Faith And Skepticism: Coexisting In Harmony

Faith and skepticism have a complex relationship. While some people of faith may be skeptical of other religions or certain aspects of their own, skepticism is generally associated with questioning religious authority and doubting the existence of God. Religious skeptics are not necessarily anti-religious or atheists; they may be theists who reject organized religion or deists who question the legitimacy of religious beliefs. The majority of skeptics are agnostics and atheists, but there are also religious people who are skeptical, generally about other religions or conflicting denominations.

The term skeptic comes from the Greek word skeptikos, meaning inquiring. Socrates, one of history's most prominent religious skeptics, embodies this inquiring nature by critiquing the legitimacy of the Greek gods. Similarly, in ancient India, the Cārvāka school of philosophy was known for its skepticism of the religious claims of the Vedic religion.

For some, skepticism is a tool of inquiry and critique, a systematic examination of religious beliefs from a critical distance. This can lead to a dynamic tension between skepticism and faith, where the authenticity of scriptures, the idea of religious affections, and the notion of subjective experiences as evidence of the divine are challenged.

Despite the apparent contradiction between faith and skepticism, it is possible to hold both simultaneously. For example, the Christian apologist C.S. Lewis, who was once an atheist, stated that being a Christian does not require believing that all other religions are wrong. Instead, he suggested that Christianity is right where it differs from other religions, but that does not mean that other religions do not contain hints of truth.

Additionally, the concept of skeptical theism acknowledges the existence of God while maintaining skepticism about our ability to understand God's reasons for acting or refraining from acting in certain instances. This view undercuts the primary argument for atheism, known as the argument from evil, by asserting that we cannot know if any instance of evil is gratuitous, and therefore, we cannot conclude that God does not exist based on the existence of evil.

In conclusion, while faith and skepticism may seem contradictory, they can coexist and even lead to a deeper understanding of one's beliefs.

Recognise the benefits of scepticism

Scepticism is a tool for inquiry and critique. It is a method of intellectual inquiry and caution that requires applying reason to the ideas and information presented to us. It encourages us to pause and reflect before accepting something as true.

Protection from Manipulation

Scepticism helps protect us from manipulation by encouraging us to ask the right questions. By questioning the legitimacy of beliefs and claims, we can avoid being taken advantage of or misled.

Encourages Critical Thinking

Scepticism is a key part of critical thinking. It involves systematically doubting and critiquing beliefs, promoting a more rational view of the world. This can lead to breakthroughs and innovative solutions to problems.

Accurate Understanding of the World

By questioning and verifying information, scepticism helps us develop an accurate understanding of the world. It allows us to separate facts from stories and conjecture, leading to better decision-making.

Self-Reflection and Growth

Scepticism is not just about questioning others but also ourselves. By applying scepticism to our own assumptions and beliefs, we can identify and challenge our biases and limitations. This self-reflection can lead to personal growth and a more open-minded perspective.

Encouraging Dialogue and Tolerance

Scepticism can foster dialogue and tolerance by creating a space for different viewpoints to be expressed and examined. It encourages active engagement with diverse ideas, promoting intellectual humility and a willingness to consider alternative perspectives.

Safeguarding against Extremism

By questioning religious authority and doctrines, scepticism can act as a safeguard against religious extremism. It encourages individuals to think critically about their beliefs and those of others, promoting tolerance and discouraging blind adherence to dogma.

While scepticism has numerous benefits, it is important to approach it productively. This involves detangling our identity from our ideas, remaining open-minded, and expressing our scepticism in a respectful and non-confrontational manner.

Understand the difference between faith and blind faith

Faith and blind faith are two very different concepts, and understanding the distinction between the two is crucial.

Faith, in its simplest form, means having complete trust or confidence in something or someone. It is often associated with religion, where individuals have faith in a higher power or divine entity. This faith is usually based on spiritual experiences, textual evidence from sacred scriptures, or the teachings of religious leaders. For example, in the Bible, 1 Peter 3:15 encourages believers to "always be ready to give an answer to anyone who asks [them] to give a reason for the hope that [they] have".

However, blind faith takes on a different nuance. The term "blind" here implies a lack of evidence or a disregard for it. It suggests that an individual is choosing to believe in something despite having no proof or even in the face of contradictory evidence. In other words, blind faith is belief without critical examination or logical reasoning.

To illustrate, let's consider the example of a person who has faith in a friend's honesty. This faith may be based on past experiences where the friend has proven to be trustworthy. However, if this person continues to believe the friend despite evidence of deception, it would be an example of blind faith.

It is important to note that faith is often associated with a positive connotation, implying hope and trust. On the other hand, blind faith often carries a negative connotation, suggesting willful ignorance or a lack of critical thinking.

Additionally, blind faith is not encouraged in many religious traditions. For instance, in Christianity, the Bible contains numerous instances where followers are urged to defend their faith and provide reasons for their beliefs. Passages such as 2 Corinthians 10:5 and 1 Peter 3:15 emphasise the importance of having a reasoned and defensible faith.

In conclusion, while faith can be a powerful force that provides hope and trust, blind faith is often seen as a weakness, indicating a lack of critical thinking and an unwillingness to engage with evidence.

Know that faith is not the opposite of knowledge

Faith is often seen as the opposite of knowledge, but this is a misconception. The two are not mutually exclusive, and one can have faith while also possessing knowledge. In fact, as J. P. Moreland argues, Christian faith is based on knowledge, and as our knowledge increases, so too can our faith strengthen.

This view of faith and knowledge as opposites is not only incorrect but also harmful and widespread. It assumes that faith is a choice to believe something despite a lack of evidence or reasonable considerations. However, this assumption is problematic for two main reasons. Firstly, it is impossible to simply choose what to believe. We cannot just decide to believe something without any basis, no matter how much we may want to or how much incentive we have. Secondly, this view of faith is unbiblical and lacking in common sense.

Instead, a better definition of faith is that it is a confidence or trust in something or someone based on what one knows about the object of faith. This does not mean that we will always understand God's plan or the specific reasons behind certain religious teachings. However, it does mean that when we take a leap of faith, we do so with a foundation of knowledge about God that allows us to trust in Him even during difficult or uncertain times.

For example, consider the story of Abraham's intention to sacrifice Isaac (Gen. 22:1–18). Abraham likely had many questions and did not fully understand why God was asking him to make this sacrifice. Yet, he had enough knowledge of God's character and trust in Him to step out in faith. Similarly, in our own lives, we may not always know why God is leading us in a certain direction or asking us to take a particular action. But if we have knowledge of God and His faithfulness, we can have the confidence to move forward in faith, even when we don't have all the answers.

In essence, faith and knowledge go hand in hand. The more we know and understand, the stronger our faith can become. So, rather than seeing them as opposites, we should recognize that knowledge can be the very foundation of our faith.

Accept that faith and scepticism can coexist

Faith and scepticism can coexist, and this is a viewpoint that has been held by many throughout history.

The Historical Perspective

Firstly, it is important to note that scepticism and faith are not mutually exclusive. Many people of faith have also been sceptics, and this has been the case since ancient times. Socrates, for example, is known for questioning the legitimacy of the religious beliefs of his time, yet he still conceived of the divine as always benevolent, truthful, authoritative, and wise. This critique of established religion did not equate to a rejection of religion itself.

Similarly, in early modern history, Thomas Hobbes disagreed with orthodox Christian teachings, arguing that all things, even God, heaven, and hell, are corporeal and in motion. However, this did not make him anti-religious; he simply rejected certain organised religious beliefs.

The Modern Perspective

In modern times, the term ''religious scepticism'' typically refers to doubting or questioning specific religious beliefs and practices, rather than a rejection of religion as a whole. Religious sceptics may question religious authority, specific doctrines, or the validity of certain claims made by religious institutions. This scepticism can lead to a deeper exploration and understanding of faith.

Additionally, in a pluralistic society, encountering other faiths and worldviews can lead to a more accepting and tolerant attitude. As C.S. Lewis noted, being a Christian does not mean believing that all other religions are wrong. Instead, he suggested that other religions may contain hints of truth, and this realisation can foster a more liberal and accepting attitude towards those with different beliefs.

The Benefits of Scepticism

Scepticism can be a healthy attitude that leads to personal growth and a deeper understanding of one's beliefs. It encourages critical thinking, the examination of evidence, and the suspension of judgment until sufficient evidence is available. This process can strengthen one's faith by providing a more solid foundation based on personal inquiry and reflection.

Furthermore, scepticism can play a positive role in society by challenging dogmatic beliefs and promoting intellectual curiosity. It can inspire social movements, encourage scientific inquiry, and lead to advancements in various fields, including science, medicine, and philosophy.

In conclusion, faith and scepticism can not only coexist but can also enhance each other. Scepticism can lead to a deeper exploration and appreciation of faith, while faith can provide a foundation for trust, hope, and a shared vision of the world.

Recognise that faith is not just about believing

Faith is often associated with belief, but the two are distinct concepts. Faith is about much more than intellectual assent to a set of doctrines. It is a commitment of the whole self, a hope and trust that, if genuine, ought to be the foundation of an entire way of life and vision of the world. Beliefs are linguistic formulations that try to express the cognitive content of faith as a lived experience.

Faith is not the same as belief. Faith involves reliance and trust, and it endures in the face of doubts. You can have faith in things or people without a corresponding belief, and vice versa. For instance, one who has faith in God may also hold the belief that God exists. But one can have faith without the corresponding belief.

Faith is a type of trust. Having faith in God is making a practical commitment – the kind involved in trusting God, or trusting in God. The root meaning of the Greek pistis, 'faith', is 'trust'.

Faith is also about action. The kind of faith of which Christian faith is a paradigm case may be understood as 'action-centred commitment' – to the Christian 'way'. Arguably, faith understood as a combination of affective and cognitive elements would miss its essential active component.

Faith is a virtue. It is traditionally regarded as one of the 'theological' virtues. If a virtue is a 'disposition of character which instantiates or promotes responsiveness to one or more basic goods', then theistic faith qualifies since it is 'a responsiveness to practical hope and truth', provided theistic faith-claims are indeed true.

Faith is not necessarily religious. There may be non-religious faith, for example, in 'scientific atheists' or 'naturalists' who make a faith venture when they take there to be no more to reality than is in principle discoverable by the natural sciences.

Frequently asked questions