Sin And Virtue: A Complex Moral Grounding

The seven deadly sins are a set of vices in Christian tradition. They are pride, envy, avarice, wrath, sloth, lust, and gluttony. Each of these has a corresponding virtue that crushes it: humility, charity, generosity, meekness, diligence, chastity, and temperance.

The seven deadly sins are not the seven worst sins per se, but rather the seven human vices from which all individual sins spring. The seven heavenly virtues are similar but distinct from the seven virtues that are considered fundamental to Christian ethics.

In his sonnet #142, Shakespeare writes:

> Love is my sin and thy dear virtue hate,

> Hate of my sin, grounded on sinful loving

Here, the poet is addressing his mistress, who hates him for his sinful love. He asks her to replace the hatred she shows towards him with pity, and to recognise that she is just as guilty of frequent adulteries.

Humility vs. Pride

Pride and humility are two opposing forces that can shape one's behaviour and outlook. While pride is often associated with a sense of self-worth and confidence, it can also lead to arrogance, self-centredness, and a refusal to admit one's mistakes. On the other hand, humility is characterised by a lack of pride and the recognition of one's flaws, which can lead to greater wisdom and honour.

Pride, when taken too far, can lead to a person's downfall, as seen in the biblical story of King Herod. Herod's pride and refusal to admit his mistake led to the gruesome martyrdom of John the Baptist. This story illustrates the "power of pride" and how it can lead to destructive decisions.

In contrast, humility is often associated with wisdom and honour. The Bible states that "pride leads to disgrace and humility leads to wisdom" (Proverbs 11:2). Humility involves accepting God's purposes and stopping trying to design one's own life, which can include making demands of God. By humbling oneself, one becomes more receptive to God's grace and guidance.

However, it is important to note that both pride and humility can exist in balance. Positive pride, or self-worth, can boost self-confidence and help one confront their fears. Similarly, humility can be seen as a form of grounded confidence, where one accurately views their talents and flaws.

The key difference lies in the recognition of one's place in the broader scheme of things. Pride can lead to a person believing they are above others or that they know better than God, while humility involves acknowledging one's dependence and submitting to God's purposes.

Ultimately, the Bible presents Jesus Christ as the greatest example of humility, and Satan as the embodiment of pride. To defeat Satan, one must imitate Christ's humility and put on the "whole armour of God" (Philippians 2:3-5).

Chastity vs. Lust

Chastity and lust are concepts that are often positioned as opposites, with one representing sexual purity and self-control, while the other signifies desire and passion. In this exploration, we will delve into the nuances of these ideas, examining their definitions, historical context, and the complexities that arise when considering their interplay.

Defining Chastity and Lust

Chastity can be defined as the practice of abstaining from sexual intercourse, particularly outside of marriage. It entails maintaining sexual purity and avoiding what is deemed as "sexual sins." This concept has been deeply rooted in various religious traditions, often tied to ideas of virtue and morality.

On the other hand, lust is characterised by strong sexual desire. It represents a longing or craving that can lead to passionate pursuits. While lust often carries negative connotations, it is worth noting that it can also signify a general sense of desire or eagerness, not necessarily confined to the sexual realm.

Historical and Cultural Context

The notions of chastity and lust have been shaped by historical and cultural forces. In the Western tradition, particularly within Christianity, chastity has been upheld as a virtue, with religious figures like Jesus serving as an embodiment of celibacy and purity. Members of certain religious orders take vows of chastity, poverty, and obedience, reflecting a dedication to a life of self-denial and spiritual devotion.

In contrast, lust has often been viewed with suspicion, sometimes associated with sinfulness or immorality. In the medieval era, lust was identified as one of the seven deadly sins, alongside pride, envy, gluttony, greed, wrath, and sloth. This classification underscores the negative perception of lust within a religious framework.

However, it is important to acknowledge that perspectives on chastity and lust vary across different cultures and belief systems. For example, in certain societies, the practice of child marriage is rooted in the desire to preserve a girl's chastity and reinforce familial ties. Additionally, historical figures like Iggy Pop challenged societal norms with their album "Lust for Life," reflecting a shift in attitudes towards lust and sexuality.

Complexities and Interplay

While chastity and lust might seem like polar opposites, their relationship is more nuanced than a simple dichotomy. Both concepts exist on a spectrum, and individuals may find themselves navigating the tensions between these forces.

For some, chastity may represent a choice to prioritise spiritual growth, self-discipline, or personal values over physical desires. It can be a source of empowerment, allowing individuals to assert control over their bodies and make decisions aligned with their beliefs.

However, the expectation of chastity can also lead to repression and the stigmatisation of sexual expression. In certain contexts, particularly within patriarchal systems, the burden of maintaining chastity falls disproportionately on women, reflecting and reinforcing gender inequalities.

Lust, when channelled healthily, can be a powerful force that fuels creativity, passion, and intimate connections. It can drive artistic endeavours, romantic pursuits, and even economic endeavours, as seen in the case of investors lusting for gold due to global uncertainties.

Yet, when unrestrained, lust can lead to harmful behaviours, such as infidelity or objectification. The onus of controlling lust should not be placed solely on one gender, as it is a shared responsibility to navigate desires in a respectful and consensual manner.

Chastity and lust represent contrasting approaches to sexuality and desire. While chastity emphasises self-control and abstinence, lust embodies passion and desire. However, their interplay is complex, and individuals may find themselves navigating the spectrum between these extremes. Ultimately, the relationship between chastity and lust is shaped by cultural, religious, and personal factors, influencing how society perceives and responds to these concepts.

Temperance vs. Gluttony

The concepts of temperance and gluttony are often understood as opposing forces. Temperance is a virtue that represents self-control and moderation, while gluttony is a vice that embodies overindulgence and a lack of restraint. This comparison is particularly prevalent in Christian theology, where the seven heavenly virtues of prudence, justice, temperance, fortitude, faith, hope, and charity are contrasted with the seven deadly sins.

Gluttony is often associated with the excessive consumption of food and drink, but it can also extend to other areas of life, such as sports, social media, money, travel, and fashion. Gluttonous individuals are characterised by their lack of self-control and their pursuit of immediate gratification, often at the expense of their health and well-being. On the other hand, temperance is about appreciating life's pleasures in moderation and respecting the needs of others.

The key difference between temperance and gluttony lies in the ability to make conscious choices and maintain a balanced approach to life's sensual pleasures. While gluttony leads to unhealthy obsessions and a disregard for consequences, temperance fosters self-control, gratitude, and a deeper appreciation for life's greatest pleasures.

To summarise, temperance is a virtue that enables individuals to exercise self-control and make choices that protect the good. It involves recognising when enough is enough and prioritising long-term well-being over immediate gratification. In contrast, gluttony is a vice that stems from a lack of self-control and wisdom, leading to overindulgence and a disregard for moderation.

Charity vs. Greed

The seven heavenly virtues in Christian tradition include charity, which is defined as Christian love, representing God's love of man, man's love of God, or man's love of his fellow men. Charity is considered a virtue as it involves giving freely of oneself and doing so without expecting anything in return.

Charity is often juxtaposed with greed, which is considered one of the seven deadly sins. Greed is defined as a selfish or excessive desire for more than is needed or deserved, especially with respect to material wealth. However, greed is not limited to material wealth and can also apply to other areas such as power or food.

The line between greed and charity can be thin. For example, if one gives only to gain more, then greed takes over, and a good act can turn into a sin. On the other hand, charitable acts can help keep greed at bay. The key difference lies in the intention behind the act. Greed involves doing anything to gain wealth, while charity involves giving freely without expecting anything in return.

Charity is often associated with giving money or goods to those in need, but it can also involve giving one's time, talents, or gifts. It is important that the act of charity is pure in nature and not done to show off or seek attention.

In summary, charity is a virtue that involves giving freely and unselfishly, while greed is a sin that involves an excessive and selfish desire for more than what one needs or deserves.

Diligence vs. Sloth

Sloth and diligence are opposing concepts. Sloth is one of the seven deadly sins and is often misunderstood as being synonymous with laziness. However, sloth is more accurately described as laziness with what matters most. It is a misordering of our endless activities, which leads to death. In other words, sloth is when we choose to do the lesser things and hide our laziness behind a flurry of activity.

On the other hand, diligence is a virtue and is defined as conscientiousness, determination, or perseverance when doing something. It is the antidote to sloth. To be diligent means to slow down, reorder our activities, and give ourselves over to the right things. It requires us to be mindful of our relationship with God and others, and to not be too lazy to love.

The Bible provides examples of the battle between sloth and diligence. In Luke 10, Martha is caught up in her busyness serving Jesus, while her sister Mary sits at Jesus' feet and listens to his teachings. Jesus rebukes Martha, saying, "you are anxious and troubled about many things." This highlights that being diligent means doing what is necessary and best, rather than what is easy.

Practicing diligence involves slowing down, listening to God, and loving our neighbors. It is about prioritizing what truly matters and not giving in to sloth, even when it feels hard.

Frequently asked questions