding in his insistence on the authority of the state. He sees Antigone's actions as a threat to the stability of Thebes and is willing to go to extreme lengths to enforce his laws, even if it means executing his own niece.

The Chorus, composed of Theban elders, initially sides with Creon, out of deference to his authority. However, as the play progresses, they become more sympathetic to Antigone and attempt to counsel Creon to be more moderate. They recognise the validity of Antigone's arguments and the injustice of Creon's decree, but they are fearful of speaking out against the power of the state.

In the end, it is Creon who suffers the most. His stubborn refusal to listen to reason and compromise leads to the deaths of Antigone, his son Haemon, and his wife Eurydice. Creon's tragic fate serves as a warning that the power of the state must be balanced with reverence for the gods. While Creon valued order and stability above all else, he failed to recognise that true wisdom lies in respecting both temporal and divine laws.

The role of women in Ancient Greece

Women in Ancient Greece had few rights compared to male citizens. They were expected to remain in the home, with their purpose in life being the rearing of children. They were barred from conducting legal proceedings, and while they could own property, their kyrios (father or husband) had the right to dispose of it. Athenian women could enter into contracts worth less than a medimnos of barley, but they were excluded from ancient Athenian democracy.

Girls were educated similarly to boys, but with a greater emphasis on dancing, gymnastics, and musical accomplishment. The ultimate goal of a girl's education was to prepare her for her role in rearing a family, not to stimulate intellectual development. Athenian women were also barely educated beyond home tutorship for basic skills such as spinning, weaving, and cooking.

Young, unmarried women had some mobility in antiquity. For example, they could retrieve water from the local fountain house, which offered an opportunity to socialise with other women. They could also attend public speeches and visit certain sanctuaries. However, during any occasion outside of the house, young women were expected to be inconspicuous, with their heads covered.

Women of various ages also took part in specific religious festivals, some of which included men, and others which were restricted to women. Religious rituals reserved for young girls probably had the most significant impact on young unmarried women. For example, girls between the ages of five and puberty were selected to serve the goddess Artemis in her sanctuary at Brauron.

Marriage usually took place at the age of 14 or 15, without the need for the bride's consent. Love had little to do with the matching of husband and wife, and all women were expected to marry.

In the family home, women were expected to manage the daily requirements of the household, with the help of slaves if the husband could afford them. Contact with non-family males was discouraged, and women largely occupied their time with indoor activities such as wool work and weaving. They could go out to visit friends and were able to participate in public religious ceremonies and festivals.

Despite the harsh limits on women's freedoms and rights in ancient Greece, their rights in the context of divorce were fairly liberal. Marriage could be terminated by mutual consent or action taken by either spouse. If a woman wanted a divorce, she needed the help of her father or another male relative to represent her. If a man wanted a divorce, he simply had to throw his wife out of the house.

Despite their lack of rights, some women rose above the limitations of Greek society and gained lasting acclaim as poets, philosophers, leaders, and physicians.

Pride as a tragic flaw

Pride is a complex human emotion that can be a double-edged sword. While it can propel individuals to remarkable achievements, it can also be their undoing, leading them down a path of self-destruction. This duality of pride is evident in literary masterpieces such as Sophocles' "Antigone" and Homer's "The Iliad", where it is portrayed as both a heroic trait and a tragic flaw.

In "Antigone," the title character's unwavering pride serves as a tragic flaw that ultimately leads to her demise. Antigone is fiercely loyal to her family and is willing to defy Creon's edict to bury her brother Polyneices, even at the risk of punishment. She believes that her duty to her family surpasses the laws of the state, demonstrating her strong sense of pride and conviction. However, her stubbornness and refusal to yield result in her being sentenced to death, highlighting how her pride becomes her tragic downfall.

On the other hand, pride can also be a driving force for heroism and exceptional accomplishments. In "The Iliad," the characters Achilleus and Hektor embody contrasting manifestations of pride. Achilleus' pride is hurt when Agamemnon dishonors him, leading to his initial refusal to fight. However, the death of his friend Patroklos ignites his pride and fuels his desire for revenge, prompting him to rejoin the battle and achieve glory. Hektor, on the other hand, is blinded by sporadic moments of arrogance, which ultimately leads to his demise. These characters showcase how pride can be a double-edged sword, capable of both heroic achievements and tragic downfalls.

Shakespeare's "Othello" and Sophocles' "Oedipus" also delve into the theme of pride as a tragic flaw. Both Othello and Oedipus possess a sense of pride that stems from their insecurities, which ultimately leads to their destruction. Othello's insecurity about his appearance and social status, coupled with his fear of what others think, drives him to jealousy and murder. Oedipus, on the other hand, believes he can establish his own destiny, independent of the gods, which leads to his shameful discovery of patricide and incest.

In conclusion, pride is a complex emotion that can propel individuals to greatness or lead them to their downfall. It is a driving force for heroism and achievement but can also be a tragic flaw when it goes unchecked. Through the exploration of pride in these literary works, we learn that maintaining a balanced sense of pride is essential, as it can either elevate us to remarkable heights or plunge us into the depths of tragedy.

The limits of human power

Antigone's faith in the gods is unwavering. She is willing to defy Creon's decree and bury her brother Polynices because she believes that the gods will favour her. Antigone's loyalty to her family and her belief in the gods are more important to her than the laws of the state.

Antigone's faith in the gods is so strong that she is willing to risk her life to uphold it. She tells her sister, Ismene, that she would rather die than deny her brother a proper burial. Antigone believes that the gods of the Underworld will rule over her eternally, while the gods of the city can only punish her temporarily. This suggests that Antigone's faith in the gods is not only unwavering but also a source of strength and courage for her.

Throughout the play, Antigone repeatedly asserts her faith in the gods and her willingness to face the consequences of her actions. When Creon questions her, she does not deny what she has done and unflinchingly argues with him about the immorality of his edict. Even when faced with the prospect of execution, Antigone remains defiant and continues to defend her actions.

Antigone's unwavering faith in the gods highlights the limits of human power. Creon, as the ruler of Thebes, believes that his laws are absolute and must be obeyed without question. He sees himself as the embodiment of the state and cannot tolerate any challenge to his authority. However, Antigone's willingness to defy him and uphold her religious beliefs demonstrates that there are limits to his power.

Creon's insistence on the primacy of the state over religion ultimately leads to his downfall. He refuses to listen to reason, even when faced with the prophetic warnings of Tiresias. In the end, Creon loses his son, his wife, and his niece Antigone. The tragic consequences of his obstinacy underscore the limits of human power in the face of divine will.

In conclusion, Antigone's unwavering faith in the gods serves as a powerful counterpoint to the limits of human power represented by Creon. Her willingness to risk her life and defy the state to uphold her religious beliefs demonstrates that there are some forces that even the most powerful ruler cannot control.

Frequently asked questions