Is Hate A Sin In Catholicism?

The Catholic Church's stance on hatred is complex, with theologians distinguishing between two types of hatred: odium abominationis (loathing) and odium inimicitiae (hostility). While the latter is considered a sin, the former is not, as it involves reprobation of what goes against the moral law. The Church emphasizes the importance of hating the sin but loving the sinner, a phrase attributed to St. Augustine, who wrote, With love for mankind and hatred for sins. This teaching aligns with biblical passages such as Romans 12:9, which states, Let love be genuine; hate what is evil, hold fast to what is good.

The Catholic Church teaches that it is never okay to hate people

The Catholic Church makes a distinction between hating a person and hating their actions or qualities. It is acceptable to hate sin, or evil qualities in a person, but not the person themselves. This is summarised in the phrase "love the sinner, hate the sin", which is derived from a letter written by St Augustine in c. 424.

Theologians identify two types of hatred: odium abominationis (loathing) and odium inimicitiae (hostility). The first type concentrates on the qualities or attributes of a person and only secondarily on the person themselves. This type of hatred is not considered a sin and may even represent a virtuous temper of soul. The second type of hatred aims directly at the person and takes pleasure in their discredit and misfortune. This type of hatred is considered a violation of the precept of charity and is always considered sinful.

The Catholic Church teaches that even God hates sin but loves sinners. This is demonstrated in the story of the woman taken in adultery (John 8:3-11), in which Jesus shows love for the woman but does not condone her sin. He tells her to "go and sin no more".

The concept of "hating the sin, not the sinner" can be difficult to explain and live by in a complex and polarised world. However, it remains an important part of Catholic teaching on charity and mercy.

The Church differentiates between two types of hatred: odium abominationis and odium inimicitiae

The Catholic Church differentiates between two types of hatred: odium abominationis and odium inimicitiae.

Odium abominationis, or loathing, refers to an intense dislike for the qualities or attributes of a person, with the feeling being directed secondarily at the person themselves. This form of hatred does not constitute a sin, and may even represent a virtuous temper of the soul. It is permissible to hate what is contrary to the moral law and detest wrongdoing. For instance, it is lawful to pray for the death of a perniciously active heresiarch to put a stop to their harm. However, it is important to ensure that this zeal is not an excuse for personal spite or rancour.

On the other hand, odium inimicitiae, or hostility, is a direct violation of the precept of charity and is always considered sinful. This type of hatred is aimed directly at the person, focusing on their perceived evil and unlovable qualities. It finds fierce satisfaction in their discredit and desires their hardship. When God becomes the object of this kind of hatred, it is considered the most grievous of sins, as it involves a direct enmity towards God and a regret for His divine perfections.

The differentiation between these two types of hatred underscores the importance of hating the sin but loving the sinner. While it is acceptable to detest sinful actions or qualities, the Catholic Church emphasizes that hatred should not be directed towards the individual person. This principle is reflected in St. Augustine's phrase, "Cum dilectione hominum et odio vitiorum," which translates to "With love for mankind and hatred of sins."

The Church teaches that it is acceptable to hate sin, but not the sinner

The Catholic Church teaches that it is acceptable to hate sin but not the sinner. This idea is derived from St. Augustine's Letter 211, "Cum dilectione hominum et odio vitiorum", which translates to "With love for mankind and hatred of sins". Over time, this has been adapted to the phrase "Love the sinner, hate the sin".

The concept is further supported by various Bible verses, including Romans 12:9, which states, "Let love be genuine; hate what is evil, hold fast to what is good". Additionally, Psalm 97:10 says, "The Lord loves those who hate evil", and Proverbs 8:13 states, "The fear of the Lord is hatred of evil".

This teaching encourages followers to distinguish between the act of sinning and the individual committing the sin. While sin should be hated and criticized, it is important to separate it from the sinner, who should be treated with love and compassion. This idea aligns with the belief in the inherent goodness of all people as children of God, even if they make immoral choices or engage in sinful behaviour.

According to St. Thomas Aquinas, goodness is related to being and is viewed as desirable. Conversely, badness or evil is considered a lack or defect of being, representing a moral choice that ignores the appropriate moral rule. Therefore, while it is acceptable to hate sin, the sinner should not be hated as a person but rather directed towards moral improvement.

This distinction between hating the sin and loving the sinner is a cornerstone of charity and mercy within the Catholic Church. It emphasizes the importance of recognizing the inherent worth of individuals while also upholding moral principles and condemning immoral actions.

The Church teaches that hatred of God is a grave sin

Hatred is a vehement aversion entertained by one person for another, or for something more or less identified with that other. The Catholic Church teaches that hatred of God is a grave sin. This is because it is a direct violation of the precept of charity, which is always sinful and may be grievously so. Personal hatred of God can take the form of disgust when a person detests God for punishing sinners. It can also manifest as the hatred of enmity, when a person wishes for evil to befall God. This type of hatred is considered diabolical and is the most grievous of all sins, as it mirrors the enmity that the devils have against God.

The Church, through the writings of St. Augustine, promotes the idea of "love the sinner, hate the sin." This concept is further supported by St. Paul, who emphasizes the importance of genuine love and hating what is evil. According to St. Thomas Aquinas, being and goodness are convertible, meaning they are identical in reference but differ in sense. Evil, therefore, is understood as the absence of being where it is otherwise expected or due. Applying this understanding, the Church teaches that it is proper to hate sin, which is a lack or defect of being, rather than the sinner.

The distinction between hating the sin and loving the sinner is a challenging concept to convey in today's society, where any criticism or disapproval of another's actions is often perceived as a personal attack. This notion is further complicated by the prevailing postmodern subjective relativism and the rejection of objective, absolute truths. However, the Bible provides clear guidance on this matter, emphasizing the importance of both loving people and hating sin.

Jesus Christ exemplifies this principle in his encounter with the woman caught in adultery (John 8:3-11). He expresses love for the woman while not condoning her sin. He points out the sinfulness of those who would have stoned her and instructs her to sin no more. Additionally, Jesus demonstrates this principle in his calling of Matthew, a tax collector, as his disciple (Matthew 9:9-13). He loves Matthew and his friends but refers to them as sinners, recognizing their need for spiritual healing.

In conclusion, the Church teaches that hatred of God is a grave sin, the most grievous of all. At the same time, the Church encourages the idea of "love the sinner, hate the sin," emphasizing the distinction between hating the sin and loving the sinner. This teaching is rooted in the understanding of sin as a lack or defect of being and is supported by both Scripture and the examples set by Jesus Christ.

The Church teaches that hatred of a human being is the opposite of the virtue of love

The Catholic Church teaches that hatred of a human being is the opposite of the virtue of love. Personal hatred of a human being is a direct contradiction of the virtue of love. Love inspires a person to wish well upon another, whereas hatred arouses the desire to cause harm or have harm befall the one hated. The severity of such sins of personal hatred depends on the seriousness of the harm intended and how deliberately malicious desires are harboured.

Hatred of a quality in someone may be either sinful or not. If the hatred is directed only toward some evil quality that a person has, but does not extend to the person, it is not sinful. It becomes sinful only if the hatred extends to the person who has some admittedly evil trait or sinful habit. Moreover, it becomes specially sinful when the hatred is directed at some virtue that a person possesses, even when the enmity does not extend to the individual personally.

The Church distinguishes between two types of hatred: odium abominationis (loathing) and odium inimicitiae (hostility). Loathing is concentrated primarily on the qualities or attributes of a person, and only secondarily on the person himself. This type of hatred is not a sin and may even represent a virtuous temper of the soul. In other words, one may hate what is contrary to the moral law.

On the other hand, hostility aims directly at the person, indulges a propensity to see what is evil and unlovable in them, and feels a fierce satisfaction at anything tending to their discredit. This type of hatred is always sinful and may be grievously so as it involves a direct and absolute violation of the precept of charity.

The Church teaches that it is okay to hate sin, but not to hate people. According to St. Thomas Aquinas, "being and goodness are convertible, which is to say identical in reference though different in sense". Evil is a due good that has gone missing, and so it is okay to hate it. Aquinas states, "Just as good is the object of love, so evil is the object of hatred". However, it is important to hate the sin and not the sinner.

The phrase "Love the sinner, hate the sin" is often attributed to St. Augustine, who wrote, "Cum dilectione hominum et odio vitiorum", which translates to "With love for mankind and hatred of sins". This phrase has been popularised by Mohandas Gandhi in his 1929 autobiography, where he wrote, "Hate the sin and not the sinner is a precept which, though easy to understand, is rarely practiced, and that is why the poison of hatred spreads in the world".

Frequently asked questions