Honor Killings: Islamic Teachings And Misinterpretations

does the muslim faith support honor killings

Honor killings, also known as shame killings, are a traditional form of murder in which a person is killed by members of their family or their partner. Honor killings are often connected to religion, caste, or other forms of hierarchical social stratification. While they are associated with South Asia, the Middle East, and the Maghreb, they are also found in other societies, such as the Philippines, Northern Caucasus, Latin America, and East Africa. Although honor killings are condemned by international conventions and human rights organizations, various communities justify and encourage them.

The Muslim faith has been associated with honor killings, but does it support this practice? The answer is no. Honor killings are not caused or encouraged by Islam and are not specific to Muslims. In fact, Islamic teachings and the Quran condemn such acts. However, some argue that the misogynistic views towards women and their position in society, often found in Muslim-majority countries, create an environment where honor killings can occur.

Characteristics Values
Religion Islam, Hinduism, Sikhism
Region South Asia, Middle East, Maghreb, Philippines, Northern Caucasus, Latin America, East Africa, Ireland, Mediterranean Europe
Victims Women, Men
Reasons Dishonour, Sexuality, Caste, Hierarchy, Religion, Dress, Marriage, Divorce, Rape, Homosexuality
Islamic Teachings Not caused or encouraged by Islam, not specific to Muslims, forbidden by Islamic law

shunspirit

Honour killings are not supported by Islamic teachings

In Islam, honour killing is considered a transgression and wrongdoing because it involves killing someone who does not deserve to be killed. According to Islamic teachings, the punishment for a virgin who commits fornication is flogging and banishment for one year, not execution. The Quran also states that killing a believer intentionally is a grave crime, and that the recompense for such an act is Hell.

The Prophet Muhammad's teachings also condemn honour killings. When asked what would happen if a husband found his wife with another man, the Prophet responded that the husband could not kill him and that no one could be punished unless there were four witnesses who had seen the act. The Quran outlines the procedure for husbands or wives who suspect infidelity, stating that the couple would appear before a judge, and the accusing spouse would swear to God that their accusation was true. If the accused spouse then swore to God that they were innocent, neither party was punished but the couple was divorced.

Muslim scholars have also spoken out against honour killings. The late Yemeni Muslim scholar, Muhammad Shawkani, wrote that one reason the Sharia stipulates execution as a potential punishment for men who murder women is to counter honour killings for alleged slights of honour. He wrote, "There is no doubt that laxity on this matter is one of the greatest means leading to women's lives being destroyed, especially in the Bedouin regions, which are characterized by harsh-heartedness and a strong sense of honour and shame stemming from Pre-Islamic times."

In conclusion, honour killings are not supported by Islamic teachings. They are considered a transgression and are condemned by the Quran, the Prophet Muhammad's teachings, and Muslim scholars. The idea that Islam supports honour killings is based on ignorance and a misunderstanding of the religion.

shunspirit

Honour killings are a result of societal culture, not religion

At their core, honour killings are rooted in societal norms and beliefs that emphasise family honour and reputation. They are typically carried out by male family members who believe that the victim, usually a woman or girl, has brought dishonour or shame to the family. This perception of dishonour can arise from a variety of reasons, such as engaging in premarital or extramarital relationships, refusing arranged marriages, or violating societal expectations of female chastity and modesty.

While some may argue that Islam, or other religions, play a role in honour killings, it is essential to understand that these acts are not condoned by religious teachings. In Islam, for example, honour killing is considered a "transgression and wrongdoing" because it involves killing someone who does not deserve to be killed. The Quran and prophetic traditions provide clear guidelines for addressing cases of suspected or proven adultery, which do not include honour killings.

Additionally, honour killings are not unique to any specific religion or culture. They have been observed in societies with different religious and cultural backgrounds, indicating that the underlying cause is not religion but rather societal norms and power dynamics. Honour killings are often associated with patriarchal societies where male family members exert control over women's lives and restrict their rights and autonomy.

Furthermore, the notion of honour and the need to preserve it through violent means is not exclusive to any particular religion. Honour cultures, which exist in various parts of the world, prioritise managing reputation and maintaining social standing within the community. In these cultures, an insult to one's personal or family honour is seen as a threat to their social status and must be met with a response, often in the form of violence.

In conclusion, honour killings are a complex societal issue that cannot be attributed solely to religion. They are a result of intersecting factors, including societal norms, power dynamics, and cultural beliefs that emphasise honour and reputation. While religion may play a role in shaping societal values, honour killings are ultimately a reflection of societal culture and power structures that exist across various religious and cultural contexts.

shunspirit

Honour killings are a form of femicide

Honour killings are often associated with South Asia, the Middle East, and the Maghreb, but they are also rooted in other societies, such as the Philippines, Northern Caucasus, Latin America, and East Africa. They are also prevalent in some of their respective diasporas in countries that do not otherwise have societal norms that encourage honour killings. Honour killings are often associated with rural and tribal areas, but they occur in urban areas as well.

In many cases, the honour killings are committed by family members against a female relative considered to have disgraced her family. Honour killings are primarily the murder of a woman or girl by male family members, due to the perpetrators' belief that the victim has lost her innocence by bringing dishonour or shame upon the family name, reputation, or prestige. Honour killings are often planned by multiple members of a family, sometimes through a formal "family council". The threat of murder is used as a means to control behaviour, especially concerning sexuality and marriage, which may be seen as a duty for some or all family members to uphold.

shunspirit

Honour killings are a global issue

Honour killings are often associated with rural and tribal areas, but they can also take place in urban settings. They are typically carried out by male family members against female relatives, due to the perpetrators' belief that the victim has brought dishonour or shame to the family name, reputation, or prestige. However, both men and women can be victims and perpetrators of honour killings. The reasons for honour killings can vary and include refusing an arranged marriage, seeking a divorce, engaging in interfaith or interracial relationships, or being the victim of a sexual crime.

The cultural features that lead to honour killings are complex and involve a mix of religion, caste, social stratification, and sexuality. In many cases, honour killings are committed to punish violations of social, sexual, religious, or family norms or hierarchies. While honour killings are often connected to specific religions or societies, the data suggests that they are primarily a cultural phenomenon rather than a religious one. For example, while honour killings are common in Muslim-majority countries like Pakistan, they are virtually unknown in other Muslim-majority countries like Indonesia, Bangladesh, Senegal, Qatar, and the United Arab Emirates.

The practice of honour killings has been condemned by international conventions and human rights organizations as a serious violation of human rights. Honour killings are addressed by several international instruments, including United Nations General Assembly Resolution 55/66 and the Council of Europe Convention on preventing and combating violence against women and domestic violence. Despite these efforts, the complex cultural and social factors that contribute to honour killings make it a challenging issue to address.

shunspirit

Honour killings are not exclusive to the Muslim faith

In fact, honour killings have been prevalent in Mediterranean countries such as Italy, Greece, France, Spain, and Portugal until relatively recently. Honour killings have a long tradition in Mediterranean Europe, where the concept of honour is a code of conduct, a way of life, and an ideal social order. In Corsica, for example, there was a strong custom of vendetta, which required Corsicans to murder anyone who wronged their family honour. Between 1821 and 1852, approximately 4,300 vendetta killings were perpetrated in Corsica. Generational family feuds resulting in murders continue to take place in Sardinia in the 21st century.

In addition, honour killings have occurred in various countries across the world, including Brazil, Canada, Ecuador, Egypt, India, Israel, Italy, Jordan, Morocco, Sweden, Syria, Uganda, the United Kingdom, and the United States. Honour killings have also taken place in western countries such as France, Germany, and the United Kingdom within migrant communities.

Honour killings are also not exclusive to any particular religion. While they are most commonly associated with Islam, they have also been found in societies of different faiths, including Coptic Christians in Egypt and Hindus and Sikhs in India. Honour killings are primarily a cultural phenomenon, rooted in tribal customs and traditions of control over women.

The practice of honour killings is not supported by Islamic teachings or the Quran. In fact, many Muslim scholars and organisations have condemned honour killings as an un-Islamic cultural practice. Islamic law, or Shariah, clearly states that honour killing is a transgression and wrongdoing, as it involves killing someone who does not deserve to be killed. The Prophet Muhammad is reported to have said that a husband who kills his wife and/or her lover has committed homicide and should be punished accordingly.

Frequently asked questions

Written by
Reviewed by
  • Aisha
  • Aisha
    Author Editor Reviewer
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment