Students' Trust In The School System: A Breakdown?

Students and parents are losing faith in the school system. A majority of Americans believe that higher education institutions are failing students and not adequately preparing them for the future. The pandemic has only exacerbated this crisis, with remote learning and school closures further harming students' academic and social development. The conflict between Israel and Hamas in Gaza, and the response of elite universities, has also contributed to the loss of faith in higher education leaders. Furthermore, the shift in the primary purpose of education from civic and humanistic values to private gain and economic interests has led to a crisis in American public education. The historical role of public schools in nurturing ethical and intelligent citizens for a democratic republic seems to be eroding. Additionally, the issue of grades and coercion in the current school system has been questioned, with evidence suggesting that grades distract students from learning and make them risk-averse. The future of American education is uncertain, and it remains to be seen whether the country will unite to enrich and continue its future through educational excellence.

Students are incentivised by future rewards rather than worthwhile experiences

The current narrative in schools is that a student's job is to become "college and career-ready", with an emphasis on college. This has led to the erosion of subjects like music and art, as well as activities like recess, which are seen as unnecessary in the face of test preparation. Students are made to believe that they must choose a major that will pay off in the future, rather than something they are interested in. This creates a system where students are incentivised by a series of indefinite future rewards, such as a well-paying job or a stable career, rather than the learning process itself.

This shift in focus has had a detrimental effect on student motivation and engagement. Students are more likely to see their education as a means to an end, and may become disillusioned when they realise that the promised rewards may not materialise. They may also feel that the education system is failing to provide them with the skills and knowledge they need to succeed in the future, further contributing to a loss of faith in the system.

Additionally, the high cost of tuition and the burden of student debt further contribute to the sense that students are suffering and sacrificing in the present for future rewards that may never come. This can lead to feelings of resentment and disillusionment, especially if students feel that their education is not adequately preparing them for the future.

To address this issue, it is important to shift the focus back to providing students with a well-rounded education that emphasises meaningful and engaging learning experiences. This can be achieved by prioritising critical thinking, creativity, and problem-solving skills, rather than solely focusing on test scores and college preparation. Additionally, it is crucial to provide students with the support and resources they need to explore their interests and discover their passions, both inside and outside of the classroom. By doing so, we can create a more engaged and motivated student body, who see the value in education beyond just future career prospects.

Grades distract students from learning

Students losing faith in the school system is a prevalent issue in the United States. The American school system is the best-financed system globally, yet it is one of the lowest-performing in the developed world. The system's performance record is alarming, especially for children from low socioeconomic backgrounds, who often receive an education in dilapidated schools with underqualified teachers.

One of the reasons students may be losing faith in the school system is the emphasis on grades. Grades are a recent phenomenon, dating back only to the 1940s, and were introduced to ease communication between institutions. However, grades have several negative impacts on students and their learning:

Grades distract from learning:

• Grades can distract students from absorbing important descriptive feedback. One study found that students who were informed they would be graded after a lesson retained less information than those who were not.
• Grades can lower students' interest in learning and enhance anxiety, especially for low achievers, who experience "dramatic declines" in academic interest upon receiving low scores.
• Grades can create a competitive classroom environment, pitting students against each other. This competition can negatively impact learning and retention.
• Grades can foster a fear of failure and reduce students' willingness to take risks and be creative in their learning.
• Grades can become the primary source of motivation for students, who focus on maximising grades while minimising effort, rather than maximising learning.
• Grades can cause students to view their self-worth through an academic lens, which is correlated with higher stress levels, anger, academic problems, and relationship conflicts.

Suggestions to mitigate the negative impacts of grades:

• Provide "evolving assignments" with descriptive feedback but no grades until the final submission. This approach shows that learning is a process and can be improved upon.
• Encourage intrinsic motivation by making the learning process interesting and giving students a sense of control over their learning.
• Use language that focuses on the learning outcome rather than task completion when giving assignments.
• Grade based on participation and effort to increase students' interest in academic improvement.
• Provide clear rubrics to reduce teacher bias and increase grading consistency.
• Prioritise descriptive feedback over numerical evaluations to improve student learning and retention.

By implementing these strategies, educators can shift the focus from grades to learning and help students view education as a means of gaining knowledge and skills rather than just a means of achieving good grades.

Students are disinterested in reading and writing

Firstly, the school system has been blamed for students' lack of interest in reading. Students have complained that they are assigned boring classic novels to read and that they don't have time to read books of their choice. The amount of work assigned in school can also be a factor, leaving students with little time or energy to engage in voluntary reading.

Another reason for students' disinterest in reading and writing could be the pressure and expectations placed on them by parents and society. Students may feel that they are studying to please others rather than for their own enjoyment or benefit.

Additionally, the primary purpose of education seems to have shifted from civic to economic purposes, with college and career readiness taking precedence over liberal arts education. This shift may contribute to students' perception of reading and writing as tedious tasks rather than enjoyable activities.

To rekindle students' interest in reading and writing, educators suggest involving students in the creation of assignment rubrics and giving them more choices in what they read and how they demonstrate their knowledge. Making connections between the curriculum and students' lives, as well as incorporating interactive elements such as instant messaging and online bulletin boards, can also help engage students and make learning more enjoyable.

By addressing these issues and working together, educators, parents, and society can help students rediscover the joy of reading and writing.

The American school system has a poor performance record

The American school system has been criticized for its poor performance, with some arguing that it is failing its students and not preparing them adequately for the future. Here are some key points that illustrate this issue:

Lack of Focus on Academic Excellence

It is believed that there is a lack of emphasis on academic excellence in American schools. Critics argue that the system prioritizes athletic success and social-emotional learning over academic rigor. International students, in particular, have noted that American teens value sports over knowledge and spend less time on homework compared to their global peers. This perception is somewhat supported by reports indicating that American students spend an average of six hours per week on homework, which is higher than the global average but still less than that of some high-performing countries.

Inadequate Education Standards

The education standards and curriculum in the American school system have been described as mediocre and ineffective. Critics argue that classes are often less challenging and fail to fully embrace the inculcation of knowledge as the primary institutional mission. This is reflected in the declining math scores in the US, which took a significant dip between 2012 and 2015. When compared to other economically developed countries, the US ranked just ahead of the international average in science and reading but lagged behind in math.

Ineffective Reforms and Lack of Accountability

The American school system has a history of ineffective reforms, with critics arguing that there is a lack of focus on results and accountability. While various initiatives have been implemented, they often fail to address the core issues and lead to a cycle of blame-shifting. Additionally, there is a perception that individual students and the entire government-controlled school system are not held accountable for poor performance, contributing to a culture of mediocrity.

Socioeconomic Disparities and Inequities

The American school system has been criticized for its failure to address socioeconomic disparities effectively. Students from low socioeconomic backgrounds, particularly in urban environments, often face significant challenges. They are educated in under-resourced and dilapidated schools, where educators may lack the necessary credentials and skills. High student-to-teacher ratios further exacerbate the problem, making it difficult to provide the support and attention needed to improve educational outcomes for these students.

Disconnect Between Testing and Student Incentives

The American school system has been criticized for its disconnect between testing and student incentives. State tests are often used to evaluate schools but are not necessarily linked to student incentives such as high school graduation requirements or college admissions. This disconnect can create a sense of disconnect and disengagement for students, impacting their motivation and overall performance.

Schools are becoming privately managed

The trend of schools becoming privately managed is not a new phenomenon. Private schools, also known as independent schools, are educational institutions that are not administered or funded by the government. Instead, they rely on private funding sources such as tuition fees, donations, and endowment income. In the United States, for example, private schools have been around since the 19th century, with many Catholic parish churches, dioceses, and religious orders establishing schools independent of government funding.

There are different types of private school ownership. They can be private not-for-profit, where proceeds from fees or donations are reinvested into the school for facilities, materials, and salaries. Alternatively, they can be privately owned by individuals or corporations, where the funds generated go to the owner or a subsidiary, who then decide how much money to allocate to the school's operations. This profit-oriented nature of private ownership can influence the school's funding and operations.

Private schools often have the freedom to select their students and are not subject to the same level of government regulation as public schools. This independence allows them to define their unique missions, student admissions criteria, teacher qualifications, and curriculum. However, they are still subject to accreditation processes and typically have a board of governors or similar governing bodies to ensure their independent operation.

The prevalence of privately managed schools varies across countries. For instance, in Australia, the education system is highly privatized, with 30% of primary students and over 40% of secondary students attending private schools. On the other hand, in Italy, about one-fifth of schools are private, catering to around 10% of Italian schoolchildren.

The growth of private schools has been influenced by various factors, such as the demand for English-medium education, dissatisfaction with public schools, affordability, and the availability of specific fields of study. However, it is important to note that private schools are generally more expensive than public schools, and their fees can vary significantly depending on factors like the student's year level, school size, and the socio-economics of the school community.

Frequently asked questions