Minister's Power: Can They Forgive Sins?

Whether or not a minister can forgive sins is a topic of debate between Catholics and Protestants. According to the Bible, Jesus gave his followers the authority to forgive sins: If you forgive anyone's sins, their sins are forgiven; if you do not forgive them, they are not forgiven (John 20:23). However, some argue that this authority is limited to God and that only he can forgive sins. Catholics believe that Jesus' priesthood was given to men so they could continue his work of forgiving sins, while Protestants argue that this authority has been given to all believers, not just an elite priesthood. Ultimately, the question of whether a minister can forgive sins depends on one's interpretation of the Bible and religious denomination.

Jesus gave the authority to forgive sins to his followers in John 20:23

In John 20:23, Jesus gives his followers the authority to forgive sins. This passage is interpreted in different ways, with some arguing that Jesus is giving his followers the power to forgive sins, while others claim that he is simply instructing them to proclaim the gospel, which includes the message of forgiveness.

The Catholic Church, Lutheran Churches, Anglican Communion, Eastern Orthodox Churches, and other Christian denominations interpret this passage as evidence that Jesus gave his followers, or apostles, the authority to forgive sins. This power is linked to the gift of the Holy Spirit mentioned in the previous verse, John 20:22, and is not seen as a human power. The Catholic Church, for example, teaches that Jesus gave his priesthood, and with it, the power to forgive sins, to his male followers. This is based on the belief that Jesus, as both God and man, had the power to forgive sins, and that he passed this power on to his apostles, who could then act in his place.

However, others argue that Jesus did not give his followers the power to forgive sins. Instead, they believe that only God can forgive sins, and that Jesus, as God, had this power, but did not pass it on to his disciples. They interpret John 20:23 as Jesus giving his followers the authority to proclaim the gospel, which includes the message of forgiveness. According to this interpretation, a person's sins are forgiven when they believe the gospel, not because a follower of Jesus proclaims them forgiven.

Ultimately, the interpretation of John 20:23 depends on one's understanding of the nature of Jesus' ministry and the role of his followers.

Only God can forgive sins

The concept of sin forgiveness is a highly debated topic among different Christian denominations. While some believe that only God can forgive sins, others argue that Jesus gave his followers the authority to forgive sins on his behalf.

The Bible states in Psalm 130:4, "But with you there is forgiveness," indicating that only God has the power to forgive sins. This view is supported by the fact that Jesus, being fully God and fully man, had the authority to forgive sins during his time on earth. However, as he is now in heaven, the power to forgive sins remains solely with God.

Jesus Gave Authority to Forgive Sins

On the other hand, it is argued that Jesus gave his followers the authority to forgive sins. In John 20:23, Jesus says, "If you forgive anyone's sins, their sins are forgiven; if you do not forgive them, they are not forgiven." This passage suggests that Jesus intended for his followers to have the power to forgive sins in his name. Additionally, in Matthew 28:18-20, Jesus says, "All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. Go, therefore, and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit." Here, Jesus grants his disciples the authority to continue his earthly work, which includes forgiving sins.

The Role of the Church

The Christian church, as the body of Christ, also plays a role in sin forgiveness. The Apostles' Creed states, "I believe in the Holy Spirit: the holy catholic church: the communion of saints: the forgiveness of sins." This suggests that the Holy Spirit works through the church to apply the forgiveness of sins. The church has the authority to represent Christ in forgiving or withholding forgiveness, often through the sacraments of baptism and Eucharist.

While there are differing interpretations, the underlying belief is that sin forgiveness is ultimately granted by God, whether directly or through the authority given to followers of Christ.

The Catholic Church's belief that a priest can forgive sins

However, this interpretation is disputed by some Christians, including Protestant Reformers like John Calvin, who argue that only God can forgive sins, and that Jesus was giving the apostles the authority to proclaim the gospel, not to forgive sins themselves. They point out that the Bible states that only God can forgive sins (Psalm 130:4) and that Jesus, as God, had the authority to forgive sins during his time on earth (Mark 2:10).

The Catholic Church responds to this objection by highlighting the distinction between God's ultimate authority to forgive sins and the role of priests as intermediaries. Priests, through the power of the Holy Spirit, stand in the place of Christ and declare the sinner forgiven. This is reflected in the Catholic formula of absolution, where the priest says, "I absolve you from your sins in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit."

Furthermore, the Catholic Church finds support for priestly authority to forgive sins in other biblical passages, such as James 5:14–15, which instructs the sick to call for the elders of the church to pray for them and forgive their sins. This passage is understood as a specific reference to the sacrament of penance and the sacrament of anointing of the sick, administered by priests.

Additionally, the Catholic Church emphasizes the importance of confession and absolution for the comfort and peace of the believer. While private confession is not considered necessary for forgiveness, it provides an opportunity for believers to hear that they are forgiven and experience the comfort and ease of mind that comes with it.

The Protestant view that only Jesus can forgive sins

In Mark 2:1–12, Jesus says to a paralytic, "Your sins are forgiven" (Mark 2:5). The scribes objected, saying, "Who can forgive sins except God alone?" (Mark 2:7). Jesus then performed a miracle, healing the paralytic to show that "the Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive sins" (Mark 2:10). This passage demonstrates Jesus' divinity and his authority to forgive sins as the Son of God.

In John 20:19–23, Jesus appeared to his disciples after his resurrection and said to them, "Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive anyone's sins, they are forgiven; if you do not forgive them, they are not forgiven" (John 20:22–23). Some Protestants interpret this passage to mean that Jesus gave his disciples, and by extension, all believers, the authority to forgive sins in his name. However, others argue that this authority is limited to proclaiming the gospel and does not include the power to forgive sins.

Protestants generally reject the idea that priests or ministers have the exclusive authority to forgive sins, as taught by the Catholic Church. They believe that Jesus gave this authority to all believers and that it is not limited to a select few. This is based on their interpretation of Jesus' commission to his disciples in Matthew 28:19-20, where he says, "go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit" (Matthew 28:19).

Ultimately, the Protestant view emphasizes the belief that Jesus is the only one who can truly forgive sins, and any authority given to humans is derived from him and is exercised in his name.

The role of the church in forgiving sins

The authority to forgive sins is a contentious issue among different Christian denominations. While some believe that only God can forgive sins, others argue that Jesus gave his followers the authority to forgive sins on his behalf. This debate centres around the interpretation of specific Bible passages, such as John 20:23, where Jesus says, "If you forgive anyone's sins, their sins are forgiven; if you do not forgive them, they are not forgiven."

The Catholic View

According to Catholic doctrine, priests have the power to forgive sins as Jesus passed on his authority to his apostles, who became the first priests of the Catholic Church. This is based on the belief that Jesus gave his priesthood to men so they could continue his earthly work of forgiving sins. This is supported by John 20:19–23, where Jesus says to his disciples, "Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained."

The Protestant View

Many Protestants disagree with the Catholic interpretation, arguing that Jesus was giving his followers the authority to proclaim the gospel, which includes the forgiveness of sins, rather than the power to forgive sins themselves. They believe that only Jesus, as God, has the innate ability to forgive sins. This view is supported by passages such as Mark 2:7, where Jesus says, "Who can forgive sins but God alone?", and John 14:12, where Jesus promises that his followers will do "greater things" than he did, implying that they have a different kind of authority.

The Lutheran View

Lutheranism takes a unique stance, asserting that ministers have the authority to forgive sins through the "Power of the Keys" given to the church by Jesus. This power is exercised publicly through ordained ministers, who act as representatives of Christ. However, Lutherans also believe that forgiveness is not dependent on ritual or specific words but on God's discretion.

The church plays a vital role in the forgiveness of sins according to Christian theology. While the specific interpretations vary, most Christians agree that the church is the body of Christ and, therefore, has the authority to represent Christ on earth. This includes the power to baptize, which is often seen as a symbol of forgiveness and a person's entry into the church community. The church also has the responsibility to maintain holiness and discipline among its members, which may include excluding unrepentant sinners from the congregation and restoring those who repent.

In conclusion, the role of the church in forgiving sins is complex and varies across different Christian denominations. While some believe that ministers have the authority to forgive sins, others argue that this power is reserved for God alone. Ultimately, the church serves as a representative of Christ on earth and plays a crucial role in facilitating the forgiveness of sins through sacraments like baptism and the proclamation of the gospel.

Frequently asked questions