Scriptural Interpretation Across Faith Traditions

Scripture interpretation varies across different faith traditions. For instance, Protestants claim that the Bible is the only rule of faith, meaning that it contains all the material one needs for theology. Catholics, on the other hand, believe in Scripture plus apostolic tradition, as manifested in the living teaching authority of the Catholic Church. The Anglican and Methodist churches regard tradition, reason, and experience as sources of authority but as subordinate to scripture – a position known as prima scriptura. The Lutheran and Reformed traditions teach that the Bible alone is a sufficient/infallible basis for all Christian teachings – a position known as sola scriptura. The Eastern Orthodox Christian tradition holds that there is one Tradition, the tradition of the church, incorporating the scriptures and the teachings of the Church Fathers.

The role of oral tradition in the transmission of scripture

Oral tradition, or oral lore, is a form of human communication in which knowledge, art, ideas, and culture are received, preserved, and transmitted orally from one generation to another. It is the most widespread medium of human communication.

Oral tradition is a medium of communication for a society to transmit oral history, oral literature, oral law, and other knowledge across generations without a writing system, or in parallel to a writing system. It is memories, knowledge, and expression held in common by a group over many generations: it is the long preservation of immediate or contemporaneous testimony.

Religions such as Buddhism, Hinduism, Catholicism, and Jainism have used oral tradition, in parallel to writing, to transmit their canonical scriptures, rituals, hymns, and mythologies.

Christianity

Catholics believe that the "rule of faith" is Scripture plus apostolic tradition, as manifested in the living teaching authority of the Catholic Church. They argue that the early Christians learned from oral instruction before the New Testament was compiled and that Jesus himself transmitted his teachings orally. Thus, they view oral tradition as a legitimate and trustworthy source of Christian doctrine, on par with written Scripture.

Islam

Islam's two major sources of divine revelation, the Quran and Hadith, were initially transmitted orally. The Quran, which means "recitation" in Arabic, is believed to have been carefully compiled and edited into a standardized written form about two decades after the last verse was revealed to Prophet Muhammad. However, during this period, it was primarily memorized and recited orally, and even today, the recitation and memorization of the Quran remain a central aspect of Islamic devotion.

Hadith, which refers to the record of the words, actions, and silent approval of Prophet Muhammad, was transmitted by oral preachers and storytellers for around 150-250 years before being compiled and committed to written form. Each hadith includes the *isnad*, or the chain of human transmitters who passed down the tradition, which helped ensure the accuracy of the transmission.

Judaism

Judaism also has a rich oral tradition, as evidenced by the Torah and other ancient Jewish literature. The Pharisees, a Jewish religious group during the time of Jesus, relied heavily on oral traditions to interpret the Law of Moses. However, Jesus cautioned against the reliance on oral tradition when it reflected the desires of traditionalists rather than the will of God.

In summary, oral tradition has played a significant role in the transmission of scripture in various faith traditions. While the specific role and authority of oral tradition may differ between denominations and religions, it has been a vital means of preserving and transmitting religious teachings, scriptures, and traditions across generations, particularly in pre-literate or partially literate societies.

The authority of the Church in interpreting scripture

The Catholic Church, on the other hand, recognises the "rule of faith" as being Scripture plus apostolic tradition, with the Church acting as the living teaching authority. This is supported by the Second Vatican Council's document on divine revelation, Dei Verbum, which explains the relationship between Tradition and Scripture:

> "Hence there exists a close connection and communication between sacred Tradition and sacred Scripture. For both of them, flowing from the same divine wellspring, in a certain way merge into a unity and tend toward the same end. For sacred Scripture is the word of God inasmuch as it is consigned to writing under the inspiration of the divine Spirit. To the successors of the apostles, sacred Tradition hands on in its full purity God’s word, which was entrusted to the apostles by Christ the Lord and the Holy Spirit."

The Orthodox Church also reserves the role of interpreting scriptures for the church, but not through the church hierarchy in the same way as the Catholic Church. Instead, the Orthodox Church finds the hermeneutical key in the mind of the Church, as expressed by the Fathers of the Church and in the Ecumenical Councils.

The Anabaptist tradition, including Mennonite, Amish, Brethren and some related churches, interprets scripture through the community. While the community can give special weight to those with skills, knowledge and training in biblical interpretation, there is no hierarchical 'priest' who dictates the interpretation. This interpretation happens at multiple levels, from small groups to the church as a whole, and even at a denominational level.

In summary, the authority of the Church in interpreting scripture varies between different faith traditions, with some emphasising the individual's direct connection to God and others giving authority to the Church or its leaders.

The relationship between tradition and scripture

Scripture and tradition are closely linked in many faiths, with sacred Tradition and sacred Scripture forming one deposit, and both contributing to the doctrinal and spiritual authority of Christianity and the Bible.

Catholicism

Catholicism teaches that the doctrines contained in Sacred Scripture (the Bible) and Sacred Tradition (the Church) are authoritative because God’s revelation is the source of both. The Catechism states that "sacred Tradition and Sacred Scripture make up a single sacred deposit of the word of God" and that "both Scripture and Tradition must be accepted and honoured with equal sentiments of devotion and reverence". Catholics believe that the teachings of Jesus and the Apostles were preserved in the scriptures and by word of mouth, with the perpetual handing on of the tradition called the "Living Tradition". This is the faithful transmission of the teachings of the Apostles from one generation to the next.

The Second Vatican Council's document on divine revelation, Dei Verbum, explains that "there exists a close connection and communication between sacred Tradition and sacred Scripture". It continues: "For both of them, flowing from the same divine wellspring, in a certain way merge into a unity and tend toward the same end".

The Catholic Church views Tradition as the passing down of apostolic faith, with the understanding of it continuing to deepen and mature over time through the action of the Holy Spirit in the history of the church.

Protestantism

Protestants, on the other hand, claim the Bible is the only rule of faith, meaning that it contains all the material one needs for theology. Anything extraneous to the Bible is simply non-authoritative, unnecessary, or wrong. This position is known as sola scriptura.

Anglicanism and Methodism

The Anglican and Methodist churches regard tradition, reason, and experience as sources of authority but as subordinate to scripture – a position known as prima scriptura.

The use of scripture in salvation

Scripture and its interpretation play a central role in the Christian faith and its various denominations. While there are many similarities, there are also some differences in how different faith traditions interpret Scripture and its role in salvation.

Roman Catholics

Roman Catholics believe that the "true 'rule of faith' is Scripture plus apostolic tradition, as manifested in the living teaching authority of the Catholic Church. They believe that the Church, in the persons of the apostles, was given the authority to teach by Christ and that the Church would be his representative. Catholics believe that the Bible is not the only source of revealed truth and that apostolic tradition, which consists of the teachings that the apostles passed on orally, is also a source of revealed truth. They believe that the Bible itself points to the importance of tradition, as the oral and written tradition of the prophets and apostles led to the formation of Scripture and the canonization of the Old and New Testaments.

Catholics believe that the interpretation of Scripture is ultimately subject to the judgment of the Magisterium, which exercises the divine commission to hold fast to and interpret God's Word authoritatively. They believe that the interpretation of Scripture should be done in the light of the Spirit of Truth and guided by the Holy Spirit.

Catholics also believe that Scripture should be interpreted in the context of the living Tradition of the whole Church, so that a true interpretation of Scripture may be grasped. They recognize two senses of Scripture: the literal and the spiritual. The literal sense refers to the meaning conveyed by the words of Scripture, taking into account their literary form, while the spiritual senses derive from the unity of God's plan of salvation. There are three spiritual senses: the allegorical, moral, and anagogical.

In terms of salvation, Catholics believe that faith which is active in charity and good works (fides caritate formata) can justify, or remove the burden of guilt in sin, from man. They believe that forgiveness of sin exists and is natural, but justification can be lost by mortal sin.

Protestants

Protestants, on the other hand, generally hold the view of sola scriptura, which asserts that the Bible is the only infallible source of authority for Christian faith and practice. They believe that the whole of Christian truth is found within the Bible and that anything extraneous to the Bible is simply non-authoritative, unnecessary, or wrong. This view is often supported by citing verses such as "These are written that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that believing you may have life in his name" (John 20:31) and "All Scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness" (2 Timothy 3:16-17).

However, there are some differences among Protestant denominations. For example, Lutherans and Calvinists believe in the doctrine of sola fide, which asserts that believers are justified by faith alone, without works. They believe that Christ's righteousness is imputed to the sinner's account through faith alone, without works. However, they also believe that anyone who truly has faith will produce good works as a product of that faith, as a good tree produces good fruit.

Other Protestant denominations, such as Methodists, hold a slightly different view. While they affirm the doctrine of justification by faith, they believe that justification refers to "pardon, the forgiveness of sins", rather than "being made actually just and righteous", which they believe is accomplished through sanctification. They believe that good works are necessary for continuance in faith and that salvation can be forfeited if it is not accompanied by continued faith and the works that naturally follow from it.

Orthodox Christians

Eastern Orthodox Christians also have a different understanding of salvation compared to Western branches of Christianity. They believe that salvation is seen as participation in the renewal of human nature itself by way of the eternal Word of God assuming the human nature in its fullness. They tend to use the word "expiation" to refer to what is accomplished in the sacrificial act of Christ's death, which seeks to change the one making the offering. They believe that Christ's death was not to appease an angry God or to avert God's wrath but to defeat and destroy sin and death, so that those who are fallen may be transfigured and become fully human as God intended.

Orthodox Christians also believe that a person abides in Christ and makes his salvation sure not only by works of love but also by patient suffering of various griefs, illnesses, misfortunes, and failures.

The role of scripture in Christian theology

Scripture plays a vital role in Christian theology, which is the systematic study of the divine and religion in Christian belief and practice. Theology draws on the foundational sacred texts of Christianity, while also investigating the development of Christian doctrine throughout history.

Christian theology varies across the main branches of Christian tradition: Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant. Each tradition has its own unique approaches to seminaries and ministerial formation.

Scripture is central to Christian theology, with theologians using biblical exegesis, rational analysis, and argument. Scripture is also essential for understanding Christian tenets, making comparisons between Christianity and other traditions, defending Christianity against criticism, facilitating church reforms, and propagating the faith.

The apologetic function of theology involves defending and explaining the faith to outsiders, as instructed in 1 Peter 3:15. Early Christian apologists responded to criticisms and accusations from pagans and Jews. Today, Christian apologists engage with religious pluralism and atheism.

Polemical theology defends Christian doctrine against heretical threats from within the church. For example, Irenaeus of Lyons defended biblical faith against Gnosticism, while Athanasius of Alexandria and the Cappadocian Fathers upheld Christ's divinity against Arianism. In modern times, theologians have countered Enlightenment biblical criticism and Unitarian denials of the Trinity and original sin.

Homiletical theology assists preachers and teachers in the exposition and teaching of Scripture. It helps place specific texts in the wider context of redemptive history, including creation, fall, redemption, and new creation. Sound homiletical theology helps preserve the distinctive Christian identity of the message.

In addition to these functions, a sound biblical theology can provide vitality, vision, and standards for assessment in local congregations. It can contribute to church growth and vitality, with robust theology often correlating with tepid worship and declining memberships. Theology can also provide a theological framework for casting a vision for the church and assessing its effectiveness in worship, discipleship, and mission.

Thus, scripture plays a central and dynamic role in Christian theology, shaping the understanding and practice of the faith across traditions.

Frequently asked questions