Who's A Jew? Exploring Jewish Identity And Heritage

The Jewish faith is passed down through the mother, meaning that a person is considered Jewish if they are born to a Jewish mother. This is a principle of Rabbinic Judaism, and it is observed in Orthodox and Conservative Judaism. However, Reform and Reconstructionist Judaism accept full Jewishness through either parent.

The origin of this principle is not entirely clear, but it is thought to have begun in late antiquity. One reason given for this principle is that the identity of the mother is always certain, but not that of the father. Another reason could be the influence of the Roman legal system, which determined personal status based on the mother.

The question of who is a Jew? has been a controversial issue, and the acceptance of patrilineal descent by some Jewish movements has deepened the division between opposing viewpoints.

Jewishness is passed down through the mother

The mother's role in shaping a child's identity is considered more significant than the father's, and this is reflected in the way Jewishness is passed down through the maternal line. While DNA testing can now confirm paternity, the argument for matrilineal descent goes beyond biological connections. It is believed that the mother's soul and identity are imprinted on the child during gestation, and this spiritual connection is what defines Jewishness.

The principle of matrilineal descent has been a topic of debate among different Jewish denominations. While Orthodox and Conservative Judaism adhere to the traditional view of matrilineal descent, Reform and Reconstructionist Judaism have adopted more inclusive approaches, recognising Jewishness through either parent if the child is raised in the Jewish faith.

The shift towards recognising patrilineal descent in some Jewish communities reflects a desire for inclusivity and a recognition of the changing nature of family structures and Jewish identity in the modern world. However, the traditional view of matrilineal descent remains firmly upheld by Orthodox and Conservative Jews, who consider it a fundamental principle of Jewish law.

The child of a Jewish mother is Jewish

The tradition of matrilineal descent dates back to at least late antiquity, though the precise date of the shift from patrilineal to matrilineal descent is disputed. Historical evidence indicates that the change took place in the 1st century, though other opinions suggest it was likely instituted in the early Tannaitic period or the time of Ezra. The Talmud adduces the law of matrilineal descent from Deuteronomy 7:3–4, which warns that as the consequence of intermarriage, a non-Jewish father will turn the child away from following God. Since only the non-Jewish father is mentioned and not the non-Jewish mother, the Talmud concludes that a child born to a Jewish mother is considered Jewish.

The stories of the Patriarchs and Matriarchs in Genesis are generally compatible with matrilineal descent, if one makes the assumption that Abraham's extended family was Jewish. Abraham fathered children with three wives or concubines: Sarah, Hagar, and Keturah. According to Jewish tradition, Sarah was a member of Abraham's extended family, and her descendants became Jewish. Hagar and Keturah's descendants were considered non-Jewish. Isaac had one wife, Rebecca, a member of Abraham's extended family, and two sons, Jacob and Esau. Jacob's descendants became Jewish, while Esau's descendants were non-Jewish due to their mothers being Hittite and Ishmaelite. Jacob had two wives, Leah and Rachel, and two concubines, Zilpah and Bilhah, who entered the family as maidservants of Leah and Rachel. All of Jacob's children were considered Jewish, as Zilpah and Bilhah were considered to belong to their mistresses Leah and Rachel.

The Conservative and Orthodox movements continue to hold by matrilineal descent, which would require that children born to non-Jewish mothers undergo conversion in order to be considered Jewish. The Reform and Reconstructionist movements, on the other hand, accept full Jewishness through either parent, provided the child is raised as Jewish.

The child of a non-Jewish mother is not Jewish

The child of a non-Jewish mother is not considered Jewish according to traditional Jewish law. This principle of matrilineal descent has been a fundamental part of the Torah since the Jewish people came into existence. However, the resolution on this issue has not always been clear-cut, and there are differing opinions on the matter.

The Principle of Matrilineal Descent

The Code of Jewish Law states that a child of a Jewish mother is Jewish, regardless of the father’s lineage. On the other hand, the child of a non-Jewish mother is not Jewish. This principle of matrilineal descent has been a fundamental part of the Torah since the Jewish people came into existence.

The Debate on Matrilineal Descent

Despite the principle of matrilineal descent, the issue of whether the child of a non-Jewish mother can be considered Jewish has been a subject of debate. While some see it as a radical departure from tradition, others view it as a more inclusive approach to the increasing prevalence of interfaith families.

In 1983, the Central Conference of American Rabbis (CCAR), the Reform movement’s body of rabbis, passed a resolution that contradicted nearly 2,000 years of tradition. The resolution stated that the child of a Jewish father and a non-Jewish mother could be considered Jewish under certain circumstances. This resolution was not the first attempt to reconsider patrilineal descent. In the 19th century, many Reform rabbis quietly integrated children of Jewish fathers and non-Jewish mothers into their religious schools and confirmed them into the Jewish faith without requiring conversion.

The Arguments for Matrilineal Descent

There are several arguments put forward in support of matrilineal descent. Firstly, it is biologically and scientifically more valid as a child receives more DNA from their mother. Secondly, it is argued that a child from a mixed marriage cannot have a half-commitment or a double faith, and a clear choice must be made. In such cases, the certainty of maternity is given precedence over the doubt of paternity. Additionally, it is posited that the mother has a superior influence on the child's religious development.

The Arguments Against Matrilineal Descent

Those who argue against matrilineal descent believe that it is a form of control over women's bodies and a denial of the right of personhood. They advocate for a more inclusive approach, especially in the context of increasing interfaith marriages.

The child of a Jewish father and non-Jewish mother is not Jewish

The Code of Jewish Law states that a child is only Jewish if they are born to a Jewish mother. This means that the child of a Jewish father and a non-Jewish mother is not considered Jewish. This has been a fundamental principle of the Torah since the Jewish people came into existence.

In the past, there was a simple answer to the question of who is Jewish: if born to a non-Jewish mother, a person would need to undergo a ritual of conversion to be considered Jewish. However, since the early 1980s, the more liberal Jewish movements, such as Reconstructionist and Reform Judaism, have embraced broader definitions of "who is a Jew", to include children with one Jewish parent, of any gender, if raised with Jewish customs.

The Conservative and Orthodox movements continue to hold by matrilineal descent, which means that children born to non-Jewish mothers must undergo a formal conversion ritual to be considered Jewish. Orthodox Judaism holds that anyone with a Jewish mother also has irrevocable Jewish status; even if such a Jew were to convert to another religion, that person would still be considered Jewish by Jewish Law.

The Talmud concludes that "your (grand)son who comes from an Israelite woman is called 'your son'...while your (grand)son who comes from a foreign woman is not called 'your son'". Thus, Jewish descent is through the mother.

The stories of the Patriarchs and Matriarchs in Genesis are generally compatible with matrilineal descent, if one makes the assumption that Abraham's extended family was "Jewish". Abraham fathered children with three wives or concubines: Sarah, Hagar, and Keturah. According to Jewish tradition, Sarah was a member of Abraham's extended family, and her descendants became Jewish. Hagar and Keturah's descendants were considered non-Jewish.

In the United States, a 2013 Pew Research Center survey shows that American children of interfaith marriages are more likely to have been raised Jewish and identify as Jewish than in the past, which some scholars attribute to more welcoming and inclusive attitudes among Jewish organisations. However, studies have also shown that adults whose fathers are Jewish and whose mothers are not can identify lasting damage to their identity formation, family relations, and faith due to patrilineal rejection.

The child of a non-Jewish father and Jewish mother is Jewish

In Orthodox Judaism, the child of a non-Jewish father and a Jewish mother is considered Jewish. This is also the case in Conservative Judaism. However, in Reform Judaism and Reconstructionist Judaism, a child is considered Jewish if they have at least one Jewish parent, regardless of gender, if they are raised as Jewish.

The Code of Jewish Law states that a child of a Jewish mother is Jewish, regardless of the father's lineage. This has been a fundamental principle of the Torah since the Jewish people came into existence.

The child of a Jewish father and a non-Jewish mother is considered to be Zera Yisrael (Seed of Israel). This child is not considered Jewish, but some authorities encourage them to convert.

The Conservative Movement's Rabbinical Assembly has affirmed that "sincere Jews by choice" should be welcomed into the community. The movement actively reaches out to intermarried families by offering them opportunities for Jewish growth and enrichment.

In the United States, children of interfaith marriages are more likely to have been raised Jewish and identify as Jewish. This has been attributed to more welcoming and inclusive attitudes among Jewish organisations.

Frequently asked questions