The Power Of Absolution: Lutheran Pastors And Forgiveness

The question of whether Lutheran pastors can forgive sins is a contentious one. Some argue that only God can forgive sins, and that placing trust in a priest or minister to do so is ludicrous, apostate, and diametrically opposed to the Word of God. However, others interpret the Bible as saying that Jesus grants certain people the authority to forgive sins on his behalf. This interpretation is supported by the fact that Jesus promises this authority to Peter in the Bible, saying, I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.

The authority of pastors to forgive sins

Biblical Basis for Pastoral Authority

Lutheran theology asserts that pastors have the authority to forgive sins based on specific Bible passages. One key passage is Matthew 16, where Jesus promises to give Peter "the keys of the kingdom of heaven," stating that "whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven" (Matthew 16:19). This authority is not limited to Peter but is extended to all his disciples, including the pastors who follow them, as recorded in John 20. In this passage, Jesus says, "As the Father has sent me, even so I am sending you... Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you withhold forgiveness from any, it is withheld" (John 20:21-23).

The Role of Pastors in Forgiveness

Lutheran pastors are seen as acting on behalf of Jesus Christ and His Church when they forgive sins. They do not have the power to grant or withhold forgiveness according to their own whims or standards but are called to reflect God's determination of forgiveness. This means that pastors forgive those who acknowledge and repent of their sins and withhold forgiveness from those who refuse to do so. The act of forgiving sins is not done independently by pastors but is exercised within the congregation "in the stead and by the command" of Jesus. In other words, it is Jesus forgiving sins through the pastor.

Pastoral Authority and Individual Faith

It is important to note that the authority of pastors to forgive sins does not diminish the role of individual faith in receiving forgiveness. Faith is essential for receiving forgiveness, and pastors are called to preach and proclaim the Word of God so that people can hear and believe. However, the act of confessing sins to a pastor and receiving absolution is seen as a means of receiving God's forgiveness tangibly and personally.

Pastoral Authority and Other Christians

While all Christians are expected to comfort and encourage one another with the Gospel message of forgiveness, not all Christians have been given the specific authority to forgive and retain sins. This authority is bestowed upon pastors, who are called and ordained for this purpose.

In conclusion, Lutheran theology affirms the authority of pastors to forgive sins based on Biblical passages and the understanding that pastors act as representatives of Jesus Christ and His Church. This authority is exercised within the congregation and is dependent on the individual's confession and repentance. However, it is essential to recognize that faith in Christ remains the foundation of forgiveness, and the role of pastors is to facilitate this process through preaching, absolving, baptizing, and communing.

The necessity of faith for forgiveness

Faith is the cornerstone of Christianity, and it is no different when it comes to the forgiveness of sins. The Lutheran tradition, rooted in the teachings of Martin Luther, emphasizes the critical role of faith in obtaining God's forgiveness. While pastors and priests play a part in this process, it is ultimately faith in Jesus Christ that brings about true forgiveness.

In Lutheranism, the role of the pastor is significant but distinct from that of a mediator between God and humans. Pastors are called to proclaim the Word of God, preach the gospel, and administer the sacraments. They are not seen as intermediaries possessing the power to grant or withhold forgiveness independently. Instead, they act as representatives of Jesus Christ and His Church.

The authority that Lutheran pastors hold regarding the forgiveness of sins stems from Jesus' words in Scripture. In John 20:21-23, Jesus says to His disciples, "Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive anyone's sins, they are forgiven; if you do not forgive them, they are not forgiven." This authority is not limited to a select few but is extended to all of Jesus' followers, including pastors.

However, it is essential to understand that pastors do not possess the ability to forgive sins on their own accord. Their role is to proclaim God's forgiveness and facilitate the means by which individuals receive that forgiveness through faith in Christ. As stated in Romans 10, faith comes by hearing the Word of Christ, and pastors are called to preach and proclaim that Word.

The act of confession, whether private or public, is an important aspect of the Lutheran tradition. During confession, individuals acknowledge and repent of their sins. The pastor, as a representative of Christ, then declares God's forgiveness. This declaration is not based on the pastor's personal authority but on the authority of Jesus Christ Himself.

It is also worth noting that, while confession is encouraged, it is not a requirement for obtaining God's forgiveness. Faith in Jesus Christ as Saviour is the fundamental requirement for forgiveness. As stated in Ephesians 1:7, "In Him we have redemption through His blood, the forgiveness of sins, according to the riches of His grace."

In conclusion, while Lutheran pastors play a role in facilitating the forgiveness of sins, it is faith in Jesus Christ that is truly necessary for forgiveness. Pastors are called to preach the gospel, administer the sacraments, and proclaim God's forgiveness to those who repent and believe. Ultimately, it is an individual's faith that brings them into a right relationship with God and results in the forgiveness of their sins.

The role of the pastoral office

The pastoral office is a divine institution, instituted by Christ, to do the work of preaching, absoling, baptizing, and communing. Pastors are given the authority to forgive sins and retain sins, to feed Christ's sheep with His Body and Blood, and to baptize in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

The pastoral office exists so that Christ's Word of reconciliation and salvation might be proclaimed. Pastors are given for this reason: so that there may be a preacher, in order that the congregation might hear, and so that they might be able to believe in the Word of salvation.

The authority to forgive sins is exercised in the congregation "in the stead and by the command" of Jesus, as is stated in the absolution itself. Another way to say it is that when the pastor is forgiving sins, Jesus is forgiving sins; or that Jesus forgives sins through the pastor.

Pastors do not forgive sins as independent agents, nor do they have the power within themselves to forgive or withhold sins. Instead, they have been called to a particular office to act on behalf of Jesus and His Church. They are called to grant and to withhold forgiveness solely as a reflection of what God has already determined in heaven.

In private confession, this means that pastors forgive those who acknowledge and repent of their sins, but withhold from those who refuse to acknowledge their sins or repent of them. Since pastors are not capable of judging anyone's heart, they must base their actions on what is declared or confessed by the person seeking forgiveness. Likewise, in public confession, absolution is given under the assumption that those confessing are confessing sincerely.

The comparison of Lutheran and Catholic beliefs

Lutheranism and Catholicism are two distinct Christian denominations with differing beliefs and practices. While both denominations share certain similarities, such as the recognition of Martin Luther as a key figure, there are also significant differences in their interpretations of biblical teachings. Here is a detailed comparison of Lutheran and Catholic beliefs:

Beliefs about Sin and Forgiveness:

Lutheran Belief: Lutherans believe that sins are forgiven solely through faith in Jesus Christ. They emphasize the importance of personal faith and the role of the Holy Spirit in bringing about forgiveness. Lutherans hold that pastors are called by God to proclaim the Gospel and administer the sacraments, including baptism and communion. While pastors can declare God's forgiveness, it is God who ultimately forgives sins.

Catholic Belief: Catholics believe in the Sacrament of Penance, also known as Confession, where sins are confessed to a priest who acts as Christ's representative. Through this sacrament, Catholics believe that God's grace and forgiveness are obtained. Catholics view the priest as having the authority to forgive sins based on Jesus' words to his apostles in John 20:23, "Whose sins you forgive are forgiven them, and whose sins you retain are retained."

Views on Mary, the Mother of Jesus:

Lutheran Belief: Lutherans hold Mary in high regard but stop short of veneration. They recognize her unique role as the mother of Jesus but deny her any divine status. Lutherans do not pray to Mary or seek her intercession, believing that Christ is the only mediator between God and humanity.

Catholic Belief: Catholics have a deep devotion to Mary and honor her as the Mother of God. They believe that Mary can intercede for them and that asking for her prayers is not worship but a recognition of her special role. Catholics may pray to Mary and seek her intercession, but they do not worship her as a goddess.

Baptism and its Significance:

Lutheran Belief: Lutherans practice infant baptism, believing that it is a means of grace and a sign of God's promise to include children in the covenant of grace. They see baptism as a public declaration of faith and a symbol of spiritual regeneration rather than a requirement for salvation.

Catholic Belief: Catholics also practice infant baptism, considering it a sacrament that washes away original sin and incorporates the individual into the Church. They believe that baptism is necessary for salvation and that it imparts sanctifying grace.

The Lord's Supper or Holy Communion:

Lutheran Belief: Lutherans believe that the bread and wine in the Lord's Supper are the true body and blood of Christ, but they do not believe in transubstantiation. They hold that Christ is truly present "in, with, and under" the elements, but the elements themselves do not change.

Catholic Belief: Catholics believe in transubstantiation, which means they hold that the bread and wine used in the Eucharist are transformed into the body and blood of Christ. They believe that the consecrated bread and wine are not merely symbols but become the real presence of Christ.

The Role of the Clergy:

Lutheran Belief: Lutherans recognize the importance of the pastoral office and the authority given to pastors by God. They believe that pastors are called to preach, absolve, baptize, and administer the sacraments. However, they do not view pastors as mediators between God and humanity.

Catholic Belief: Catholics hold that priests are necessary for the forgiveness of sins and the administration of the sacraments. They believe that priests derive their authority from the apostles, who were given the power to forgive sins by Jesus himself.

The validity of public absolution

In the Lutheran Church, absolution is considered a sacrament and is often practised in two forms. The first form of confession and absolution is done at the Divine Service with the assembled congregation. Here, the entire congregation pauses for a moment of silent confession, recites the Confiteor, and receives God's forgiveness through the pastor as he says the following (or similar): "Upon this your confession and in the stead and by the command of my Lord Jesus Christ, I forgive you all your sins in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit."

The second form of confession and absolution is known as "Holy Absolution", which is done privately to the pastor (commonly only upon request). Here the person confessing (known as the "penitent") confesses his individual sins and makes an act of contrition as the pastor, acting in persona Christi, announces this following formula of absolution (or similar): "In the stead and by the command of my Lord Jesus Christ I forgive you all your sins in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit."

However, it is important to note that pastors may not grant or withhold forgiveness according to their own whims or standards. Instead, they are called to grant and withhold forgiveness solely as a reflection of what God has already determined. Pastors do not forgive sins as independent agents but have been called to a particular office to act on behalf of Jesus and His Church. Their authority to forgive sins is exercised in the congregation "in the stead and by the command" of Jesus.

Some may argue that only God can forgive sins and that it is ludicrous for any minister or priest to declare that one must go through them to obtain forgiveness. However, it is important to understand the role of the pastor in the Lutheran Church. The pastor is not a mediator between the individual and God but is instead given the authority to proclaim God's forgiveness. This is further supported by Paul's words in Romans 10, "Faith comes by hearing, and hearing by the word of Christ." Pastors are given so that there may be a preacher and that people might hear and believe in the Word of salvation.

In conclusion, the validity of public absolution in the Lutheran Church is based on the belief that pastors have been given the authority to proclaim God's forgiveness and to act on behalf of Jesus and His Church. While some may argue that this is heresy, the Lutheran Church maintains that the pastor's declaration of forgiveness is just as valid as if Christ Himself had dealt with us.

Frequently asked questions