Investors Losing Faith: What's Next For The Industry?

It is unclear which industry you are referring to, but I can tell you about some of the reasons investors lose faith in companies and industries.

In 2022, investors endured a negative return shock across global financial markets, with many fixed-income assets witnessing the worst start to a calendar year on record. The combination of central banks raising interest rates to curb inflation, the ongoing Ukraine crisis, surging energy prices, and the threat of recession created a highly toxic backdrop for investors.

In the same year, the worst sell-off across all fixed-income assets on record led many to question the role of a diversified fixed-income allocation in a portfolio.

Additionally, stock prices can fall due to changes in investor sentiment, poor financial performance, rising interest rates, geopolitical tensions, major shareholder actions, and sector-specific problems. When investors lose faith in a company, they typically sell off their stocks and invest elsewhere.

Is there a specific industry you would like to know more about?

Surprises and lack of transparency

Surprises are a major reason why investors lose confidence. As Jason M. Lemkin, founder of SaaS and Cloud, notes, "Nothing undermines confidence more than an out-of-the-blue email that growth plummeted." Investors expect a rough quarter or two, but as a founder, it's important to keep them in the loop well ahead of time. Being transparent about challenges and providing multiple early warnings can make all the difference in maintaining their confidence.

Another aspect of transparency is sharing financial information and providing prompt investor updates. Withholding information or delaying updates can create anxiety and undermine investor confidence. Being proactive in sharing bad news, along with an action plan to address it, is crucial. Hiding issues or surprises can spook investors and lead to a loss of faith.

Additionally, it's essential to have a realistic plan for growth and to communicate it clearly. Investors want to understand how you plan to adjust your strategy, upgrade your team, and improve your product to get back on track. They also want to know your understanding of the Zero Cash Date and its implications.

Being too optimistic or too negative in investor updates can also be detrimental. It's important to strike a balance by being positive yet grounded in data and reality. Providing realistic investor reports that are honest about challenges while also highlighting opportunities can help maintain investor confidence.

In summary, surprises and a lack of transparency can significantly impact investor confidence. Being proactive in communicating challenges, providing realistic plans, and sharing prompt updates are key to maintaining investor faith during difficult periods.

Poor financial performance

For example, in the case of the US fracking oil industry, despite reaching record-high production levels, the industry has been struggling to turn a profit. This has led to legendary oil trader Andy Hall shutting down his main hedge fund, and other investors may follow suit as they lose faith in the industry's profitability.

Another example is when a company reports lower-than-expected earnings, profits, or revenue. This can signal to investors that the company is underperforming financially, leading to a sell-off as shareholders lose confidence. Missed earnings targets or profit warnings are key triggers for stock price declines and can result in a significant loss of faith in the company's prospects.

Additionally, during economic downturns or recessions, consumer spending decreases, and business investments slow down. This can lead to reduced revenues and potential layoffs for companies, causing their stock values to fall. Investors often pull out of equities in favor of safer assets during these times, further compounding the decline in stock prices.

Furthermore, rising interest rates can also impact stock prices. When central banks raise interest rates, borrowing becomes more expensive for companies and consumers, reducing corporate profits and consumer spending. This can lead to a shift in investor sentiment, with money flowing out of stocks and into bonds and other fixed-income investments.

To maintain investor confidence and avoid losing faith, it is crucial for companies to consistently meet or exceed financial expectations, adapt to changing market conditions, and effectively communicate their financial health and growth strategies to investors.

Lack of a realistic plan

A lack of realistic planning can cause investors to lose faith in a company. For instance, investors in the US fracking industry have lost faith in the industry's profitability. Despite record highs in shale oil production, companies are cutting their capital expenditures, which will hinder future oil discoveries and production. This, in addition to the industry's mounting debt, has resulted in a loss of investor confidence.

Similarly, investors lose faith when companies fail to provide a realistic plan to recover from a rough quarter. This is especially true if the company lacks a clear vision for growth and fails to communicate its plans, thoughts, and strategies to investors. For example, a company that is unable to make up for a poor quarter, outline adjustments, or explain how it is upgrading its team and product will likely cause investors to lose faith.

Furthermore, investors lose faith when companies do not have a realistic financing plan and rely on existing investors to bail them out. It is the founder's responsibility to ensure the company does not run out of money, and blindly relying on investors to provide funding during difficult times can quickly erode confidence.

Additionally, companies that are too slow to make key hires, evolve their product, or adapt to changes will also cause investors to lose faith. Investors are aware that the best founders are able to evolve and make necessary changes quickly. If a company takes too long to address issues, investors may lose confidence in its ability to win and succeed.

In summary, a lack of realistic planning can manifest in various ways, including poor financial performance, lack of growth, and slow adaptation to changes. When companies fail to address these issues and provide a clear and realistic path forward, investors may lose faith and choose to sell their stocks and invest elsewhere.

Geopolitical tensions

Rising Inter-State Tensions:

The increase in inter-state tensions has been most pronounced in Europe, but all regions have been affected. The conflict between Russia and Ukraine has upended Russia's relations with the EU and its immediate neighbours. The rivalry between the US and China has also contributed to rising tensions in Asia, with both superpowers using a mix of inducements and coercive tactics to further their interests.

Economic and Technological Competition:

The US-China relationship has been characterised by a steady and downward trajectory, with the US becoming more concerned about China's behaviour in international commerce and human rights issues. This has led to export controls, investment limitations, and technological competition between the two countries. The desire to maintain economic growth and entice foreign investors creates uncertainty and sends mixed signals.

Impact on Natural Resources:

The Middle East tensions, particularly between Israel and Iran, have raised concerns about the potential disruption of significant transit routes like the Strait of Hormuz, which accounts for almost 20% of global oil supply. While Iran itself is a small oil supplier, a broader conflict in the region could impact energy supply and prices.

Inflation and Monetary Policy:

A surge in energy costs due to geopolitical tensions can impact inflation, especially in Europe, which is more energy-dependent than North America. Central banks may struggle to balance inflation risks with potential growth headwinds, making monetary policy decisions tricky.

Market Volatility:

Investment Opportunities:

Geopolitical realignments can create new investment opportunities in different regions. Countries with sophisticated technology sectors, such as Japan and South Korea, or those with cost-effective labour forces, like Mexico, may attract additional investment flows due to their proximity to major powers.

Risk Mitigation:

Assets with physical value, such as gold and oil, can serve as effective hedges against extreme developments arising from geopolitical tensions.

Sector-specific problems

In the oil and gas industry, investors might be losing faith due to high costs and low returns. Despite record-high U.S. shale oil production, the industry is not profitable. Oil trader Andy Hall's hedge fund lost 30% in the first half of 2017, and other major players like Pioneer Natural Resources and Occidental Petroleum have faced significant losses. The high costs and low returns in this industry may be due to the large amounts of capital expenditures and negative free cash flow.

Additionally, the oil industry faces another negative factor that could spell trouble: the staggering amount of water consumed in shale oil and gas production in the United States. This issue has received little media attention, but it poses a significant threat to farming and drinking water sources in arid states. As a result, investors in the fracking industry may be facing increased scrutiny and criticism for their involvement in this sector.

In the SaaS and Cloud sector, companies like Datadog, Snowflake, HubSpot, and Salesforce are growing faster than ever, with revenue surpassing $1 billion. However, the stock market has taken a tumble, leading to a dramatic change in the VC ecosystem and making venture funding twice as hard to obtain. This situation may cause investors to lose faith in the industry as they panic about their investments and the ability of companies to deliver on their promises.

Frequently asked questions