Sexual Morality Sins: Lesser In Catholic Doctrine?

The Catholic Church teaches that there are two types of sin: mortal and venial. The mortal sins are those that involve a serious matter and full consent of the will, and they break our relationship with God. On the other hand, venial sins are those that are habitual, do not constitute a serious matter, or do not involve the full consent of the will. While the Catholic Church forbids sexual relations outside of marriage between an adult male and female, it does not consider sexual sins to be the worst kind of sin. In fact, Pope Francis has criticised priests who seem to fixate exclusively on sexual sins, arguing that there are other serious sins such as pride, arrogance, and social injustice that deserve equal attention. Similarly, C.S. Lewis asserts that while sexual sins are bad, they are the least bad of all sins, and that the worst pleasures are purely spiritual, such as the pleasure of putting others down or seeking power.

Homosexuality is a sin, but homosexual attraction is not

The Catholic Church's stance on homosexuality is complex and often contentious. According to Catholic doctrine, having same-sex attractions or homosexual desires is not considered a sin in itself. The Catechism of the Catholic Church states that homosexual persons "must be accepted with respect, compassion, and sensitivity" and that "every sign of unjust discrimination in their regard should be avoided".

However, the Church teaches that acting upon these desires by engaging in sexual activity with someone of the same sex is a grave sin against chastity. This is based on the belief that sexual intercourse has a twofold unitive and procreative purpose. The Catechism states that homosexual acts "violate natural law, cannot bring forth life, and do not proceed from a genuine affective and sexual complementarity".

The Church's teachings on this issue have evolved over time, influenced by papal interventions and theologians. While the Church does not perform or recognize sacramental marriages between same-sex couples, Pope Francis has taken a more inclusive approach than his predecessors. He became the first pope to support civil union status for same-sex couples and has publicly denounced sodomy laws.

In summary, while the Catholic Church considers homosexual behaviour a sin, it distinguishes this from homosexual attraction, which is not inherently sinful. The Church calls homosexual persons to chastity and encourages them to practice self-mastery and inner freedom with the support of the Church community.

The Catholic Church considers sex outside of marriage a grave sin

The Catechism of the Catholic Church outlines several transgressions and sins against chastity, including masturbation, fornication, pornography, and homosexual practices. Additionally, adultery, divorce, polygamy, and free union are considered grave offenses against the dignity of marriage. The Church's teachings on sexual morality are derived from natural law, canonical scripture, divine revelation, and sacred tradition, as interpreted by the Church's magisterium.

While some may argue that the Church overemphasizes sexual sins, others, including Pope Francis, have criticized priests who seem to fixate exclusively on these sins. The Pope has emphasized that the Church needs a profound conversion in this area, noting that there are other serious sins, such as pride, arrogance, social injustice, slander, gossip, and lies, that should also be addressed.

It is important to note that the Church does not consider all sexual sins to be equal. The degree of sinfulness can vary depending on the type and circumstances, with some sins considered mortal and others venial. Mortal sins are those that involve a serious matter and the full consent of the will, leading to a break in the relationship with God. Venial sins, on the other hand, are less serious and do not lead to spiritual death, but they can still harm one's relationship with God.

In conclusion, while the Catholic Church considers sex outside of marriage a grave sin, it is important to keep in perspective that there are other sins that are equally or even more serious in the eyes of the Church.

Sins of the flesh are considered the least bad of all sins

In Catholic theology, sins are divided into two categories: mortal and venial. Mortal sins are considered very serious, involving a serious matter, and full consent of the will. They break one's relationship with God and can lead to spiritual death and hell. Venial sins, on the other hand, are less serious, do not break one's relationship with God, and do not lead to spiritual death. However, they can easily lead to mortal sin when left unchecked.

When it comes to sexual sin, the Catholic Church's position is straightforward. It forbids sexual relations outside of marriage between an adult biological male and female. Any sexual activity outside of this context is considered sinful, including lust, voyeurism, masturbation, contraception, fornication, homosexuality, polygamy, and more. These activities are always considered sinful and require confession and repentance.

While the Catholic Church recognizes the seriousness of sexual sins, some theologians and clergy, including Pope Francis, have cautioned against an exclusive focus on these sins. They argue that other sins, such as pride, arrogance, social injustice, slander, and gossip, can be just as harmful and should not be overlooked. This perspective is reflected in the writings of C.S. Lewis, who asserted that "the sins of the flesh are bad, but they are the least bad of all sins." He further explained that there are two competing natures within humans: the Animal self and the Diabolical self, with the latter being worse as it involves spiritual sins.

Lewis' distinction between the Animal and Diabolical selves echoes the Catholic Church's understanding of the difference between sins of the flesh and spiritual sins. Sins of the flesh are those that arise from our lower, animal nature, such as indulging in inappropriate sexual behaviour. These sins often evoke feelings of shame and remorse, making them easier to repent. On the other hand, spiritual sins, like pride, are considered more dangerous because they are angelic sins that seek something above us. They can lead to a sense of self-righteousness and pride, making them more challenging to recognize and repent.

In conclusion, while sins of the flesh, including sexual sins, are considered serious transgressions in Catholic theology, they are not viewed as the worst sins. The Church cautions against an excessive focus on sexual sins while neglecting other harmful sins, such as pride and social injustice. This perspective aims to provide a more holistic understanding of sin and morality, recognizing that spiritual sins can be more subtle, deadly, and difficult to overcome.

Sexual sins are a gateway to greater spiritual sins

The Catholic Church's position on sexual sin is that sexual relations, of all kinds, are forbidden except between married heterosexual couples. The Church's teachings on sexual morality are drawn from "natural law", canonical scripture, divine revelation, and sacred tradition.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church lists several transgressions and sins against chastity, including masturbation, fornication, pornography, and homosexual practices. It also states that "adultery, divorce, polygamy, and free union are grave offenses against the dignity of marriage".

While the Church considers sexual sins to be grave matters, some Catholic theologians and clergy have argued that they are not as serious as spiritual sins, such as pride, arrogance, and dominion. This is because sexual sins are seen as being rooted in our lower, animal nature, while spiritual sins are considered more subtle and deadly as they are purely spiritual and seek something above us.

However, it is important to note that sexual sins can be a gateway to greater spiritual sins. For example, abortion may start with the inappropriate appeasement of sexual appetites, but it quickly becomes a matter of asserting one's own supposed well-being over that of the unborn child. Additionally, attachment to sexual sins can lead to self-centeredness and indifference to the human casualties caused by these actions.

In conclusion, while the Catholic Church considers sexual sins to be grave matters, they are not necessarily viewed as being more serious than spiritual sins. However, it is recognized that sexual sins can lead to greater spiritual sins, and thus they should not be taken lightly.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church lists several transgressions and sins against chastity

Lust is considered a disordered desire for or inordinate enjoyment of sexual pleasure. Sexual pleasure is deemed morally wrong when pursued for its own sake, isolated from its procreative and unitive goals. Masturbation is defined as the deliberate stimulation of the genital organs to derive sexual pleasure. The Catechism characterises masturbation as an "intrinsically and gravely disordered action," and it is regarded as a grave sin.

Pornography is also considered a grave offense, as it perverts the conjugal act and the intimate giving of spouses to each other. It is seen as causing grave harm to the dignity of its participants, reducing them to objects of base pleasure and illicit profit. Civil authorities are encouraged to prevent the production and distribution of pornographic materials.

Prostitution is another transgression against chastity, as it reduces the person to an instrument of sexual pleasure and violates the chastity pledged in baptism. It is considered a social scourge and a grave sin, although the imputability of the offense can be lessened by factors such as destitution, blackmail, or social pressure.

Other transgressions against chastity include fornication, adultery, divorce, polygamy, and free union. Fornication, or carnal union between an unmarried man and woman, is deemed gravely contrary to the dignity of persons and human sexuality. Adultery is defined as sexual relations between a married person and someone other than their spouse, violating the covenant of the marriage bond.

Frequently asked questions