Unknowing Confessions: Sin And Uncertainty

Confession of sin is the admission of one's actions and agreement with God that those actions were wrong. However, a person cannot be culpable for a sin they did not know they had committed. While confession to another person is not necessary for forgiveness, it is beneficial for healing relationships. Therefore, while one may not be obligated to confess a sin they were unaware of, doing so can have positive effects on their spiritual, psychological, or emotional state.

You are not culpable for sins you don't know you've committed and are therefore not obligated to confess them

According to Catholic doctrine, a person is not culpable for a sin if they do not know or have a reasonable expectation of knowing that it is a sin. In such cases, the person is not obligated to confess the sin, although they are free to do so if they believe it will be spiritually, psychologically, or emotionally beneficial.

For a sin to be considered mortal, it must involve an action that violates the Ten Commandments and be committed with full knowledge and deliberate consent. If a person is not aware that an action is a sin, or does not have a reasonable expectation of knowing, then they are not culpable for that action and are not obligated to confess it. However, this does not apply to venial sins, which can be forgiven through other penitential acts such as prayer, fasting, or spiritual works of mercy.

It is important to note that even if a person is not culpable for a sin due to a lack of knowledge, they may still experience negative consequences from their actions. Additionally, confession is recommended for venial sins as it can help individuals form their conscience, fight against evil tendencies, and progress in their spiritual life.

While confession is not required for sins committed in ignorance, it is important to cultivate a spirit of humility, sincerity, and completeness when confessing. This involves accusing oneself of sins with sorrow for offending the Lord, being honest and truthful, and confessing all mortal sins, including the number of times they have been committed.

Confession to God and other believers can bring healing and restore relationships

Confessing our sins to God and others can be a powerful tool for healing and restoring relationships. While it may be intimidating to admit our wrongdoing, doing so can bring freedom and relief.

The Bible tells us that confession is necessary for healing and restoration. James 5:16 says, "Confess your sins to one another and pray for one another, that you may be healed." When we confess our sins, we bring them out of the darkness and into the light, allowing God to wash us clean.

Confessing to God is an important first step. All sins are ultimately against God, and He already knows our sins, so confession is an acknowledgment of our wrongdoing and a request for forgiveness.

However, confessing to other believers can also bring healing. It can be scary to admit our sins to others, but doing so allows us to be vulnerable and build trust. Confessing to a trusted friend or mentor can provide accountability and support in our struggle against sin. It can also help us avoid the shame and guilt that come from isolating ourselves.

Additionally, confession can restore our relationships with others. While it may be tempting to withhold the truth out of embarrassment or fear, confession can set us free from emotional and relational baggage. It allows for forgiveness, healing, and future growth in our relationships.

When confessing, it is important to be specific and honest. Hiding behind generalities or minimizing our sins will only hinder the healing process. Instead, we should name our sins and take responsibility for them.

Confession is a courageous act that brings us closer to God and others. It allows us to leave the past behind and move forward in faith, experiencing the freedom and grace that come from being forgiven.

Confession is not always necessary for forgiveness, but it can be beneficial

In the Bible, it is stated that "If we confess our sins, He (Christ, not a man) is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness." This suggests that confession is a crucial step in the forgiveness process. However, it is important to note that the Bible also teaches that all sins are ultimately committed against God, and God is quick to forgive.

In the Old Testament, people were required to confess their sins to priests, who served as intermediaries between God and the people. This practice is still followed in some religious traditions, such as Catholicism. However, the Bible also states that believers are all "priests," suggesting that confession can be made directly to God.

Additionally, some sins may be unknown to the person committing them, or they may not understand that their actions are sinful. In such cases, confession is not necessary for forgiveness, as the person is not culpable for their actions. Nevertheless, confessing these unknown or unintentional sins can still be spiritually, psychologically, or emotionally beneficial.

Confession can help maintain our relationship with God and restore fellowship with Him. It is an acknowledgment of our wrongdoing and a way to seek His help in overcoming our sins. While confession is not always necessary for forgiveness, it can be a valuable tool in our spiritual growth and development.

Sins can be committed in thought as well as action

In the Gospel of Matthew, Jesus says:

> "You have heard that it was said, 'You shall not commit adultery'; but I say to you that everyone who looks at a woman with lust for her has already committed adultery with her in his heart."

Here, Jesus explains that sin does not occur if one looks at someone and feels attracted, but rather when one continues to dwell on those thoughts. This is further supported by James 1:14-15, which states that sin occurs when one decides to give in to their internal feelings.

However, it is important to note that temptation itself is not a sin. It is only when one gives in to temptation and acts upon it that sin occurs. As Cain in Genesis 4:7 was told: "Sin is crouching at the door; and its desire is for you, but you must master it."

In order to be culpable for a sin, one must know, at some level, that it is a sin. Our conscience often tells us that something is wrong, even if we don't know exactly why. There are also some things that we should know are sins, even if they were never explicitly explained to us. In such cases, we are still culpable for those actions.

If someone does not understand or have a reasonable expectation of knowing that something is a sin, they are not culpable for it and are not obligated to confess it. However, confession can still be beneficial for spiritual, psychological, or emotional reasons.

A good confession is humble, sincere, and complete

A good confession is also sincere. This means being honest and truthful without exaggerating or excusing our sins. We should confess our sins as they are, trusting that God's forgiveness is greater than our sins. Confession should be serious and self-directed, recognising that our only hope is forgiveness.

Lastly, a good confession is complete. This means confessing all our mortal sins, including the number of times we have committed each one. We should not hide our sins in generalities but be specific and name them. This helps us to avoid minimising our sins and allows us to receive help in making specific changes to remove sin from our lives. While it is not necessary to repeatedly confess past sins that have been fully confessed and repented of, it is important to confess every sin, including those we are reluctant to share due to shame or fear.

Frequently asked questions