The Jewish Faith And Christmas: A Cultural Perspective

While Christmas is a major holiday for Christians, it is not a Jewish holiday and is not celebrated by Jews. However, this doesn't mean the day is devoid of significance for Jews, especially those living in countries where Christmas is widely celebrated. For some, it is an opportunity to reflect on their relationship with the wider society, and some Jews have chosen to adopt certain Christmas traditions, while others have actively rejected them.

The Jewish faith does not celebrate Christmas as a religious holiday

Historically, Christmas has been a time of increased persecution for Jews. In the past, Jews would stay at home on Christmas, playing games with their families, rather than studying the Torah in the synagogue, for fear of being attacked in the street. In Western Europe, however, the Jewish elite would adopt Christmas symbols, such as the Christmas tree, as a sign of secular inclusion in society.

In modern times, some Jews who live in parts of the world where Christmas is widely celebrated might participate in certain elements of the festivities, such as having a Christmas tree. This is especially true for Jews from countries like Russia, where pine trees are associated with the New Year. Some Jews might also attend Christmas pageants or sing Christmas songs to take part in celebrations at their school or in their community.

In addition, some Jews might attend or host Christmas celebrations if they have Christians in their immediate family, or if they grew up in a home where both Jewish and Christian traditions were observed. In these cases, the celebration of Christmas is often about being with family and sharing happy memories, rather than a religious event.

The Jewish holiday of Hanukkah sometimes overlaps with Christmas, and in countries where Christmas is part of the public atmosphere, Hanukkah has also become a more public celebration. However, Hanukkah and Christmas are not related, and they celebrate vastly different things.

Christmas is a time for Jews to reflect on their relationship with wider society

For Jews, December 25th is just another day on the calendar, with no particular religious or cultural significance. However, the festive season can serve as a reminder of past persecution and increased vigilance during Christmas-time. Historically, Jews in Central and Eastern Europe would refrain from studying the Torah on Christmas and would stay indoors, fearing attacks in the streets. In contrast, affluent Jews in Western Europe embraced holiday symbols like the Christmas tree as a sign of secular inclusion. This dichotomy illustrates how Jews' relationship with Christmas is influenced by their cultural surroundings and historical context.

In modern times, some Jews have chosen to adopt certain Christmas traditions, such as gift-giving or decorating with wreaths, especially in countries where Christmas is a widely celebrated public holiday. This blending of Christmas and Hanukkah traditions, sometimes referred to as "Chrismukkah," reflects a desire to participate in the festive atmosphere and connect with their non-Jewish neighbours. However, it has also sparked controversy, with some Jews emphatically rejecting the rituals and symbols of Christmas as a way to preserve their cultural and religious identity.

Christmas can also be a time for Jews to engage in charitable deeds, or "mitzvot," which aligns with the spirit of the season and allows them to proudly affirm their Jewish identity while celebrating the holiday in their own way. Volunteering in soup kitchens, visiting the homebound, and delivering meals are some ways Jews have embraced the Christmas spirit while upholding their religious values.

Additionally, Christmas has become an occasion for Jewish singles to socialise and connect with each other through events like the Matzo Ball, held in cities across North America. This tradition provides a space for Jewish individuals to come together during a time when they might otherwise feel lonely or left out of the festive cheer.

In summary, Christmas is a time for Jews to reflect on their relationship with wider society, shaped by historical context, cultural surroundings, and personal experiences. While some Jews embrace certain Christmas traditions or engage in charitable deeds, others firmly reject the holiday, illustrating the diverse and nuanced nature of Jewish engagement with Christmas.

Some Jews have adopted Christmas festivities, while others have rejected them

While Christmas is not a Jewish holiday, some Jews have chosen to adopt Christmas festivities, while others have rejected them. This is especially true for Jews living in parts of the world where Christmastime is a festive season. For example, some Jews might participate in certain elements of celebration associated with Christmas, such as having a Christmas tree. This is particularly true for Jews from countries like Russia, where pine trees are associated with the New Year. Some Jews might also attend Christmas pageants or sing Christmas songs to join in with their community or school celebrations.

In the United States, a widespread tradition among Jewish Americans is eating Chinese food on Christmas Day, as Chinese restaurants generally remain open. This tradition has spread across America and has been the subject of many comedic routines. Many Jewish people also go to the movies on Christmas Day, as movie theaters are often open.

Historically, Christmas has been a time of increased persecution for Jews. In Central and Eastern Europe, Jews would stay at home on Christmas, wary of being attacked in the street. However, in Western Europe, holiday symbols like the Christmas tree signified secular inclusion in society for the Jewish elite. Affluent German Jews would often pose for portraits with their families in front of elaborately decorated Christmas trees.

In the 19th and early 20th centuries, some American Jews adopted Christmas traditions, incorporating both Christmas and Hanukkah symbols. They decorated Christmas trees, exchanged gifts, and hung wreaths on their doors. However, rabbis and some Jewish people objected to the increasing importance of Hanukkah, arguing that it was not necessary to elevate the minor holiday to rival Christmas.

Christmas has historically been a time of increased persecution for Jews

Rabbis prohibited Jewish students from leaving home to study the Torah on Christmas Eve, as they feared that Jewish students would be attacked on the way to study. The study of the Torah was also prohibited because Jesus, in his youth, engaged in religious study, and the medieval rabbis prohibited the activity lest it lend merit to Jesus.

Over the centuries, Jews developed customary Christmas activities. Certain East European Jews covertly read Ma’se Talui (The Tales of the Crucifix), a secret scroll containing derogatory versions of the birth of Jesus. Such legends are part of a genre of Jewish legends called Toledot Yeshu (History of Jesus). These legends first appeared in Hebrew in the 13th century and circulated in different versions throughout the Middle Ages. Toledot Yeshu describes Jesus as the illegitimate son of Mary by the Roman soldier Panthera. According to these tales, Jesus’ powers derived from black magic, and his death was a shameful one.

Christmas was also a popular time for Jewish card playing, despite traditional rabbinic condemnation of gambling and betting. Indeed, in the Middle Ages, many measures were devised to suppress card playing, including communal restrictions (takanot) and literary satires.

In the years 500-1500, Jews, as a religious and cultural minority, were often preyed upon by the Christian majority. The papal record is inconsistent, with harsh infringements of Jewish rights censured at the same time that restrictions were imposed on their full participation in society. The vocabulary of guilt for Jesus' crucifixion and charges of stubbornness and blindness were recurring themes.

In the early 19th century, anti-Jewish sentiment in Catholic and Protestant Europe, despite being increasingly secularized, had other roots that were no less mythical. The proper term for it is anti-Semitism. Its target was Jewish ethnicity, and it was primarily politically and economically motivated. Demagogues were only too happy to put the ancient Christian rhetoric of anti-Judaism in its service.

Some Jewish people may attend Christmas celebrations if they have Christians in their family

While Christmas is not a Jewish holiday, some Jewish people may choose to attend Christmas celebrations if they have Christians in their family. This could include Jewish people who are married to Christians, or those who grew up celebrating both Jewish and Christian traditions. In these cases, Christmas is often about spending time with family and sharing happy memories, rather than a religious celebration.

Historically, Christmas has been a difficult time for Jews, as it was a time of increased persecution. In the past, Jewish people would refrain from studying the Torah on Christmas Eve, instead staying at home and playing games with their families, for fear of being attacked in the street. In some countries, such as Russia, Jewish people may participate in certain elements of Christmas celebrations, such as having a Christmas tree, as pine trees are associated with the New Year.

In the United States, it has become a tradition for Jewish Americans to eat Chinese food on Christmas Day, as Chinese restaurants tend to remain open. This tradition is thought to symbolise a rejection of historical Christmas traditions and a feeling of commonality with those excluded from the holiday. Another tradition is the Matzo Ball, an annual party held on Christmas Eve in many cities across the US and Canada for Jewish singles.

In recent years, there has been some blending of Christmas and Hanukkah traditions, resulting in new practices such as decorating Christmas trees with Jewish symbols. This combination of holidays has been referred to as "Chrismukkah". However, some Jewish people may feel uncomfortable about this mixing of traditions, and it is not widely accepted within the Jewish community.

Frequently asked questions