Trading Stocks: A Personal, Moral Choice?

Trading on the stock market is a divisive topic among Christians, with some arguing that it is immoral or a form of gambling, while others view it as a legitimate way to grow their finances and provide for their future. The Bible offers guidance on how to manage wealth and warns against the get-rich-quick mentality, encouraging long-term planning and generosity. Trading involves risk and can be complex, requiring knowledge, preparation, and emotional discipline. It is important for Christians to carefully consider their motivations, values, and personal convictions when deciding whether to engage in stock market trading.

Trading is a business, not a sin

Trading is a business, and like any other business, it comes with risks. Trading is not a sin, even when done in ignorance, which is how over 90% of traders approach it. Trading is only wrong when the person doing it is behaving foolishly instead of wisely. Foolishness is not immorality, nor is it a sin.

Trading is about creating value. Many people erroneously believe that trading, along with every other business on Earth, has the primary purpose of making a profit, but that is not true. If a business cannot create value, it will ultimately fail or be replaced by a business that does create value.

Trading is investing time, effort, energy, money, and skill in exchange for a fair return. To become a successful trader, a person spends time, money, and energy to learn the skill of trading. An aspiring trader has to also learn how to run a successful business and all that is entailed in doing so. Trading involves the right application of knowledge (wisdom) to market situations, as well as self-discipline and self-control. It takes a lot of self-discipline and self-control to become a successful trader, and there are few who achieve that success.

Trading is not about providing a service. It is not necessary to provide a service or create a product to have a successful business. A business can exist solely to provide money for other things.

If you don't believe that trading is the right thing to do, then you definitely should not do it. However, if you can see trading as a legitimate business, then it is not a sin.

Investing is not the same as gambling

Investing and gambling are often compared, as they both involve risking capital with the hopes of future profit. However, there are several key differences between the two activities.

Firstly, gambling is typically a short-lived activity, whereas investing in the stock market can last a lifetime. Investing in the stock market usually carries a positive expected return over the long run, while gamblers face negative expected returns.

Secondly, investors have more sources of relevant information than gamblers. They can research and study company earnings, financial ratios, and management teams, as well as use stock charts and historical data to inform their decisions. Gamblers, on the other hand, often have limited information to work with, and their decisions are more heavily influenced by chance.

Thirdly, investors have more ways to mitigate losses than gamblers. For example, setting stop losses on stock investments can help investors avoid undue risk and retain some of their capital even if the stock price drops. In contrast, gamblers who bet on sports or horse racing typically cannot get any of their money back if their bet loses, even if their team or horse comes close to winning.

Another important distinction between investing and gambling is the expected return. Gambling always has a negative expected return over time due to the built-in "house edge" that favours casinos. In contrast, investments in stocks and bonds have reliably yielded positive returns over the past century, and it is possible for both investors and the issuers of securities to win.

Finally, the motivation and time frame behind investing and gambling are often different. Investing is typically done with a long-term view, whereas gambling is usually a short-term activity driven by the excitement of potential quick gains.

In conclusion, while investing and gambling both involve risk and the potential for loss, investing is a more rational and systematic activity that relies on informed decision-making, diversification, and long-term planning.

The Bible encourages wise investing

The Bible does not explicitly mention investing, but it does offer guidance on how to manage our wealth.

The Bible also encourages diversification of investments. Ecclesiastes 11:2 says, "Invest in seven ventures, yes, in eight; you do not know what disaster may come upon the land." This verse is a reminder to spread your investments across different financial instruments, industries, asset classes, or geographical regions to mitigate risks.

Additionally, the Bible emphasizes the importance of diligent planning and hard work. Proverbs 21:5 says, "The plans of the diligent lead to profit as surely as haste leads to poverty." This verse reminds us that careful and intentional investment decisions can lead to financial gain, while impulsive decisions can lead to poverty.

The Bible also teaches about the importance of stewardship and investing wisely with the resources God has given us. In the Parable of the Talents (Matthew 25:14-30), Jesus teaches that those who are faithful and diligent with what they have will be entrusted with more, while those who are careless and do not use their resources for growth will face consequences.

Furthermore, the Bible warns against the love of money and the dangers of greed. 1 Timothy 6:10 cautions, "For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil. Some people, eager for money, have wandered from the faith and pierced themselves with many griefs." This reminds us to approach investments with a humble and content heart, trusting in God rather than wealth.

While the Bible encourages wise investing, it is important to remember that our ultimate investment should be in eternal values, such as sharing the Gospel and serving others. Our primary focus should be on investing our time, talents, and resources in ways that honor God and further His kingdom.

Sin stocks are publicly traded companies involved in immoral activities

Sin stocks are publicly traded companies that operate in sectors considered unethical or immoral. These sectors include alcohol, tobacco, gambling, sex-related industries, and weapons manufacturing. However, the definition of a sin stock is not entirely clear-cut and can vary based on regional and societal expectations. For example, while alcohol stocks are typically considered sin stocks, brewing may not be seen as a sin in certain parts of the world. Similarly, military contractors and weapons manufacturers may be viewed as sinful by some, while others may see them as patriotic.

Sin stocks often have consistent consumer demand and are more recession-proof than other companies. This is because they deal in products with relatively inelastic demand, meaning that consumers do not significantly reduce their consumption in response to price increases. For instance, a 20% increase in the price of cigarettes or beer is unlikely to lead to a corresponding 20% decrease in consumption. As a result, sin stocks are often seen as stable investments that can provide market-beating returns.

However, sin stocks also face greater political and regulatory risks than most other stocks. They are more vulnerable to shifts in national and political opinion and may be subject to sin taxes, which are supported by both conservative and economic arguments. Additionally, the public perception of an industry as immoral can be the first step towards it being outlawed, as was the case with drugs and alcohol in the US during parts of the 20th century.

Sin stocks are recession-proof

Whether or not trading stocks is a sin is a question that traders, especially those who identify as Christians, often grapple with. While some people oppose stock market investment, arguing that it is akin to gambling, others disagree, distinguishing between the intent of gambling and investing.

The Bible offers examples of growing wealth through legitimate means, and God’s intentions for how wealth should be managed can be found in many Scriptures. For instance, Proverbs 28:20 says, "A faithful man will be richly blessed, but one eager to get rich will not go unpunished." This discourages the "get-rich-quick" mentality, which is also echoed in Second Corinthians 9:6, "Remember this: whoever sows sparingly will reap sparingly, and whoever sows generously will reap generously."

The parable of the talents in the Book of Matthew, Chapter 25, verses 14-30, and a similar parable in the Book of Luke, Chapter 19, verses 12-28, show that Jesus encouraged his disciples to grow their wealth. In these parables, servants are entrusted with funds in the form of talents to take care of while their master is away. The servant who traded and gained the most for his master was rewarded, while the servant who did nothing was punished.

Thus, investing is an option that Christians can consider, as long as it is approached with the right intent and attitude.

Sin stocks refer to shares of companies or industries that are considered resilient to the adverse effects of an economic downturn. While no investment is entirely immune to market fluctuations, sin stocks tend to outperform the broader market during challenging economic times.

A research paper titled "Wise Investing: Analysis of the Recession-Proof Sin Stocks" by Fatih Cenk Ozkan and Yan (Yelena) Xiong found that a portfolio of sin stocks provided recession-proof returns to investors. The majority of the time, industry sub-portfolios under sin stocks also provided superior results than the market. The paper presents evidence that the risk-return characteristics of sin stocks are superior compared to the market as well as socially responsible stocks.

During the 2008 financial crisis and the 2020 COVID-19 pandemic-induced recession, the following stocks demonstrated resilience, making them attractive options for investors seeking recession-resistant stocks:

• Walmart Inc. (WMT)
• Abbott Laboratories (ABT)
• Synopsys Inc. (SNPS)
• Accenture PLC (ACN)
• T-Mobile US Inc. (TMUS)
• Netflix Inc. (NFLX)
• NextEra Energy Inc. (NEE)

Additionally, certain stock market sectors have historically shown resilience to economic fluctuations, offering relatively recession-proof stocks. These include:

• Healthcare: Johnson & Johnson (JNJ), UnitedHealth Group (UNH), and Walgreens Boots Alliance (WBA)
• Consumer staples: Procter & Gamble (PG)
• Retail: Dollar stores, home improvement centers, discount retailers, and auto parts stores
• Utilities: American Water Works (AWK), Brookfield Infrastructure (BIPC), NextEra Energy (NEE), and Waste Management (WM)

When evaluating potential recession-proof stocks, investors should consider characteristics such as low volatility, steady profits, past and future growth, strong balance sheets, consistent dividends, essential products or services, competitive advantage, geographic diversification, and management quality.

While no strategy guarantees full protection, a well-constructed portfolio of recession-resistant stocks and diversified assets can help navigate market volatility.

Frequently asked questions