American Democracy: Worth Our Faith?

American democracy is facing a crisis of confidence. The public's faith in the government's ability to solve problems is at a near-historic low, with only 24% of Americans expressing trust in their government. This skepticism is rooted in dissatisfaction with the state of American democracy, and the perception that it is plagued by partisanship and dysfunction. The Trump presidency, the 2021 Capitol riots, and the 2024 election have all contributed to a decline in international perceptions of American democracy, with US allies such as Japan concerned about the future of the democratic system. The challenge now is to restore faith in American democracy, both domestically and abroad.

Is the American democratic system under threat?

The American democratic system is facing a crisis of confidence, with many citizens questioning the health and sustainability of their democracy. A range of factors, including political divisions, dysfunctional government, and challenges to civic norms, have contributed to this climate of uncertainty.

Historical Context

Public trust in the US federal government has been low for decades, with a gradual erosion of confidence since the 1960s. The Vietnam War, the Watergate scandal, and economic struggles all played a part in this decline. While there have been periods of recovery, such as in the mid-1980s and late 1990s, trust has generally continued to falter. The terrorist attacks of 9/11 marked a brief exception, with public trust reaching a three-decade high, but this soon declined once more.

Current Challenges

The United States is currently grappling with a range of issues that are testing its democratic foundations. Partisan divisions have long plagued American politics, but the country now finds itself divided over fundamental principles, such as whether voting is a right or a privilege, and who ultimately decides election outcomes. This national divide has been exacerbated by the Trump presidency, which has undermined the image of the United States as a model of democratic governance.

The 2024 election results, with Donald Trump securing a second term, have further shaken confidence in American democracy. Despite warnings about the threat Trump poses to American freedom, he prevailed in a free and fair election, indicating that a significant portion of the electorate supports him and his policies.

The current political climate is characterised by deep divisions, with some questioning the legitimacy of election results and others expressing concerns about the growing extremism in the Republican Party. The assault on the US Capitol on January 6, 2021, highlighted the depth of this crisis, with half of Americans reporting decreased confidence in the stability of their democracy.

International Perspective

The perception of the United States as a shining example of democratic governance has been a significant element of its global soft power. However, this image has been tarnished in recent years, with US allies and other advanced economies expressing doubts about the effectiveness of American democracy. The struggle to reform and revitalise American democracy is likely to impact the country's international standing and influence.

The American democratic system is undoubtedly facing significant challenges and threats. While there is a clear desire among Americans for governmental action to address pressing issues, there is a disconnect between this expectation and their trust in the government's ability to deliver. The outcome of this struggle will have profound implications for the future of the United States and its role on the global stage.

What is the role of the government?

The role of the government in a democratic society is multifaceted and vital to ensuring the stability, prosperity, and well-being of its citizens. Firstly, the government serves as the representative of the people, acting on their behalf and in their best interests. This involves creating and enforcing laws that protect the rights and freedoms of all citizens, ensuring equality and justice. A key aspect of this representation is maintaining a fair and independent legal system, guaranteeing equal treatment before the law.

Secondly, the government is responsible for providing public services that benefit society as a whole. This includes ensuring access to quality education, healthcare, infrastructure, and social safety nets. By investing in these areas, governments can promote social mobility, reduce inequality, and improve the overall quality of life for their citizens. It is also responsible for fostering economic growth and stability. This involves creating policies that encourage job creation, innovation, and a robust business environment.

Additionally, the government plays a crucial role in national security and foreign affairs. It is tasked with protecting the nation's borders, safeguarding its citizens from external threats, and promoting international cooperation. This involves maintaining a strong military, engaging in diplomatic relations, and representing the country's interests on a global stage. The government also has a duty to act as a steward of the environment, ensuring that natural resources are managed sustainably for future generations.

Lastly, the government serves as a catalyst for social progress and change. It can address societal issues, promote equality, and respond to the needs of marginalized communities. By enacting policies that address systemic injustices and promoting social inclusion, the government can create a more equitable and just society. In a democratic society, the government is ultimately accountable to its citizens. It derives its power from the people and is responsible for ensuring that their voices are heard and their needs are met. Regular elections and a free press help maintain this accountability, allowing citizens to choose their representatives and hold them responsible for their actions.

Is voting a right or a privilege?

The question of whether voting is a right or a privilege is a highly contested issue in the United States, with the answer often depending on one's political affiliation. The answer has significant implications for the future of American democracy, and the country's international image.

Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents overwhelmingly say that voting is a fundamental right that should not be restricted in any way. 78% of Democrats hold this view, while fewer than a quarter (21%) say it is a privilege. This is because Democrats tend to win elections when turnout is high. On the other hand, two-thirds of Republicans and Republican leaners say that voting is a privilege that can be limited if certain requirements are not met. This is because Republicans tend to benefit when turnout is low.

The view that voting is a fundamental right is most widespread among minorities, younger people, and the highly educated—all core Democratic constituencies. Those who back voting restrictions are more likely to be white, older, and less educated—the typical Republican voter. Black Americans are more likely than those in other racial and ethnic groups to see voting as a fundamental right, with about three-quarters (77%) expressing this view. This is followed by 63% of Hispanic Americans and 66% of Asian Americans. White Americans are more divided, with 51% saying voting is a right, and 48% saying it is a privilege.

While the U.S. Constitution does not explicitly give citizens the right to vote, the Supreme Court has affirmed the notion. In the 1972 Dunn v. Blumstein decision, Justice Marshall stated, "In decision after decision, this Court has made clear that a citizen has a constitutionally protected right to participate in elections on an equal basis with other citizens in the jurisdiction." Additionally, in the 1974 Richardson v. Ramirez case, Justice Rehnquist wrote, "Because the right to vote 'is of the essence of a democratic society, and any restrictions on that right strike at the heart of representative government,'... voting is a 'fundamental' right."

However, scholars disagree on whether the U.S. Constitution gives Americans the right to vote. Some believe that the right is implicit, embedded in the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment, while others argue that the right does not exist. The Constitution has been amended several times to prohibit states from denying the right to vote based on specific criteria, such as race, color, sex, failure to pay poll tax, and age. While these amendments protect citizens from voting interference based on certain reasons, they do not explicitly assert a right to vote. As such, some argue that the right to vote is treated as a privilege that can be restricted by states for reasons other than those explicitly prohibited.

How does the media influence democracy?

The media has a significant influence on democracy, and this relationship has been the subject of extensive academic research. Media democracy is a democratic approach to media studies that aims to reform mass media to strengthen public service broadcasting and promote participation in alternative media and citizen journalism. The concept advocates for a diverse range of voices and perspectives within the news system, empowering citizens and promoting democratic ideals.

One of the key ways in which the media influences democracy is through its impact on public opinion and political attitudes. Social media platforms, in particular, offer new avenues for people to interact with the news, government, and each other. People can share information and political opinions with their online networks, and political leaders can reach the public directly, bypassing traditional media outlets. This direct access can influence democratically important outcomes like polarization and participation. Additionally, the spread of false and misleading information (fake news) on social media can impact public opinion and disrupt democratic processes.

The concentration of media ownership by large private entities is another critical aspect of the media's influence on democracy. In the United States, for example, media outlets are predominantly owned by the "Big Six" corporations, leading to a reduction in the diversity of voices and opinions communicated to the public. This consolidation of media power can result in increased commercialization of news, a decline in investigative reporting, and a focus on profitability over informative public discourse. Media democracy advocates argue for media diversification, such as promoting local news sources, to ensure a broader range of ideas and perspectives.

Furthermore, the media's role in holding political leaders accountable and providing accurate information to the public is essential for democracy. News media is a vital institution in a democratic system, and when it is influenced by commercial interests or biased reporting, it can fail to serve its purpose. Media democracy proponents emphasize the need for independent and diverse media outlets that prioritize public service over profit.

Social media has also been credited for its role in democratic uprisings, such as the Arab Spring in the Middle East and North Africa. These platforms enabled citizens to connect, exchange information, and organize protests against their governments. However, the same tools can be exploited by malicious actors, including populist leaders, who use them to manipulate public opinion and silence minority voices.

Overall, the media's influence on democracy is complex and multifaceted. While it can promote democratic values and participation, it is essential to recognize the potential negative consequences, such as the spread of misinformation and the concentration of media power. Academic research in this field continues to explore the complex relationship between media and democracy, aiming to find ways to harness the positive potential of media while mitigating its negative impacts.

What is the future of American democracy?

The future of American democracy is uncertain, with a recent history of political upheaval and a decline in public trust in the government. The 2024 election saw Donald Trump re-elected for a second term, despite his controversial first term and the strong opposition he faced from progressives. This has caused concern for the future of democracy in the United States, both domestically and internationally.

The election of Trump has been seen by some as a threat to American democracy and freedom, with his appeal to voters based on fear and hatred, rather than hope and joy, as offered by his opponent, Kamala Harris. However, it is important to note that Trump's victory was not a rejection of democracy, but rather a reflection of the will of the people. In a free and fair election, he prevailed because the voters wanted him in office, and this should not be interpreted as an endorsement of authoritarianism.

The state of American democracy is a cause for concern, with a growing divide between Democrats and Republicans, and a decline in public trust in the government. This is not a new phenomenon, as trust in the government has been eroding since the 1960s, with a brief recovery in the mid-1980s and late 1990s. The current level of trust is near historic lows, with only 22% of Americans saying they trust the government to do what is right "just about always" or "most of the time". This lack of trust is more pronounced among Republicans, with only 11% expressing trust in the government, compared to 35% of Democrats.

The partisan divide in the United States is also reflected in the differing views on the right to vote. Democrats overwhelmingly believe that voting is a fundamental right and support measures to make voting easier, such as automatic voter registration and expanding early and mail-in voting. On the other hand, Republicans view voting as a privilege that can be limited, and have enacted laws in several states to restrict voting access. This difference in ideology has led to a deepening national divide, with the promise of the right to vote depending on the state in which Americans live.

The outcome of the 2024 election has further deepened this crisis of American democracy, with two-thirds of Republican voters refusing to accept Joe Biden's victory in the previous election. This, along with the assault on the US Capitol on January 6, 2021, has shaken faith in the stability of American democracy, with half of Americans expressing less confidence in its future. The current struggle to reform American democracy is a partisan battle, with Democrats advocating for broadening voter participation and Republicans seeking to limit it, each for their own political gain.

The future of American democracy hangs in the balance, with the country facing significant challenges, including widespread concerns about the government's ability to solve problems such as the coronavirus pandemic, climate change, and economic inequality. While Americans firmly believe in democracy, there is a growing sense of dissatisfaction with the way it is currently functioning. The path forward for American democracy is uncertain, and it remains to be seen whether the country can restore its international image and rebuild public trust in the government.

Frequently asked questions