Innocent Absolution: Torah's Take On Sin And Redemption

The Torah teaches that if a person sins unintentionally, they can offer a sacrifice and be forgiven. However, a person who sins intentionally is cut off from the people. The scapegoat ritual on Yom Kippur atones for all of Israel's sins, even acts of rebellion. According to Numbers 15, a person who sins unintentionally can bring an offering and be forgiven, but a person who sins intentionally is cut off from the people. This text states that a person who acts defiantly against God will be punished with excision or cutting off. The community must root out sinful individuals to maintain its good standing with God and protect itself from misfortune.

The question of whether an innocent person can take away the sins of a sinner is complex and depends on the interpretation of various Torah passages. Some sources suggest that only God can forgive sins, while others suggest that repentance and charity are also forms of atonement. The role of human sacrifice and the concept of blood atonement are also debated, with some arguing that human sacrifice is prohibited in the Torah and that the death of Jesus cannot provide atonement.

The idea of sacrificing the sinner or punishing them to prevent further wrongdoing is also explored in Jewish texts and tradition. While some argue that leniency should be shown to prevent people from leaving the faith, others emphasize the need for punishment to deter others from committing sins. The priority is given to the well-being of the community as a whole rather than the individual sinner.

The Torah's teachings on the importance of community

The Torah, or the Five Books of Moses, is the foundation of all Jewish instruction and guidance. The Torah teaches that community, or "Kehillah", is of utmost importance. The very layout of the Tabernacle, or Mishkhan, underscores this. The Tabernacle was situated in the centre of the camp, with the Levite families in an inner layer and the twelve tribes in an outer one. This arrangement provided every Jew with access to the Tabernacle and also served as a defence mechanism.

The Torah also teaches that each person has a unique role to play in God's world and that every action has the potential to improve or deteriorate the world. This is why it is necessary to elevate every member of the community, make them feel valued, and bring them closer to God, Torah, and one another.

The importance of community is further underscored by the fact that the Jewish people were instructed to influence other peoples to keep the basic tenets of human decency. The Talmud states that any human being who lives by these laws is considered righteous and has a share in the world to come.

Community service and volunteering are also integral parts of Jewish life. Acts of kindness and generosity are deeply ingrained in Jewish culture, with the belief that helping others is essential to leading a meaningful and fulfilling life. This is reflected in the concept of "Tikkun Olam", which means repairing the world through acts of charity and social justice, as well as taking care of the environment and promoting peace.

The role of repentance in the Torah

Repentance, or teshuvah in Hebrew, is a key element of atoning for sin in Judaism. The primary purpose of repentance in Judaism is ethical self-transformation.

The Hebrew word for sin, chet, means "to go astray". Thus, the idea of repentance in Jewish thought is a return to the path of righteousness. In the Torah, repentance is focused on two levels: the immediate social-religious context of the individual, and the destiny of the entire community.

According to the Torah, remorse or confession is not acceptable once a perpetrator has already been apprehended, as it is assumed that such an expression of regret would be insincere. However, if the perpetrator feels guilty before they are caught, the Torah makes allowance for individual remorse. In Leviticus, for example, a person who has stolen from or defrauded another and feels guilty before being caught must confess their crime and make restitution to the victim.

The process of repentance, as laid out by Maimonides, includes three stages: confession, regret, and a vow not to repeat the misdeed. True repentance, according to Maimonides, is when an individual declines to commit the same sin again, even when presented with the opportunity. Prayer, charity, and fasting are also said to help one win forgiveness.

There are two categories of sin in Jewish thought: sins against God and sins against other people. According to Jewish tradition, only sins against God can be atoned for through confession, regret, and promising not to repeat the action. Sins against other people can only be atoned for once the wrong has been made right—for example, through restitution for a financial crime or forgiveness from the victim.

The Talmud makes two statements about the power of repentance to transform one's past sins. If one repents out of fear, intentional sins are turned into unintentional sins. However, if one repents out of love, intentional sins become merits.

The different types of sin

Judaism recognises three types of sin:

Ḥeṭ (חַטָּאת*): This is the lightest type of sin, committed in ignorance of the existence or meaning of a commandment. The word is derived from the root "ḥaṭā," meaning "to miss the mark" or "to miss the path." It is used in the story of Joseph, where Pharaoh's cupbearer says, "Today I am reminded of my mistakes."

Avon (עָו‍ֹן*): This is a breach of a minor commandment committed with full knowledge of its existence and nature. It is often translated as "iniquity" or "evil" and carries the idea of taking advantage of someone else. It is derived from the root "ʿ-w-n," meaning "to bend, make crooked, pervert."

Pesha (פֶּשַׁע*): This is the most severe type of sin, a rebellious act against God or a wicked intention. It is a willful act of disobedience against a direct command from God. The word is derived from the root "p-sh-ʿ," meaning "to rebel."

These three types of sin are mentioned in the Book of Psalms: "We have sinned, we have committed iniquity, we have done wickedly" (Psalm cvi. 6). The confession of sin by the high priest on Yom Kippur followed this order: "ḥeṭ, 'awon, pesha" (Yoma 36b).

In addition to these three main types, there are other terms used in the Hebrew Bible and rabbinic literature to describe different aspects of sin:

• Ma'al (מַעַל): A sin that is later repented.
• Tiflah (תִּפְלָה): Vice or depravity.
• Amal (עַמַל): Enormity or corruption.
• Resha (רֶשַׁע): Ill conduct, viciousness, or criminality.
• Avera (עֲבֵרָה): Transgression or trespass, including both sin and crime.
• Abera (עֲבֵרָה): Transgression, trespass, or violation of a covenant.

According to the rabbis, these terms refer to sins of different severities: ḥeṭ is an unintentional sin, avon is an intentional sin, and pesha is an act of rebellion.

The role of the priest

The Torah also distinguishes between unintentional and intentional sins when it comes to atonement. Numbers 15 states that a person who sins unintentionally can bring an offering and be forgiven, while someone who sins intentionally is cut off from the people and cannot be forgiven through sacrifice. In this case, the priest's role is to make expiation for the unintentional sinner, but they have no role in the atonement of intentional sins.

The priest also plays a role in the sin sacrifice, or korban chatat, which is described as only atoning for unintentional sins. The priest would offer a sin offering on behalf of the sinner, and through this ritual, the sinner would be forgiven.

Additionally, the Torah highlights the importance of repentance and charity as methods of atonement alongside sacrifices. While the priest may guide and facilitate these processes, the onus is on the individual to repent and make amends for their intentional sins.

Overall, the role of the priest in the Torah is primarily focused on performing rituals and sacrifices to atone for the sins of the people. They are responsible for facilitating atonement and guiding the community towards spiritual purity and a stronger connection with God.

The concept of atonement

The Torah also prescribes specific rituals and sacrifices for atonement. For unintentional sins, individuals were required to offer a one-year-old female goat as a sin offering, with the priest making atonement before God. On the other hand, intentional sins were considered more severe and were often associated with punishment such as banishment or death. The Torah emphasizes the importance of repentance and restitution as part of the atonement process.

Additionally, the Torah highlights the role of the priest in achieving atonement. During the scapegoat ritual, the priest confesses the sins of the people and places their hands on the head of the scapegoat, symbolically transferring the sins onto the animal. This ritual is meant to cleanse and purify the sanctuary and the people from their sins.

The Torah also mentions the concept of "teshuvah," which refers to repentance and the decision to refrain from committing the same sin again. While some interpret this as a prerequisite for atonement, others view it as a separate mitzvah or commandment. The Torah also acknowledges that not all sins can be atoned for, and that intentional sins, particularly those committed defiantly against God, may result in severe consequences.

In summary, the concept of atonement in the Torah involves rituals, sacrifices, and repentance, with a focus on distinguishing between intentional and unintentional sins. The Torah emphasizes the role of the priest in achieving atonement and highlights the importance of removing sin from the community to maintain its purity and well-being.

Frequently asked questions