Have Ministers And Evangelicals Really Forsaken Their Faith?

The question of whether well-known spiritual ministers and evangelicals have forsaken the faith is a complex one. While there is no definitive answer, it is important to consider the various factors that could contribute to such a decision. Some individuals may have experienced a crisis of faith, while others may have chosen to leave the church due to personal reasons or disagreements with its teachings. It is also worth noting that the term evangelical can encompass a broad range of beliefs and denominations, making it challenging to define who exactly qualifies as an evangelical. Nonetheless, there have been notable figures in the evangelical community who have publicly renounced their faith or distanced themselves from organized religion. For example, Ted Haggard, the founder and former pastor of New Life Church, resigned from his position after allegations of sexual misconduct and drug use. Additionally, some individuals may choose to remain in the church despite losing their faith, creating a sense of internal conflict and uncertainty. The Clergy Project is an organization that provides support for religious professionals who have lost their faith, illustrating the prevalence of this issue. Ultimately, the decision to forsake the faith is a deeply personal one, and the reasons behind it can vary greatly from person to person.

The Clergy Project: a support group for religious professionals who have lost their faith

The Clergy Project (TCP) is a non-profit organisation that provides support to current and former religious leaders who no longer believe in a god or other supernatural elements. It was launched in March 2011 as a collaborative effort to create an online space for deconverted clergy to gather and support one another.

Who is it for?

The Clergy Project is for current or former religious professionals who no longer hold supernatural beliefs. Applicants are carefully vetted and must meet two qualifications for forum admission: being both religious professionals (current or formerly employed) and non-supernaturalist.

The group focuses on providing private online forums for its participants, as well as career transition assistance (including career coaching grants) and subsidised psychotherapy sessions in partnership with Recovering from Religion's Secular Therapy Project.

The online community of forums is a safe and secure space composed entirely of religious leaders who no longer hold supernatural beliefs. Participants can choose to identify themselves with a pseudonym and an avatar image if they prefer, and the private-access website is held secure to ensure anonymity.

Forum discussions include practical concerns such as finding a new career path and deciding when and how to come out as a non-believer, as well as more philosophical conversations centred on ethics and humanism.

Who is involved?

The Clergy Project was started by Dan Barker, a former Christian minister, and scientist and activist Richard Dawkins, after they met at the 2006 International Humanist and Ethical Union Convention in Reykjavik, Iceland. Dawkins wanted to find a way to help others in situations like Barker's and brought Robin Elisabeth Cornwell, then-executive director of the Richard Dawkins Foundation for Reason and Science, on board. The Richard Dawkins Foundation provided the funding and technical support needed to create and administer TCP's online community of forums and subsequent website.

As of September 2019, TCP had reached a milestone of 1,000 verified non-believing clergy (current and former) participating. Participants come from a wide range of religious and cultural backgrounds, including Islam, Judaism, Buddhism, Hinduism, Scientology, and more than thirty different segments of Christianity.

The emotional and social difficulties of losing one's faith

Losing one's faith can be a challenging and emotionally difficult experience, often leading to feelings of confusion, self-doubt, and uncertainty. It can be hard to know what to do or where to turn. The emotional and social difficulties associated with losing one's faith can be particularly acute for spiritual ministers and evangelicals, as their entire lives, careers, and social networks may be built around their religious beliefs.

Emotional difficulties

Losing one's faith can result in a range of emotions, including confusion, self-doubt, and uncertainty. It can be a devastating experience that undermines one's confidence, convictions, and well-being. It is not uncommon for individuals to feel guilty or ashamed about losing their faith, especially if they have previously been staunch believers. This can lead to a sense of self-condemnation and self-criticism. The loss of faith can also trigger feelings of grief and mourning, as individuals may feel they are losing something that was once a significant part of their lives.

For spiritual ministers and evangelicals, the emotional difficulties of losing their faith can be intensified. They may feel like they are losing their sense of purpose and identity, as their entire lives and careers may have been built around their religious beliefs. This can lead to a crisis of meaning and a search for a new sense of purpose.

Social difficulties

The social implications of losing one's faith can also be significant, especially for spiritual ministers and evangelicals. They may find themselves disconnected from their religious communities and social networks, which can lead to feelings of isolation and loneliness. If their friends and associates are predominantly from their religious community, they may struggle to maintain those relationships or find a new social circle.

For spiritual ministers and evangelicals, the social difficulties of losing their faith can be exacerbated. They may feel like they are letting down their congregation or followers, who looked up to them for spiritual guidance and support. They may also face judgment or ostracism from their religious community, particularly if they are seen as having abandoned their faith or betrayed their beliefs.

Additionally, spiritual ministers and evangelicals may face practical challenges, such as losing their source of income and struggling to find alternative employment, especially if they have dedicated their lives to religious service and have limited transferable skills.

Coping strategies

Acknowledging and accepting one's emotions is an important first step when dealing with the loss of faith. It is crucial to show oneself compassion and seek support from loved ones or counselors if needed. Meditation, prayer, and gratitude practices can help individuals reconnect with their spirituality and find inner peace. Social support is also essential, whether it be from loved ones, support groups, or faith-based therapists/counselors. Reflecting on one's beliefs and values, engaging in acts of kindness, and spending time in nature can also aid in processing the loss of faith and discovering new sources of meaning and connection.

The financial and career difficulties of leaving the pulpit

Leaving the pulpit can be a challenging decision for spiritual ministers and evangelicals, often involving financial and career difficulties. Here are some expanded insights into these challenges:

Financial Challenges:

• Financial instability is a significant concern for clergy members who contemplate leaving the pulpit. Many individuals in this situation, like "Lynn", an active Methodist pastor and atheist, choose to remain in their positions due to financial commitments. Leaving their current role might cause financial hardship for themselves and their families.
• Clergy members often face the challenge of transitioning to secular employment. They may need to acquire new skills, relocate, or start over in a different career, which can be daunting and financially unstable.
• The Clergy Project, a support group for clergy who have left the supernatural beliefs of their religious traditions, recognizes the financial challenges its members face. The project provides a safe space for individuals like "Lynn" to seek guidance and share success stories of finding gainful secular employment.

Career Difficulties:

• Leaving the pulpit can result in a loss of community and social connections. Clergy members may risk losing friends, being ostracized by their community, and even facing rejection from their families. This can be isolating and detrimental to their mental health.
• The career transition for former clergy members can be challenging due to the specialized nature of their previous work. They may need to develop new skill sets, adapt to different work cultures, and face the uncertainty of starting over in a new career path.
• Some former clergy members may struggle with feelings of fraudulence or imposter syndrome as they navigate their new careers. They may question their abilities and worry about being exposed as former religious leaders, especially if they are not ready to disclose their past publicly.
• The pressure and expectations placed on clergy members are immense. They are often expected to be available 24/7, provide counseling, and navigate complex political and administrative duties. Leaving the pulpit can be a way to alleviate these pressures and set healthier boundaries.
• However, it is important to note that not all career transitions are negative. Some former clergy members, like Justin Barringer, have found fulfilling work outside of traditional ministry, such as working with the unhoused and opening their homes to the community.

The reasons why religious leaders lose their faith

It is not uncommon for religious leaders to lose their faith. In fact, there are many reasons why this may happen. One reason could be that they are no longer sure about their beliefs and are going through a crisis of faith. This could be due to a variety of factors, such as personal doubts, changes in theological views, or even trauma or suffering that causes them to question their faith. Another reason could be that they feel constrained by the doctrines and practices of their religion and wish to explore other spiritual paths. Additionally, some religious leaders may leave their faith due to disagreements with the religious institution or its members. This could be related to issues such as social justice, inclusion, or political differences. Furthermore, some religious leaders may experience burnout or disillusionment, leading them to question their faith and seek alternative paths.

It is important to note that losing one's faith can be a traumatic and challenging experience, especially for those whose entire lives and careers are built around their religious beliefs. Leaving the faith can lead to feelings of confusion, self-doubt, and uncertainty about the future. It can also be socially and emotionally difficult, as it may involve distancing oneself from religious communities, friends, and family members who share different beliefs.

For religious leaders, losing their faith can be particularly complex due to the expectations and responsibilities associated with their role. They may feel a sense of hypocrisy or struggle with the idea of counselling others in a faith they no longer hold. Additionally, they may face challenges in finding alternative career paths, as their training and skills may be specifically tailored to religious roles.

To conclude, there are various reasons why religious leaders may lose their faith, and it can be a difficult and complex journey. It is important to approach this topic with empathy and understanding, recognising the unique challenges and struggles that religious leaders may face in such situations.

The impact of losing faith on the lives of religious leaders and their families

Losing faith can be a traumatic experience for religious leaders, as it involves a complete shift in their worldview and often their entire identity. This can lead to massive confusion, self-doubt, self-condemnation, and uncertainty about the future. The impact of losing faith can be particularly devastating for religious leaders, as their livelihood and sense of purpose are often deeply intertwined with their religious beliefs. They may find themselves in a difficult position where they feel like they are losing their entire identity and sense of self.

The loss of faith can also have significant financial implications for religious leaders, as they may no longer be able to rely on their religious community for financial support. They may struggle to find alternative employment, especially if they have dedicated their lives to religious service and have not developed other marketable skills. This can cause significant stress and anxiety, especially if they have families to support.

The impact of losing faith on the families of religious leaders can be profound. They may feel like they are losing their spiritual guide and mentor, and their entire support system may be upended. Spouses and children may struggle to come to terms with the change in their loved one's beliefs and may even feel betrayed or abandoned. The religious leader may also face rejection and condemnation from their religious community, which can be extremely isolating and painful.

On the other hand, some religious leaders who lose their faith may find relief and freedom in their new perspective. They may feel like they are finally being true to themselves and living authentically. They may also find new purpose and meaning in life, such as through humanitarian work or social activism. Some may even continue to work within a religious context, using their skills and experience to support others going through similar crises of faith.

Overall, the impact of losing faith on the lives of religious leaders and their families can be complex and multifaceted. It can involve a range of emotions, from grief and confusion to relief and freedom. It can also have significant practical implications, affecting livelihoods, relationships, and sense of self. The experience is deeply personal and unique to each individual, and there is no one-size-fits-all outcome.

Frequently asked questions